程序化间歇硬膜外推注与患者自控硬膜外镇痛用于分娩镇痛维持的比较:双中心双盲随机研究
该双中心双盲随机对照研究纳入130名初产妇,比较程序化间歇硬膜外推注(PIEB)与无背景输注的患者自控硬膜外镇痛(PCEA)维持分娩镇痛的效果。PIEB组爆发痛发生率显著低于PCEA组(10.9% vs 62.3%,p<0.0001),运动阻滞发生率也更低(1.6% vs 13.1%,p=0.015),但局麻药消耗量更大。患者满意度和产科新生儿结局无差异。
要点
- PIEB较无背景输注的PCEA显著降低爆发痛发生率(10.9% vs 62.3%)。
- PIEB组运动阻滞(改良Bromage评分≤4)发生率更低(1.6% vs 13.1%)。
- PIEB组局麻药消耗量更大但PCEA推注次数更少,满意度无差异。
核心结论
- 采用10ml程序化推注联合5ml PCEA推注的PIEB技术优于采用5ml推注且无背景输注的PCEA技术。
研究设计与样本
- 双中心、双盲、随机对照试验,共招募130名接受初始脊髓镇痛的初产妇。
- 硬膜外镇痛使用0.12%罗哌卡因复合0.75 µg·ml-1舒芬太尼维持。
- PIEB组每小时程序化推注10ml,PCEA按需推注5ml,锁定时间20分钟。
- PCEA组推注5ml,锁定时间12分钟,无背景输注;两组每小时潜在最大容积相同。
主要发现
- PIEB组爆发痛(需麻醉医生追加剂量)发生率为7例(10.9%),PCEA组为38例(62.3%),p<0.0001。
- 运动阻滞(改良Bromage评分≤4)发生率PIEB组1例(1.6%),PCEA组8例(13.1%),p=0.015。
- PIEB组局麻药消耗量更大,PCEA推注次数更少。
- 患者满意度评分及产科、新生儿结局两组间无差异。
临床怎么用
- 分娩镇痛维持可优先考虑PIEB方案(10ml/h程序化推注联合5ml PCEA推注,锁定20分钟),以降低爆发痛和运动阻滞。
- 采用PIEB时需注意局麻药消耗量可能增加。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The programmed intermittent epidural bolus technique has shown superiority to continuous epidural infusion techniques, with or without patient-controlled epidural analgesia for pain relief, reduced motor block and patient satisfaction. Many institutions still use patient-controlled epidural analgesia without a background infusion, and a comparative study between programmed intermittent epidural bolus and patient-controlled epidural analgesia without a background infusion has not yet been performed. We performed a randomised, two-centre, double-blind, controlled trial of these two techniques. The primary outcome was the incidence of breakthrough pain requiring a top-up dose by an anaesthetist. Secondary outcomes included: motor block; pain scores; patient satisfaction; local anaesthetic consumption; and obstetric and neonatal outcomes. We recruited 130 nulliparous women who received initial spinal analgesia, and then epidural analgesia was initiated and maintained with either programmed intermittent epidural bolus or patient-controlled epidural analgesia using ropivacaine 0.12% with sufentanil 0.75 µg·ml-1 . The programmed intermittent epidural bolus group had a programmed bolus of 10 ml every hour, with on-demand patient-controlled epidural analgesia boluses of 5 ml with a 20 min lockout, and the patient-controlled epidural analgesia group had a 5 ml bolus with a 12 min lockout interval; the potential maximum volume per hour was the same in both groups. The patients in the programmed intermittent epidural bolus group had less frequent breakthrough pain compared with the patient-controlled epidural analgesia group, 7 (10.9%) vs. 38 (62.3%; p < 0.0001), respectively. There was a significant difference in motor block (modified Bromage score ≤ 4) frequency between groups, programmed intermittent epidural bolus group 1 (1.6%) vs. patient-controlled epidural analgesia group 8 (13.1%); p = 0.015. The programmed intermittent epidural bolus group had greater local anaesthetic consumption with fewer patient-controlled epidural analgesia boluses. Patient satisfaction scores and obstetric or neonatal outcomes were not different between groups. In conclusion, we found that a programmed intermittent epidural bolus technique using 10 ml programmed boluses and 5 ml patient-controlled epidural analgesia boluses was superior to a patient-controlled epidural analgesia technique using 5 ml boluses and no background infusion.
引用
- Roofthooft E, Barbé A, Schildermans J, et al. Programmed intermittent epidural bolus vs. patient-controlled epidural analgesia for maintenance of labour analgesia: a two-centre, double-blind, randomised study†. Anaesthesia. 2020. PMID: 32530518. doi:10.1111/anae.15149
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。