文献速递气道管理

Macintosh视频喉镜用于手术室插管:一项比较性质量改进项目

Macintosh Videolaryngoscope for Intubation in the Operating Room: A Comparative Quality Improvement Project.
PubMed 文献 · Anesth Analg · 2021-01-01

该质量改进项目在手术室比较了4种Macintosh视频喉镜(McGrath-Mac、C-MAC-S、C-MAC-S-PM、APA)在直接和间接喉镜下的插管表现,主要终点为需改用高角度镜片。2017年5-9月共纳入589例患者,McGrath-Mac组需改用高角度镜片比例(12%)显著低于C-MAC-S(30%)和APA(25%),插管尝试次数也更少。

要点

  • McGrath-Mac组需改用高角度镜片比例最低(12%),优于C-MAC-S和APA。
  • McGrath-Mac组插管尝试次数显著少于C-MAC-S和C-MAC-S-PM组。
  • McGrath-Mac主观困难度更低、易用性更高,但图像质量评分低于C-MAC-S和C-MAC-S-PM。

核心结论

  • 在4种一次性Macintosh视频喉镜中,McGrath-Mac在直接和间接喉镜下声门视野改善最显著,需改用高角度镜片更少,插管尝试次数更少。

研究设计与样本

  • 质量改进项目,纳入2017年5月至9月589例手术室插管患者,比较4种Macintosh视频喉镜(McGrath-Mac、C-MAC-S、C-MAC-S-PM、APA)。

主要发现

  • McGrath-Mac组插管尝试次数显著少于C-MAC-S和C-MAC-S-PM组。
  • McGrath-Mac组插管困难度NRS评分更低、易用性NRS评分更高;C-MAC-S和C-MAC-S-PM图像质量评分高于APA和McGrath-Mac。

临床怎么用

  • 在手术室使用Macintosh视频喉镜时,McGrath-Mac可减少高角度镜片的使用需求和插管尝试次数,但图像质量主观评分略低。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: "Macintosh"-videolaryngoscopes (VLs) are VLs that allow both direct and indirect laryngoscopy for intubation. We describe the decision-making and implementation-processes that our hospital used regarding the choice of device. We compared the performances of 4 Macintosh-VLs both in direct and indirect laryngoscopy. METHODS: A quality-improvement-project for airway management aiming at implementing Macintosh-VL for all intubation procedures performed in the operating room, involving 4 Macintosh-VLs (McGrath-Mac, C-MAC-S, C-MAC-S-Pocket-Monitor [PM], and APA). Three consecutive steps were described: (1) direct laryngoscopy with Macintosh-VL, (2) indirect laryngoscopy with Macintosh-VL (intubation attempt with Macintosh-style blade in case of Cormack I or II), (3) intubation attempt with hyperangulated blade in case of Cormack III/IV or failure of Macintosh-style blade. The main end point was the need to move to step III and use a hyperangulated blade. A mixed-effects multivariable logistic regression analysis was performed to compare devices on the main end point while considering site as a random effect. Comparison of means was performed using analysis of variance and Tukey's test for multiple comparisons (number of laryngoscopy attempts, numeric rate scale [NRS] difficulty of intubation and NRS user-friendliness). Comparison of percentages was performed using a χ2 test for the need to move to step III and a Kruskal-Wallis test for the quality of image (bad, passable, good, very good, excellent). A P value ≤.008 was considered statistically significant. RESULTS: From May to September 2017, 589 patients were included. Using the McGrath-Mac (22/180 [12%]) was associated with less use of hyperangulated blade than using the C-MAC-S (39/132 [30%], odds ratio [OR] [99.2% confidence interval {CI}] 0.34 [0.16-0.77], P = .0005), the APA (35/138 [25%], OR [99.2% CI] 0.42 [0.19-0.93]; P = .004), but not the C-MAC-S-PM (29/139 [21%], OR [99.2% CI] 0.53 [0.23-1.2]; P = .04).Overall, the number of intubation attempts was significantly lower using the McGrath Mac than the C-MAC-S or the C-MAC-S-PMVLs. Subjective appreciation of intubation difficulty and user-friendliness of the devices showed respectively lower and higher NRS scores for the McGrath-Mac compared to the other devices, whereas subjective assessment of image quality showed higher quality for the C-MAC-S and C-MAC-S-PM compared to the APA or McGrath-Mac. CONCLUSIONS: Among 4 single-use Macintosh-VLs, glottic visualization in direct and indirect laryngoscopy with the Macintosh-style blade was significantly improved with the McGrath-Mac compared to other Macintosh-VLs, leading to a less frequent need to resort to the hyperangulated blade and reduced overall number of intubation attempts.

来源:Anesth Analg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. De Jong A, Pouzeratte Y, Laplace A, et al. Macintosh Videolaryngoscope for Intubation in the Operating Room: A Comparative Quality Improvement Project. Anesth Analg. 2021. PMID: 32739955. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000005031

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。