连续实时压力传感技术客观识别硬膜外间隙:与透视和传统阻力消失法的随机对照比较
这项前瞻性随机对照非劣效性试验纳入400例患者,在慢性疼痛管理和分娩镇痛两个队列中,比较连续定量实时针尖压力测量(CompuFlo系统)与透视或传统阻力消失法识别腰椎硬膜外间隙的成功率,结果显示压力测量法非劣效于两种标准方法。
要点
- 针尖压力测量识别腰椎硬膜外间隙的成功率非劣效于透视和阻力消失法。
- 慢性疼痛队列中两种方法成功率均为100%,分娩镇痛队列中压力法为97.1%而阻力消失法为91%。
- 该技术可能避免辐射和造影剂暴露并降低医疗成本。
核心结论
- 连续定量实时针尖压力测量用于腰椎硬膜外间隙识别,在慢性疼痛管理和分娩镇痛中分别非劣效于透视和传统阻力消失法。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性随机对照非劣效性试验,共纳入400例患者;慢性疼痛管理组240例随机接受透视或针尖压力测量,分娩镇痛组160例随机接受阻力消失法或针尖压力测量,采用改良意向性分析,由盲法观察者判定成功。
主要发现
- 慢性疼痛管理组两种方法硬膜外间隙识别成功率均为100%(OR 1.1;97.27%CI 0.52-8.74;非劣效性P=.021)。
- 分娩镇痛组针尖压力测量成功率97.1%,阻力消失法91%(OR 3.3;97.27%CI 0.62-21.54;非劣效性P=.019),预设非劣效界值为0.50。
- 两组人口学特征相似,性别经标准化差异评估存在轻度不平衡。
关键数值与推荐
- 非劣效性判定标准为OR的97.27%置信区间下限高于0.50且非劣效性P值<.023。
临床怎么用
- 在慢性疼痛管理和分娩镇痛中,可采用连续实时针尖压力测量替代透视或阻力消失法识别腰椎硬膜外间隙,可能避免辐射和造影剂暴露并降低医疗成本。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Performance of epidural anesthesia and analgesia depends on successful identification of the epidural space (ES). While multiple investigations have described objective and alternative methodologies to identify the ES, traditional loss of resistance (LOR) and fluoroscopy (FC) are currently standard of care in labor and delivery (L&D) and chronic pain (CP) management, respectively. While FC is associated with high success, it exposes patients to radiation and requires appropriate radiological equipment. LOR is simple but subjective and consequently associated with higher failure rates. The purpose of this investigation was to compare continuous, quantitative, real-time, needle-tip pressure sensing using a novel computer-controlled ES identification technology to FC and LOR for lumbar ES identification. METHODS: A total of 400 patients were enrolled in this prospective randomized controlled noninferiority trial. In the CP management arm, 240 patients scheduled to receive a lumbar epidural steroid injection had their ES identified either with FC or with needle-tip pressure measurement. In the L&D arm, 160 female patients undergoing lumbar epidural catheter placements were randomized to either LOR or needle-tip pressure measurement. Blinded observers determined successful ES identification in both arms. A modified intention-to-treat protocol was implemented, with patients not having the procedure for reasons preceding the intervention excluded. Noninferiority of needle-tip pressure measurement regarding the incidence of successful ES identification was claimed when the lower limit of the 97.27% confidence interval (CI) for the odds ratio (OR) was above 0.50 (50% less likely to identify the ES) and P value for noninferioirty <.023. RESULTS: Demographics were similar between procedure groups, with a mild imbalance in relation to gender when evaluated through a standardized difference. Noninferiority of needle-tip pressure measurement was demonstrated in relation to FC where pain management patients presented a 100% success rate of ES identification with both methodologies (OR, 1.1; 97.27% CI, 0.52-8.74; P = .021 for noninferiority), and L&D patients experienced a noninferior success rate with the novel technology (97.1% vs 91%; OR, 3.3; 97.27% CI, 0.62-21.54; P = .019) using a a priori noninferiority delta of 0.50. CONCLUSIONS: Objective lumbar ES identification using continuous, quantitative, real-time, needle-tip pressure measurement with the CompuFlo Epidural Computer Controlled Anesthesia System resulted in noninferior success rates when compared to FC and LOR for CP management and L&D, respectively. Benefits of this novel technology may include nonexposure of patients to radiation and contrast medium and consequently reduced health care costs.
引用
- Gebhard RE, Moeller-Bertram T, Dobecki D, et al. Objective Epidural Space Identification Using Continuous Real-Time Pressure Sensing Technology: A Randomized Controlled Comparison With Fluoroscopy and Traditional Loss of Resistance. Anesth Analg. 2019. PMID: 31237571. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000003873
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。