硬膜外与腹横肌平面阻滞用于腹部手术:系统评价、荟萃分析与试验序贯分析
该系统评价纳入18项随机对照试验共1220例患者,比较硬膜外镇痛与腹横肌平面阻滞的镇痛效果与副作用。硬膜外组静息12小时疼痛评分平均降低0.69分(95%CI 0.12-1.27,p=0.02),证据质量低;24小时无差异。硬膜外组0-24小时静脉吗啡当量消耗减少5.91 mg(95%CI 2.34-9.49,p=0.001),但72小时低血压风险比5.88(95%CI 2.08-16.67,p<0.001)。作者认为两者临床无差异。
要点
- 硬膜外镇痛较腹横肌平面阻滞降低12小时静息疼痛评分0.69分,但低于最小临床重要差异。
- 硬膜外组0-24小时静脉吗啡当量消耗减少5.91 mg,但72小时低血压风险增加(RR 5.88)。
- 选择镇痛方式需权衡硬膜外的镇痛获益与低血压风险,证据确定性不一。
核心结论
- 硬膜外镇痛与腹横肌平面阻滞在腹部手术后疼痛评分上无临床重要差异。
- 硬膜外镇痛减少24小时内静脉吗啡当量消耗,但增加72小时低血压风险。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价、荟萃分析与试验序贯分析,纳入18项随机对照试验共1220例患者。
主要发现
- 硬膜外组静息12小时疼痛评分平均降低0.69分(95%CI 0.12-1.27,p=0.02),证据质量低。
- 静息24小时疼痛评分无差异,证据质量极低。
- 硬膜外组0-24小时静脉吗啡当量消耗平均减少5.91 mg(95%CI 2.34-9.49,p=0.001)。
- 硬膜外组72小时低血压风险比5.88(95%CI 2.08-16.67,p<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 硬膜外镇痛在12小时疼痛控制上略有优势但未达临床重要差异,需权衡低血压风险。
- 腹横肌平面阻滞虽增加24小时吗啡消耗,但降低72小时低血压风险。
局限性
- 存在检测偏倚与实施偏倚、显著统计学异质性和发表偏倚。
- 证据质量低至极低,估计值不确定性高。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Traditionally, pain relief for abdominal surgery has centred on epidural analgesia, but transversus abdominis plane block is increasingly being used. Our aim was to compare the analgesic efficacy and the side-effect profile of transversus abdominis plane block with epidural analgesia in a systematic review with meta-analysis and trial sequential analysis. After a systematic search of the electronic databases, we identified 18 randomised controlled trials with 1220 patients. Confirmed by trial sequential analysis, our first co-primary outcome, postoperative pain score at rest at 12 h, was decreased by a mean difference (95%CI) of 0.69 (0.12-1.27; p = 0.02) with epidural analgesia compared with transversus abdominis plane block, with the quality of evidence graded as low. No difference was found for the second co-primary outcome, postoperative pain score at rest at 24 h, with the quality of evidence rated as very low. Relative to transversus abdominis plane block, epidural analgesia further reduced the need for intravenous morphine-equivalent consumption during the 0-24 h interval by a mean difference (95%CI) of 5.91 mg (2.34-9.49; p = 0.001) at the expense of an increased incidence of hypotension at 72 h, with a risk ratio (95%CI) of 5.88 (2.08-16.67; p < 0.001). Our meta-analysis was limited by detection and performance bias, significant statistical heterogeneity and publication bias. In view of the minimal clinically important difference in postoperative pain scores, epidural analgesia was interpreted to not be clinically different to transversus abdominis plane block after abdominal surgery. With transversus abdominis plane block, the increase in intravenous morphine-equivalent consumption at 24 h should be balanced against the decreased risk of hypotension at 72 h. In choosing between epidural analgesia and transversus abdominis plane block, potential benefits should be balanced against the reported risk of harm, although the confidence in the evidence varied, underlining the uncertainty in our estimates.
引用
- Desai N, El-Boghdadly K, Albrecht E, et al. Epidural vs. transversus abdominis plane block for abdominal surgery - a systematic review, meta-analysis and trial sequential analysis. Anaesthesia. 2020. PMID: 32385856. doi:10.1111/anae.15068
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。