术中知晓伴回忆:一项基于调查的描述性队列研究
该研究为前瞻性登记研究的子研究,对48151例成人手术患者术后问卷调查,17875例应答,622例报告感知全麻期间有特定记忆,282例报告相关疼痛、瘫痪和/或痛苦,149例接受电话调查,87例确认知晓,其中仅22例接受全麻,经3名麻醉科医生裁定6例为明确知晓、8例为可能知晓、8例非知晓。
要点
- 全麻术中知晓伴回忆仍会发生,但多数报告实际发生于镇静或区域麻醉。
- 患者对麻醉方式的错误预期与术中意识体验相关,是潜在干预靶点。
- 电话调查确认的知晓报告中,仅部分经裁定为明确或可能知晓。
核心结论
- 全麻术中知晓伴回忆仍会发生,但许多知晓报告发生于接受镇静或区域麻醉的患者,与对麻醉技术和意识体验的错误预期有关。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性登记研究的子研究,分析术后调查中4个聚焦术中知晓伴回忆的问题。
- 共发送48151份调查,收到17875例患者应答。
- 对282例报告疼痛、瘫痪和/或痛苦的患者尝试电话联系,149例参与电话调查。
- 全麻患者的访谈结果由3名麻醉科医生裁定。
主要发现
- 622例报告感知全麻期间有特定记忆,其中282例报告相关疼痛、瘫痪和/或痛苦。
- 149例电话调查参与者中87例确认先前知晓报告,但仅22例接受全麻,51例仅镇静,14例区域麻醉。
- 3名麻醉科医生独立裁定22例全麻病例:6例明确知晓、8例可能知晓、8例非知晓。
- 65例区域或镇静麻醉后确认知晓的患者中,37例(31例镇静和6例区域麻醉)术前未预期术中清醒。
临床怎么用
- 临床应关注接受镇静或区域麻醉患者对术中意识的预期,纠正错误预期可能减少知晓相关痛苦报告。
- 对报告术中知晓伴回忆的患者,应进行系统电话随访和多学科裁定以明确诊断。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Unintended intraoperative awareness with recall (AWR) is a potential complication of general anesthesia. Patients typically report recollections of (1) hearing sounds or conversations, (2) being unable to breathe or move, (3), feeling pain, and/or (4) experiencing emotional distress. The purpose of the current study was to identify and further characterize AWR experiences identified through postoperative surveys of a large unselected adult surgical cohort. METHODS: This is a substudy of a prospective registry study, which surveys patients on their health and well-being after surgery. Responses to 4 questions focusing on AWR were analyzed. Patients who reported AWR with pain, paralysis, and/or distress were contacted by telephone to obtain more information about their AWR experience. The interview results for patients who received general anesthesia were sent to 3 anesthesiologists, who adjudicated the reported AWR episodes. RESULTS: Of 48,151 surveys sent, 17,875 patient responses were received. Of these respondents, 622 reported a specific memory from the period between going to sleep and waking up from perceived general anesthesia and 282 of these reported related pain, paralysis, and/or distress. An attempt was made to contact these 282 patients, and 149 participated in a telephone survey. Among the 149 participants, 87 endorsed their prior report of AWR. However, only 22 of these patients had received general anesthesia, while 51 received only sedation and 14 received regional anesthesia. Three anesthesiologists independently adjudicated the survey results of the 22 general anesthesia cases and assigned 6 as definite AWR, 8 as possible AWR, and 8 as not AWR episodes. Of the 65 patients who confirmed their report of AWR after regional or sedation anesthesia, 37 (31 with sedation and 6 with regional anesthesia) had not expected to be conscious during surgery. CONCLUSIONS: The complication of AWR continues to occur during intended general anesthesia. Many reports of AWR episodes occur in patients receiving sedation or regional anesthesia and relate to incorrect expectations regarding anesthetic techniques and conscious experiences, representing a potential target for intervention.
引用
- Bombardieri AM, Mathur S, Soares A, et al. Intraoperative Awareness With Recall: A Descriptive, Survey-Based, Cohort Study. Anesth Analg. 2019. PMID: 31453869. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000004358
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。