低成本3D打印智能手机兼容Tansen视频喉镜与Pentax-AWS及Macintosh直接喉镜在困难气道模型中的性能测试
TVL在插管成功率、声门视野分级和插管时间上不劣于Pentax-AWS,且优于Macintosh;但Pentax-AWS的主观易用性评分更高。
要点
- TVL在困难气道模型中的插管成功率、视野分级和插管时间不劣于Pentax-AWS,优于Macintosh。
- Pentax-AWS的主观易用性评分优于TVL,TVL优于Macintosh。
- TVL成本低、可重复使用,适合资源有限环境。
核心结论
- 在困难气道模型模拟中,TVL在插管成功率、声门视野分级和插管时间上不劣于Pentax-AWS视频喉镜,且优于Macintosh直接喉镜。
- 参与者认为Pentax设备更易使用,其反馈为改进TVL提供了见解。
- TVL成本低、简单且可重复使用,适合资源有限的环境。
研究设计与样本
- 模型研究,使用困难气道模型(SimMan3G,舌完全充气,颈硬)。
主要发现
- 总体插管成功率:TVL 88% vs. Pentax-AWS 98% vs. Macintosh 67%(P < 0.05)。
- 声门视野分级(中位Cormack-Lehane分级):TVL 1 vs. Pentax-AWS 1 vs. Macintosh 3(P < 0.01)。
- 中位插管时间:TVL 17.5 s vs. Pentax-AWS 15.5 s vs. Macintosh 27 s(P < 0.01)。
- 主观易用性评分(Likert型1-5分):Pentax-AWS 4 vs. TVL 4 vs. Macintosh 1(P < 0.00001)。
临床怎么用
- TVL可作为资源有限环境下困难气道管理的低成本替代方案。
- TVL在插管成功率和时间上不劣于商用视频喉镜Pentax-AWS,但易用性稍差。
局限性
- 研究为模型模拟,非临床患者。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: While videolaryngoscopes help in the management of difficult airways, they remain too expensive for those with limited resources. We have developed a robust, re-usable, low-cost videolaryngoscope at United Mission Hospital Tansen, Nepal, by combining a smartphone-compatible endoscope capable of capturing still and video images with a three dimensional-printed, channelled, hyperangulated blade. The computer-aided design file for the videolaryngoscope blade was emailed and printed in London before evaluation of its performance on a difficult airway manikin. OBJECTIVE: To benchmark the intubation performance of the Tansen Videolaryngoscope (TVL) in a 'difficult airway' manikin (SimMan3G, tongue fully inflated, neck stiff), against a commercially available videolaryngoscope and a conventional Macintosh laryngoscope. DESIGN: A manikin study. SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: Forty-three experienced videolaryngoscope users in two London teaching hospitals. INTERVENTION AND OUTCOME: Primary outcome: Intubation success rate. SECONDARY OUTCOMES: grade of laryngeal view, median time to intubation and intubator-rated 'ease of use'. RESULTS: Our device was equivalent to Pentax-AWS and superior to Macintosh laryngoscope (TVL vs. Pentax-AWS vs. Macintosh) in overall intubation success rate (88 vs. 98 vs. 67%, P < 0.05); grade of view (median Cormack-Lehane grade 1 vs. 1 vs. 3, P < 0.01); median time to intubation (17.5 vs. 15.5 vs. 27 s, P < 0.01). In subjective 'ease of use' scores, Pentax-AWS was superior to the TVL, which was superior to Macintosh laryngoscope (Likert-type 1 to 5 scale: 4 vs. 4 vs. 1, P < 0.00001). CONCLUSION: In this manikin simulation of a difficult airway, the 'TVL' was superior to the Macintosh laryngoscope, and noninferior to the Pentax-AWS videolaryngoscope in intubation success rate, grade of laryngeal view and time to intubation. Participants found the Pentax device easier to use, and their feedback has given us valuable insights for improving our device. The TVL is well suited to settings in which resources are limited, being inexpensive, simple and re-usable.
引用
- Lambert CT, John SC, John AV, et al. Development and performance testing of the low-cost, 3D-printed, smartphone-compatible 'Tansen Videolaryngoscope' vs. Pentax-AWS videolaryngoscope vs. direct Macintosh laryngoscope: A manikin study. Eur J Anaesthesiol. 2020. PMID: 32675700. doi:10.1097/EJA.0000000000001264
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。