氯普鲁卡因与丙胺卡因用于门诊膝关节镜脊髓麻醉的双盲随机试验
这项双盲随机试验纳入150例门诊膝关节镜患者,比较鞘内注射40mg 2-氯普鲁卡因与40mg丙胺卡因的麻醉恢复特征。主要结局运动阻滞完全恢复时间在氯普鲁卡因组中位数60分钟,比丙胺卡因组的75分钟缩短15分钟(p=0.004)。氯普鲁卡因组感觉阻滞完全消退和出院时间也更短,患者满意度和尿潴留需导尿率两组相同。
要点
- 2-氯普鲁卡因运动阻滞完全恢复中位时间60分钟,比丙胺卡因的75分钟快15分钟(p=0.004)。
- 2-氯普鲁卡因感觉阻滞完全消退中位120分钟,短于丙胺卡因的165分钟(p<0.001)。
- 2-氯普鲁卡因出院时间平均缩短57分钟(95%CI 38至77,p<0.001)。
核心结论
- 在膝关节镜手术中,2-氯普鲁卡因脊髓麻醉的运动和感觉阻滞恢复均快于丙胺卡因,并导致更快的出院。
研究设计与样本
- 双盲随机试验,150例患者随机接受鞘内40mg 2-氯普鲁卡因或40mg丙胺卡因。
主要发现
- 运动阻滞完全恢复时间氯普鲁卡因中位60分钟(IQR 60-82.5),丙胺卡因中位75分钟(IQR 60-90),p=0.004。
- 感觉阻滞完全消退时间氯普鲁卡因中位120分钟(IQR 90-135),丙胺卡因中位165分钟(IQR 135-190),p<0.001。
- 出院时间平均差异57分钟(95%CI 38至77),p<0.001,有利于氯普鲁卡因。
- 最高感觉阻滞平面氯普鲁卡因中位T9(IQR T6-T12),丙胺卡因中位T10(IQR T8-T12),p<0.008。
- 患者满意度和需要导尿的尿潴留两组相等。
临床怎么用
- 对于门诊膝关节镜,可优先考虑2-氯普鲁卡因脊髓麻醉以加速运动和感觉恢复并缩短出院时间。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In ambulatory lower limb surgery, spinal anesthesia with rapid onset and a short duration of block is preferable. We hypothesized that the use of 2-chloroprocaine would be associated with a faster motor block recovery compared with prilocaine in knee arthroscopy. A difference of 15 min was considered clinically relevant. METHODS: 150 patients were randomly allocated to receive intrathecally either 40 mg of 2-chloroprocaine or 40 mg of prilocaine. The primary outcome was the time to complete recovery from motor blockade. Secondary outcomes included time to full regression of sensory block, peak sensory block level, urine retention needing catheterization, time until hospital discharge, incidence of transient neurologic symptoms and patient satisfaction. RESULTS: Time to complete recovery from motor blockade was 15 min shorter for 2-chloroprocaine (median: 60 min; IQR: 60-82.5) than for prilocaine (median: 75 min; IQR: 60-90; p=0.004). 2-Chloroprocaine also resulted in faster full regression of sensory block (median: 120 min; IQR: 90-135 compared with median: 165 min; IQR: 135-190, p<0.001) and faster time to hospital discharge (mean difference: 57 min; 95% CI 38 to 77, p<0.001). Peak sensory block was higher in the 2-chloroprocaine group (median: T9; IQR: T6-T12 compared with median: T10; IQR: T8-T12, p<0.008). Patient satisfaction and urine retention needing catheterization were equal in both groups. CONCLUSIONS: In knee arthroscopy, spinal anesthesia with 2-chloroprocaine results in a faster recovery of motor and sensory block, leading to quicker hospital discharge compared with prilocaine. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NTR6796.
引用
- Wesselink E, Hurk GJD, Vegt RV, et al. Chloroprocaine versus prilocaine for spinal anesthesia in ambulatory knee arthroscopy: a double-blind randomized trial. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2019. PMID: 31439640. doi:10.1136/rapm-2019-100673
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。