产科麻醉质量改进关键指标的识别:OAA/NPEU协作Delphi项目
该三阶段Delphi调查邀请133名利益相关者(80%完成全部阶段),从31项质量指标中筛选出11项被至少两个专家组>90%参与者评为极其重要,最终投票选出5项用于产科麻醉质量评估与基准比对。
要点
- 5项关键指标涵盖硬膜外镇痛意外穿破硬脊膜率、产前转诊指南、择期剖宫产专用手术列表、血红蛋白即时检测及45分钟内镇痛达标率。
- 指标可用于质量改进和国家基准比对,支持产科麻醉质量标准实施。
- 多利益相关者参与(产科麻醉医师、其他产科保健人员、产妇)确保指标相关性。
核心结论
- 从31项初始质量指标中确定5项关键指标,用于产科麻醉质量改进与国家基准比对。
研究设计与样本
- 三阶段Delphi调查,133名利益相关者注册,80%完成全部三个阶段;参与者分为产科麻醉医师、其他产科保健人员和产妇三个专家组。
主要发现
- 初始31项质量指标中,11项被至少两个专家组>90%参与者评为极其重要。
- 最终投票选出的5项指标为:硬膜外/腰硬联合分娩镇痛意外穿破硬脊膜百分比、产前麻醉转诊指南存在性、择期剖宫产专用手术列表、血红蛋白即时检测可用性、硬膜外置入开始后45分钟内充分镇痛百分比。
关键数值与推荐
- 11项指标被至少两个专家组>90%参与者评为极其重要。
- 最终5项指标由利益相关者投票选出,用于评估和基准比对产科麻醉质量。
临床怎么用
- 可将5项指标用于产科麻醉质量改进和国家基准比对,支持质量标准实施。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
A three-stage Delphi survey process was undertaken to identify the quality indicators considered the most relevant to obstetric anaesthesia. The initial quality indicators assessed were derived from national peer-reviewed publications and were divided into service provision, service quality and clinical outcomes. A range of stakeholders were invited to participate and divided into three panels: obstetric anaesthetists; other maternity care health professionals; and women who had used maternity services. In total, 133 stakeholders registered to participate with 80% completing all three phases of the survey process. Participants ranked indicators for their relative importance using the grading of recommendations assessment, development and evaluation scale. From an initial list of 31 quality indicators, 11 indicators were rated as extremely important by > 90% of participants in at least two panels. These 11 indicators were presented to stakeholders; they were asked to vote for the five indicators they considered most relevant and useful for assessing and benchmarking the quality of obstetric anaesthesia provided. The indicators chosen were: the percentage of women who had an epidural/combined spinal-epidural for labour analgesia with accidental dural puncture; the presence of guidelines for the referral of patients to an anaesthetist for antenatal review; whether there are dedicated elective caesarean section lists; the availability of point-of-care testing for estimation of haemoglobin concentration; and the percentage of epidurals for labour analgesia that provided adequate pain relief within 45 min of the start of epidural insertion. These indicators may be used for quality improvement and national benchmarking to support the implementation of quality standards in obstetric anaesthesia.
引用
- Bamber JH, Lucas DN, Plaat F, et al. The identification of key indicators to drive quality improvement in obstetric anaesthesia: results of the Obstetric Anaesthetists' Association/National Perinatal Epidemiology Unit collaborative Delphi project. Anaesthesia. 2019. PMID: 31657014. doi:10.1111/anae.14861
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。