肩部手术的膈肌保留神经阻滞再审视
本文综述了肩部手术后镇痛中替代肌间沟臂丛阻滞(ISB)的膈肌保留方案。累积证据显示喙锁阻滞可提供与ISB相似的术后镇痛且半膈肌麻痹(HDP)发生率为0%,但证据仅来自单项小样本研究,尚需验证;前路肩胛上神经阻滞可提供手术麻醉与相似镇痛,但HDP风险未正式量化。
要点
- 喙锁阻滞镇痛与ISB相似且HDP发生率为0%,但仅单项小样本研究。
- 前路肩胛上神经阻滞可提供手术麻醉与相似镇痛,HDP风险未量化。
- 锁骨上、上干及锁骨下-前路肩胛上联合阻滞镇痛相似且HDP<10%。
核心结论
- 累积证据提示喙锁阻滞可能提供与ISB相似的术后镇痛且HDP发生率为0%,但需进一步确认性试验。
- 前路肩胛上神经阻滞已证明可提供手术麻醉和与ISB相似的镇痛,但其HDP风险尚未正式量化。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为叙述性综述,汇总2017年前后发表的多个随机对照试验,涉及锁骨上阻滞、上干阻滞、前路肩胛上神经阻滞、喙锁阻滞及锁骨下-肩胛上联合阻滞。
主要发现
- 喙锁阻滞的累积证据显示术后镇痛与ISB相似,HDP发生率为0%,但仅基于单项研究的小样本量。
- 前路肩胛上神经阻滞可提供手术麻醉且镇痛与ISB相似,但HDP风险未正式量化。
- 锁骨上阻滞(局麻药注射于臂丛后外侧)、上干阻滞及锁骨下-前路肩胛上联合阻滞镇痛与ISB相似,HDP发生率<10%。
关键数值与推荐
- 喙锁阻滞:HDP发生率为0%,镇痛与ISB相似(基于单项小样本研究)。
- 锁骨上阻滞(后外侧注射)、上干阻滞、锁骨下-前路肩胛上联合阻滞:HDP发生率<10%,镇痛与ISB相似。
- 前路肩胛上神经阻滞:可提供手术麻醉,镇痛与ISB相似,HDP风险未量化。
临床怎么用
- 对存在基础肺功能损害的患者,可考虑膈肌保留阻滞替代ISB,但需注意各方案的证据强度与HDP风险数据。
- 喙锁阻滞和前路肩胛上神经阻滞是目前较有前景的替代方案,但前者需更多确认性试验,后者HDP风险未量化。
局限性
- 喙锁阻滞的证据仅来自单项研究,样本量小,需进一步确认性试验。
- 前路肩胛上神经阻滞的HDP风险尚未正式量化。
- 喙锁阻滞能否达到肩部手术的手术麻醉水平尚待研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Although interscalene brachial plexus block (ISB) remains the gold standard for analgesia after shoulder surgery, the inherent risks of ipsilateral phrenic nerve block and hemidiaphragmatic paralysis (HDP) limit its use in patients with preexisting pulmonary compromise. In a previous Daring Discourse (2017), our research team has identified potential diaphragm-sparing alternatives to ISB for patients undergoing shoulder surgery. In recent years, the field has been fertile with research, with the publication of multiple randomized controlled trials investigating supraclavicular blocks, upper trunk blocks, anterior suprascapular nerve blocks, costoclavicular blocks, and combined infraclavicular-suprascapular blocks. To date, the cumulative evidence (pre-2017 and post-2017) suggests that costoclavicular blocks may provide similar postoperative analgesia to ISB coupled with a 0%-incidence of HDP. However, in light of the small number of patients recruited by the single study investigating costoclavicular blocks, further confirmatory trials are required. Moreover, future investigation should also be undertaken to determine if costoclavicular blocks could achieve surgical anesthesia for shoulder surgery. Anterior suprascapular nerve blocks have been demonstrated to provide surgical anesthesia and similar analgesia to ISB. However, their risk of HDP has not been formally quantified. Of the remaining diaphragm-sparing nerve blocks, supraclavicular blocks (with local anesthetic injection posterolateral to the brachial plexus), upper trunk blocks, and combined infraclavicular-anterior suprascapular blocks merit further investigation, as they have been shown to achieve similar analgesia to ISB, coupled with an HDP incidence <10%.
引用
- Tran DQ, Layera S, Bravo D, et al. Diaphragm-sparing nerve blocks for shoulder surgery, revisited. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2019. PMID: 31541010. doi:10.1136/rapm-2019-100908
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。