学术麻醉科手术麻醉生产率的全行业调查基准数据
该研究通过SAAAPM成员调查,收集140家机构12个月的手术麻醉生产率数据,以ASA单位衡量。结果显示,学术医学中心与儿童医院每麻醉站点总ASA单位中位数相似(12592 vs 12364),门诊手术中心最低(8911)。研究为学术麻醉科提供了设施层面的基准数据。
要点
- 学术医学中心与儿童医院每站点生产率中位数相近,门诊手术中心最低。
- 小型机构(<10站点)总体生产率中位数低于大型机构。
- 学术医学中心和儿童医院中超过20%的站点为非手术室麻醉站点。
核心结论
- 学术麻醉科需要设施层面的基准数据以进行数据驱动的生产率决策。
- 本调查提供了学术麻醉科手术麻醉生产率的现行基准数据。
研究设计与样本
- 对SAAAPM成员进行问卷调查,收集设施类型、人员配置、麻醉站点数及12个月计费ASA单位和病例数。
- 共63名成员提交140家设施的完整调查数据,包括69家学术医学中心、26家社区医院、7家儿童医院和38家门诊手术中心。
主要发现
- 学术医学中心和儿童医院每麻醉站点总ASA单位中位数分别为12592和12364,门诊手术中心为8911。
- 小型设施(<10站点)的总体生产率中位数低于大型设施。
- 学术医学中心和儿童医院中超过20%的麻醉站点为非手术室麻醉站点。
- 麻醉住院医师主要在学术医学中心和儿童医院工作;门诊手术中心和社区医院中分别仅18%和35%的设施有住院医师工作。
- 超过一半的学术医学中心报告每日至少1名休息认证注册麻醉护士(CRNA)。
临床怎么用
- 麻醉科领导者可利用这些基准数据在设施层面进行有意义的比较。
- 在多设施提供医疗服务的团队可进行内部比较并追踪测量指标随时间的变化。
- 领导者可将本机构设施与行业整体测量值比较,即进行基准对标。
局限性
- 调查仅纳入使用ASA单位计费的麻醉服务,排除产科麻醉及未计费或使用相对价值单位(RVU)计费的服务。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Benchmarking group surgical anesthesia productivity continues to be an important but challenging goal for anesthesiology groups. Benchmarking is important because it provides objective data to evaluate staffing needs and costs, identify potential operating room management decisions that could reduce costs or improve efficiency, and support ongoing negotiations and discussions with health system leadership. Unfortunately, good and meaningful benchmarking data are not readily available. Therefore, a survey of academic anesthesiology departments was done to provide current benchmarking data. METHODS: A survey of members of the Society of Academic Associations of Anesthesiology and Perioperative Medicine (SAAAPM) was performed. The survey collected data by facility and included type of facility, number and type of staff and anesthetizing sites each weekday, and the billed American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) units and number of cases over 12 months. The facility types included academic medical center (AMC), community hospital (Community), children's hospital (Children), and ambulatory surgical center (ASC). All anesthesia care billed using ASA units were included, except for obstetric anesthesia. Any care not billed or billed using relative value units (RVUs) were excluded. Percentage of nonoperating room anesthetizing sites, staffing ratio, and surgical anesthesia productivity measurements "per case" and "per site" were calculated. RESULTS: Of the 135 society members, 63 submitted complete surveys for 140 facilities (69 AMC, 26 Community, 7 Children, and 38 ASC). In the survey, overall median productivity for AMC and Children was similar (12,592 and 12,364 total ASA units per anesthetizing site), while the ASC had the lowest median overall productivity (8911 total ASA units per anesthetizing site). By size of facility, in the survey, the smaller facilities (<10 sites, ASC or non-ASC) had lower median overall productivity as compared to larger facilities. For AMC and Children, >20% of anesthetizing sites were nonoperating room anesthetizing sites. Anesthesiology residents worked primarily in AMC and Children. In ASC and Community, residents worked only in 18% and 35% of facilities, respectively. More than half the AMCs reported at least 1 break certified nurse anesthetist (CRNA) each day. CONCLUSIONS: To make data-driven decisions on clinical productivity, anesthesiology leaders need to be able to make meaningful comparisons at the facility level. For a group that provides care in multiple facilities, one can make internal comparisons among facilities and follow measurements over time. It is valuable for leaders to also be compare their facilities with industry-wide measurements, in other words, benchmark their facilities. These results provide benchmarking data for academic anesthesiology departments.
引用
- Abouleish AE, Hudson ME, Levy RS, et al. Industry-Wide Survey of Academic Anesthesiology Departments Provides Up-to-Date Benchmarking Data on Surgical Anesthesia Productivity. Anesth Analg. 2020. PMID: 32541253. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000004934
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。