视频喉镜引导下经鼻气管插管中气管导管热软化是否有益:一项随机对照试验
该随机对照试验纳入140例患者,比较气管导管热软化与不软化在视频喉镜引导经鼻气管插管中的效果。结果显示热软化组鼻出血发生率显著降低(7% vs 51%),且导管通过鼻腔阻力更低、时间更短,而口咽至声门及声门至气管的导航性无差异。提示在套囊充气辅助下,热软化可减少鼻损伤而不影响口咽导航。
要点
- 热软化气管导管可显著降低经鼻插管鼻出血发生率(7% vs 51%)。
- 热软化不增加口咽至声门及声门至气管的插管难度或时间。
- 套囊充气辅助下,所有导管均无需Magill钳即可送入气管。
核心结论
- 在视频喉镜引导经鼻气管插管中,套囊充气辅助下,气管导管热软化可显著减少鼻出血且不恶化口咽导航性。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,纳入140例患者,随机分为热软化组与对照组,比较经鼻气管插管相关指标。
主要发现
- 热软化组鼻出血发生率7%,对照组51%,差异44.2%(95%CI 29.9%-56.2%,P<.001)。
- 热软化组导管通过鼻腔阻力更低(P=.001)且时间更短(P<.001)。
- 两组间口咽至声门及声门至气管的导航分级与时间无显著差异(P>.99和P=.054;P>.99和P=.750)。
- 所有140例患者导管均成功插入,且两组均未使用Magill钳。
临床怎么用
- 视频喉镜引导经鼻气管插管时,可考虑将气管导管热软化并套入橡胶导管,以降低鼻出血风险。
- 套囊充气技术可辅助导管导航,避免使用Magill钳。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Thermosoftening of the endotracheal tube (ETT) and telescoping the ETT into a rubber catheter have been suggested as a method for reducing epistaxis during nasotracheal intubation (NTI). However, thermosoftening technique is known to make it difficult to navigate the ETT into trachea without the use of Magill forceps during NTI. The cuff inflation technique has been suggested as an effective alternative to the use of Magill forceps to improve the oropharyngeal navigation of the ETT, irrespective of their stiffness, during direct laryngoscope-guided NTI. We evaluated whether thermosoftening of the ETT telescoped into rubber catheters has an additional benefit in reducing nasal injury. Simultaneously, we also evaluated whether thermosoftening of the ETT worsened orotracheal navigability during cuff inflation-supplemented videolaryngoscope-guided NTI. METHODS: One hundred forty patients were randomly assigned to 1 of the 2 groups depending on whether the ETT was softened by warming or not. The primary outcome was the incidence of epistaxis during NTI. The secondary outcome was nasotracheal navigability of the ETT, assessed by navigation grade and time required for insertion of ETT in each phase (from nose to oropharynx, from oropharynx to glottic inlet aided by cuff inflation if needed, and from glottic inlet to trachea). RESULTS: The ETTs were successfully inserted through the selected nostril of all 140 patients. In the thermosoftening group, the incidence and severity of epistaxis was significantly lower (7% vs 51%; difference of 44.2%; 95% confidence interval, 29.9%-56.2%; P < .001), and the ETT passed through the nasal cavity with lower resistance (P = .001) and less time (P < .001) when compared to the control group. No difference was found in the ease of ETT insertion (navigation grade and time required) from the oropharynx to the glottic inlet (P > .99 and P = .054, respectively) and from the glottic inlet to the trachea (P > .99 and P = .750, respectively) between the 2 groups. In both groups, all ETTs could be navigated into the trachea without the use of Magill forceps. CONCLUSIONS: Supplemented with cuff inflation during videolaryngoscope-guided NTI, thermosoftening of the ETT telescoped into rubber catheters has a substantial benefit because it significantly reduces the incidence of epistaxis without worsening the oropharyngeal navigability of the ETT.
引用
- Kim EM, Chung MH, Lee MH, et al. Is Tube Thermosoftening Helpful for Videolaryngoscope-Guided Nasotracheal Intubation?: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Anesth Analg. 2019. PMID: 31425224. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000003822
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。