氯普鲁卡因与利多卡因复合液用于择期剖宫产硬膜外延伸麻醉的比较:随机三盲非劣效研究
单中心随机三盲非劣效试验纳入70例健康足月产妇,比较3%氯普鲁卡因(CP)与2%利多卡因+150μg肾上腺素+2mL 8.4%碳酸氢钠+100μg芬太尼(LEBF)将硬膜外分娩镇痛延伸为剖宫产麻醉的效果。主要结局为T7触觉消失时间,非劣效界值3分钟;CP组平均655秒,LEBF组558秒,均值差97秒(90%CI -10.6至204),90%CI上限超过3分钟界值,未能证实CP非劣效。
要点
- CP与LEBF均能快速将低浓度硬膜外感觉阻滞延伸至外科麻醉水平
- CP组T7触觉消失时间均值655秒,LEBF组558秒,均值差97秒
- 90%CI上限204秒超过预设3分钟非劣效界值,非劣效性未证实
核心结论
- 两种局麻药液均可快速将低剂量硬膜外感觉阻滞延伸为剖宫产外科麻醉。
- 现有数据不足以证实CP在快速硬膜外延伸麻醉中非劣效于LEBF,需进一步研究。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心随机三盲非劣效试验,纳入70例接受剖宫产的健康成年产妇,随机分为CP组或LEBF组。
- 入手术室前已建立T10针刺感觉阻滞,入室后按标准化方式给予研究药物以模拟硬膜外分娩镇痛向外科麻醉的转换。
- 主要结局为T7水平触觉消失时间,非劣效界值设为3分钟;次要结局为术中是否需要追加镇痛。
主要发现
- CP组T7双侧触觉阻滞平均起效时间655秒(SD=258),LEBF组558秒(SD=269)。
- 两组术中追加镇痛需求无有意义的差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 非劣效界值:3分钟。
- 主要结局T7触觉消失时间:CP组655秒(SD=258),LEBF组558秒(SD=269),均值差97秒(90%CI -10.6至204)。
- LEBF配方:2%利多卡因+150μg肾上腺素+2mL 8.4%碳酸氢钠+100μg芬太尼。
- CP浓度:3%。
临床怎么用
- CP与LEBF均可用于将硬膜外分娩镇痛快速延伸为剖宫产麻醉,起效均较快。
- 因非劣效性未证实,不能依据本研究断言CP不劣于LEBF,选择时需结合其他证据与临床条件。
局限性
- 样本量70例,可能不足以确证非劣效性。
- 单中心研究,外推性受限。
- 研究模拟择期剖宫产情境,未直接针对紧急产时剖宫产。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: For emergent intrapartum cesarean delivery (CD), the literature does not support the use of any particular local anesthetic solution to extend epidural analgesia to cesarean anesthesia. We hypothesized that 3% chloroprocaine (CP) would be noninferior to a mixture of 2% lidocaine, 150 µg of epinephrine, 2 mL of 8.4% bicarbonate, and 100 µg of fentanyl (LEBF) in terms of onset time to surgical anesthesia. METHODS: In this single-center randomized noninferiority trial, adult healthy women undergoing CD were randomly assigned to epidural anesthesia with either CP or LEBF. Sensory blockade (pinprick) to T10 was established before operating room (OR) entry for elective CD. On arrival to the OR, participants received the epidural study medications in a standardized manner to simulate the conversion of "epidural labor analgesia to surgical anesthesia." The primary outcome was the time to loss of touch sensation at the T7 level. A noninferiority margin was set at 3 minutes. The secondary outcome was the need for intraoperative analgesia supplementation. RESULTS: In total, 70 women were enrolled in the study. The mean onset time to achieve a bilateral sensory block to touch at the T7 dermatome level was 655 (standard deviation [SD] = 258) seconds for group CP and 558 (269) seconds for group LEBF, a difference in means of 97 seconds (90% confidence interval [CI], SD = -10.6 to 204; P = .10 for noninferiority). The upper limit of the 90% CI for the mean difference exceeded the prespecified 3-minute noninferiority margin. There was no meaningful difference in the requirement for intraoperative analgesia between the 2 groups. CONCLUSION: Both anesthetic solutions have a rapid onset of anesthesia when used to extend low-dose epidural sensory block to surgical anesthesia. Data from the current study provide insufficient evidence to confirm that CP is noninferior to LEBF for rapid epidural extension anesthesia for CD, and further research is required to determine noninferiority.
引用
- Sharawi N, Bansal P, Williams M, et al. Comparison of Chloroprocaine Versus Lidocaine With Epinephrine, Sodium Bicarbonate, and Fentanyl for Epidural Extension Anesthesia in Elective Cesarean Delivery: A Randomized, Triple-Blind, Noninferiority Study. Anesth Analg. 2021. PMID: 32852294. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000005141
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。