屏障装置、插管与气溶胶防护策略:COVID-19时期的个人防护装备
该研究用生理学准确的咳嗽模拟器评估插管箱与透明塑料插管膜两种常用屏障装置对飞沫和气溶胶扩散的影响,用商用雾化机模拟气溶胶、荧光素染料模拟飞沫,并以高速闪光摄影定性评估。结果显示两种装置似可阻挡飞沫,但气溶胶可逸出屏障并向床头流动,移除屏障时滞留气溶胶被释放并冲向床头医护人员;无屏障时轻度反Trendelenburg位可使气溶胶远离床头医护人员。
要点
- 插管箱和插管膜可能减少飞沫暴露,但不能可靠阻挡气溶胶。
- 移除屏障时滞留的气溶胶会被释放并冲向床头的医护人员。
- 无屏障时轻度反Trendelenburg位可能使气溶胶远离床头医护人员。
核心结论
- 插管箱和插管膜可能减少医护人员对飞沫的暴露,但二者可能只是改变气溶胶的流向,在某些情况下反而增加气溶胶暴露。
- 咳嗽后气溶胶可能滞留在屏障装置内,操作插管箱可能使其释放。
- 新型屏障装置应谨慎使用,仍需进一步验证研究。
研究设计与样本
- 采用生理学准确的咳嗽模拟器,在模拟插管环境中评估插管箱和透明塑料插管膜两种常用屏障装置。
- 气溶胶用商用雾化机模拟,飞沫用荧光素染料模拟,由咳嗽模拟器驱动。
- 数据通过高速闪光摄影采集,对有无屏障时的气溶胶和飞沫扩散进行定性评估。
主要发现
- 模拟咳嗽后的飞沫污染似乎被两种屏障装置所阻挡。
- 模拟气溶胶逸出屏障并向床头方向流动。
- 移除屏障时,滞留在其下方的模拟气溶胶被释放并冲向床头的医护人员。
- 使用插管膜使飞沫集中在较小区域。
- 未使用屏障时,将患者置于轻度反Trendelenburg位可使气溶胶远离位于床头的医护人员。
临床怎么用
- 插管箱和插管膜不应被视为气溶胶的可靠屏障,使用时应配合其他防护措施。
- 移除屏障装置时需警惕滞留气溶胶释放,注意操作方式与人员防护。
- 无屏障条件下可考虑轻度反Trendelenburg位以使气溶胶远离床头医护人员。
- 新型屏障装置应谨慎使用,等待进一步验证。
局限性
- 气溶胶与飞沫扩散均为定性评估,采用雾化机与荧光素染料模拟,非真实病毒或临床环境。
- 原文未报告样本量、定量数值或统计学比较。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Numerous barrier devices have recently been developed and rapidly deployed worldwide in an effort to protect health care workers (HCWs) from exposure to coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) during high-risk procedures. However, only a few studies have examined their impact on the dispersion of droplets and aerosols, which are both thought to be significant contributors to the spread of COVID-19. METHODS: Two commonly used barrier devices, an intubation box and a clear plastic intubation sheet, were evaluated using a physiologically accurate cough simulator. Aerosols were modeled using a commercially available fog machine, and droplets were modeled with fluorescein dye. Both particles were propelled by the cough simulator in a simulated intubation environment. Data were captured by high-speed flash photography, and aerosol and droplet dispersion were assessed qualitatively with and without a barrier in place. RESULTS: Droplet contamination after a simulated cough was seemingly contained by both barrier devices. Simulated aerosol escaped the barriers and flowed toward the head of the bed. During barrier removal, simulated aerosol trapped underneath was released and propelled toward the HCW at the head of the bed. Usage of the intubation sheet concentrated droplets onto a smaller area. If no barrier was used, positioning the patient in slight reverse Trendelenburg directed aerosols away from the HCW located at the head of the bed. CONCLUSIONS: Our observations imply that intubation boxes and sheets may reduce HCW exposure to droplets, but they both may merely redirect aerosolized particles, potentially resulting in increased exposure to aerosols in certain circumstances. Aerosols may remain within the barrier device after a cough, and manipulation of the box may release them. Patients should be positioned to facilitate intubation, but slight reverse Trendelenburg may direct infectious aerosols away from the HCW. Novel barrier devices should be used with caution, and further validation studies are necessary.
引用
- Fried EA, Zhou G, Shah R, et al. Barrier Devices, Intubation, and Aerosol Mitigation Strategies: Personal Protective Equipment in the Time of Coronavirus Disease 2019. Anesth Analg. 2020. PMID: 33315602. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000005249
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。