文献速递气道管理

床头上抬头高位与GlideScope喉镜插管的随机对照非劣效试验

Comparison of Macintosh Laryngoscopy in Bed-up-Head-Elevated Position With GlideScope Laryngoscopy: A Randomized, Controlled, Noninferiority Trial.
PubMed 文献 · Anesth Analg · 2020-01-01

该随机对照非劣效试验纳入138例ASA I-III患者,比较床头上抬头高位(BUHE)与GlideScope(GLSC)喉镜插管的喉部暴露。BUHE组平均POGO评分80.14%±22.03%,GLSC组86.45%±18.83%,平均差异-6.3%(98%CI -13.2%至0.6%),满足非劣效界值。两组喉部暴露均优于嗅物位基线,BUHE组插管时间更短。

要点

  • BUHE体位插管的喉部暴露不劣于GlideScope喉镜插管。
  • 两种方法喉部暴露均优于嗅物位基线喉镜。
  • BUHE体位插管时间短于GlideScope插管。

核心结论

  • 在一般人群中,BUHE插管体位提供的喉部视野不劣于GLSC插管。
  • 两种方法获得的喉部视野均优于嗅物位获得的喉部视野。

研究设计与样本

  • 随机对照非劣效试验,纳入138例ASA I至III患者,随机分为BUHE组(n=69)和GLSC组(n=69)。
  • 所有患者先于嗅物位行基线喉镜检查,随后BUHE组在BUHE体位插管,GLSC组使用GlideScope喉镜插管。
  • 非劣效界值为两组平均POGO评分差异的98%CI下限不超过-15%。

主要发现

  • BUHE组平均POGO评分为80.14%±22.03%,GLSC组为86.45%±18.83%,平均差异-6.3%(98%CI -13.2%至0.6%)。
  • 两组POGO评分均较嗅物位基线显著改善(BUHE组基线25.8%±4.7%,GLSC组基线30.7%±6.8%;P<.0001)。
  • BUHE组平均插管时间为36.23±14.41秒,GLSC组为44.33±11.53秒(P<.0001)。
  • 基线CL 3级患者中,两组平均POGO评分无显著差异(BUHE组49.2%±19.6% vs GLSC组70.5%±29.7%;P=.054)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 非劣效性判定标准:两组平均POGO评分差异的98%CI下限不超过-15%。
  • 实际平均差异-6.3%(98%CI -13.2%至0.6%),下限-13.2%未超过-15%,故声明非劣效。

临床怎么用

  • 临床医生可考虑将BUHE体位作为一般人群的标准插管体位,因其简单、成本效益好且未证明有不良反应。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Approximately half of all difficult tracheal intubations (DTIs) are unanticipated; hence, proper positioning during intubation is critical to increase the likelihood of success. The bed-up-head-elevated (BUHE) intubation position has been shown to improve laryngeal view, reduce airway complications, and prolong safe apneic time during intubation. In this study, we sought to determine whether the BUHE intubation position is noninferior to Glidescope (GLSC)-assisted intubation with regard to laryngeal exposure. METHODS: A total of 138 American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) I to III patients were randomly assigned into 2 groups and underwent baseline laryngoscopy in the sniffing position. Group BUHE patients (n = 69) were then intubated in the BUHE position, while group GLSC patients (n = 69) were intubated using GLSC laryngoscopy. Laryngeal exposure was measured using Percentage of Glottic Opening (POGO) score and Cormack-Lehane (CL) grading, and noninferiority will be declared if the difference in mean POGO scores between both groups do not exceed -15% at the lower limit of a 98% confidence interval (CI). Secondary outcomes measured included time required for intubation (TRI), number of intubation attempts, use of airway adjuncts, effort during laryngoscopy, and complications during intubation. RESULTS: Mean POGO score in group BUHE was 80.14% ± 22.03%, while in group GLSC it was 86.45% ± 18.83%, with a mean difference of -6.3% (98% CI, -13.2% to 0.6%). In both groups, there was a significant improvement in mean POGO scores when compared to baseline laryngoscopy in the sniffing position (group BUHE, 25.8% ± 4.7%; group GLSC, 30.7% ± 6.8%) (P < .0001). The mean TRI was 36.23 ± 14.41 seconds in group BUHE, while group GLSC had a mean TRI of 44.33 ± 11.53 seconds (P < .0001). In patients with baseline CL 3 grading, there was no significant difference between mean POGO scores in both groups (group BUHE, 49.2% ± 19.6% versus group GLSC, 70.5% ± 29.7%; P = .054). CONCLUSIONS: In the general population, BUHE intubation position provides a noninferior laryngeal view to GLSC intubation. The laryngeal views obtained in both approaches were superior to the laryngeal view obtained in the sniffing position. In view of the many advantages of the BUHE position for intubation, the lack of proven adverse effects, the simplicity, and the cost-effectiveness, we propose that clinicians should consider the BUHE position as the standard intubation position for the general population.

来源:Anesth Analg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Tsan SEH, Lim SM, Abidin MFZ, et al. Comparison of Macintosh Laryngoscopy in Bed-up-Head-Elevated Position With GlideScope Laryngoscopy: A Randomized, Controlled, Noninferiority Trial. Anesth Analg. 2020. PMID: 31348051. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000004349

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。