神经轴麻醉中肌松药误用的临床与人为因素分析
该综述检索1965至2019年文献,纳入20例经椎管内误用肌松药(NMBDs)的报告,涉及7种药物。硬膜外罗库溴铵和琥珀胆碱起效延迟,硬膜外维库溴铵、泮库溴铵、顺阿曲库铵和琥珀胆碱作用延长;5例需紧急气道干预;注射器换错是主要原因,感知错误最常见。
要点
- 椎管内误用肌松药可导致全身神经肌肉阻滞,硬膜外给药起效延迟、作用延长。
- 注射器换错是主要错误原因,感知错误最常见,实施推荐措施可能预防错误。
- 当前常用肌松药椎管内给药后未报告严重并发症,但需紧急气道干预。
核心结论
- 硬膜外注射肌松药后效应延迟且延长,当前常用肌松药椎管内给药未报告严重并发症。
- 感知错误导致注射器选择错误是最常见原因,可采取四项措施减少此类错误。
研究设计与样本
- 综述,检索1965至2019年发表的椎管内误用肌松药的人类错误报告,不限语言,排除非椎管内错误。
- 共纳入20篇报告,涉及7种不同肌松药经硬膜外或鞘内误用。
主要发现
- 硬膜外罗库溴铵和琥珀胆碱起效延迟;硬膜外维库溴铵、泮库溴铵、顺阿曲库铵和琥珀胆碱作用延长。
- 5例患者需要紧急气道干预;鞘内加拉碘铵引起惊厥和肌肉痉挛向身体上部蔓延。
- 注射器换错是大多数错误的主要原因,感知错误最常见。
临床怎么用
- 临床中应警惕椎管内误用肌松药的可能,尤其注意注射器换错和感知错误。
- 实施推荐的四项措施可能减少此类错误。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Drug errors during neuraxial anaesthesia or analgesia are not well known. OBJECTIVES: To review the clinical consequences associated with incorrect administration of neuromuscular blocking drugs (NMBDs) during spinal or epidural anaesthesia, and to investigate human factors and strategies available to help prevent such errors. DESIGN: A review of reports of neuraxial administration of NMBDs in humans. DATA SOURCES: Published reports of errors involving NMBDs. We searched the period between 1965 and 2019. ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA: Error reports in any language. Nonneuraxial drug errors were excluded. RESULTS: We identified 20 reports involving seven different NMBDs inadvertently administered via the epidural or intrathecal routes. All patients developed systemic neuromuscular junction blockade. Fourteen errors occurred while patients were awake. The onset of action was delayed following epidural rocuronium and suxamethonium. The duration of action was prolonged following epidural administration of vecuronium, pancuronium, cisatracrium and suxamethonium. Five patients required emergency airway interventions. Intrethecal gallamine caused convulsions and muscle spasms migrating up the body. Syringe swap was the primary cause for the majority of errors and perceptual errors were the most common. Implementation of recommendations could have prevented the errors. CONCLUSION: Following the epidural injection of NMBDs the effects are delayed and prolonged. There was no serious morbidity reported following neuraxial administration of the NMBDs used in current practice. Perceptual errors resulting in incorrect syringe choice were the commonest cause. Four measures can be introduced to reduce such errors.
引用
- Patel S. Erroneous neuraxial administration of neuromuscular blocking drugs: Clinical and human factors analysis. Eur J Anaesthesiol. 2020. PMID: 32371827. doi:10.1097/EJA.0000000000001232
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。