三种佐剂对单次肌间沟臂丛阻滞镇痛时长影响的比较:前瞻性随机三盲临床试验
本研究将160例择期肩部手术患者随机分为四组,分别接受罗哌卡因单用或联合可乐定75 µg、地塞米松8 mg、丁丙诺啡300 µg的肌间沟臂丛阻滞。主要结局镇痛持续时间在四组间无统计学显著差异(p=0.11),阻滞起效时间及感觉、运动阻滞总持续时间亦无组间差异。结论认为三种佐剂均未显著延长镇痛时长,但患者反应变异较大,研究可能对主要结局把握度不足。
要点
- 罗哌卡因联合可乐定、地塞米松或丁丙诺啡均未显著延长肌间沟臂丛阻滞镇痛时长。
- 四组间阻滞起效时间及感觉、运动阻滞总持续时间无差异。
- 患者反应变异较大,研究可能对主要结局把握度不足。
核心结论
- 在罗哌卡因基础上加入可乐定、地塞米松或丁丙诺啡均未显著改善肌间沟臂丛阻滞的镇痛持续时间。
- 患者反应变异大于预期,研究可能对主要结局把握度不足。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性、随机、三盲临床试验,纳入160例择期肩部手术患者,随机分为四组。
- 四组分别接受罗哌卡因单用、罗哌卡因联合可乐定75 µg、罗哌卡因联合地塞米松8 mg、罗哌卡因联合丁丙诺啡300 µg的肌间沟臂丛阻滞。
- 主要结局为镇痛持续时间;次要结局为阻滞起效时间及感觉和运动阻滞持续时间。
主要发现
- 四组间总镇痛时间无统计学显著差异(p=0.11)。
- 两两比较的镇痛时间及99%CI:对照组 vs 可乐定 -1.94小时(-7.33至3.12);对照组 vs 地塞米松 -4.16小时(-9.50至0.58);对照组 vs 丁丙诺啡 -1.1小时(-5.34至3.23)。
- 各组间阻滞起效时间、感觉和运动阻滞总持续时间无差异。
临床怎么用
- 基于本试验结果,单次肌间沟臂丛阻滞中添加可乐定75 µg、地塞米松8 mg或丁丙诺啡300 µg未显示延长镇痛时长的获益。
- 临床决策时需结合患者反应变异较大的特点及本研究的把握度限制综合判断。
局限性
- 患者反应变异大于预期,研究可能对主要结局把握度不足。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Use of regional anesthesia can result in faster recovery and better patient satisfaction. Addition of perineural adjuncts to local anesthetics may improve the duration of analgesia, but there is a paucity of data comparing them in a single randomized trial. We compared the effects of three adjuncts clonidine, dexamethasone, and buprenorphine, on the duration of analgesia of interscalene brachial plexus block. METHODS: 160 patients, undergoing elective shoulder surgery, were randomized to four groups to receive an interscalene block with one of the following solutions: ropivacaine alone, ropivacaine with clonidine 75 µg, ropivacaine with dexamethasone 8 mg, or ropivacaine with buprenorphine 300 µg. The primary outcome variable was the duration of analgesia; secondary outcome measures were time to onset of the block, and the duration of sensory and motor blocks. RESULTS: There was no statistically significant difference in the total analgesia time among the four groups; p=0.11. The pairwise comparison in analgesic time and 99% CI were: control versus clonidine (-1.94 hours (-7.33 to 3.12)), control versus dexamethasone (-4.16 hours (-9.50 to 0.58)) and control versus buprenorphine (-1.1 hours (-5.34 to 3.23)). There was no differences in block set-up time, or total sensory and motor block duration among the groups. CONCLUSION: There was no significant improvement in the duration of analgesia with addition of any of the three adjuncts to interscalene blocks. However, there was a larger than expected variability in patient response, hence the study may have been underpowered for the primary outcome.
引用
- Seering MS, Bayman EO, Wong CA, et al. Comparison of the effect of three different adjuvants on the analgesic duration of single injection interscalene brachial plexus block: a prospective, randomized, triple blinded clinical trial. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2019. PMID: 31308262. doi:10.1136/rapm-2018-100201
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。