医院间腰骶硬膜外类固醇注射年超4次比例异质性
该观察性队列研究分析2012年7月至2017年9月爱荷华州121家非联邦医院数据,发现48,270例患者中54.1%在首次注射后364天内未再接受注射,1.27%患者接受≥5次注射,1.91%的注射为第5次或以上;在39家高频注射医院中,6家第5次及以上注射比例显著高于总体1.91%(范围3.0%-6.4%),14家显著低于总体。
要点
- 多数患者一年内仅接受1次腰骶硬膜外类固醇注射(54.1%)。
- 1.27%患者一年内接受≥5次注射,1.91%的注射为第5次或以上。
- 医院间第5次及以上注射比例存在显著异质性,部分医院显著高于总体。
核心结论
- 虽然多数患者一年内仅接受1次腰骶硬膜外类固醇注射,但1.27%患者接受5次或以上,1.91%的注射为第5次或以上。
- 部分医院第5次及以上注射比例显著高于总体平均,这种异质性值得研究是否应将每年每患者注射次数作为临床质量指标或按指南调整支付。
研究设计与样本
- 观察性队列研究,纳入爱荷华州121家非联邦医院所有设施2012年7月至2017年9月的数据。
- 共48,270例独特患者至少接受1次腰骶硬膜外类固醇注射,在112家医院设施接受诊疗。
主要发现
- 54.1%的患者在首次注射后364个日历天内未再接受额外类固醇注射。
- 1.27%的患者接受了≥5次类固醇注射(即注射为第5次或以上)。
- 在39家至少每4天进行1次类固醇注射的医院中,6家第5次及以上注射比例显著高于总体1.91%(范围3.0%-6.4%),14家显著低于总体。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Current guidelines for the administration of therapeutic epidural injections suggest that these be limited to a maximum of 4 per year. We sought to gain an understanding of the proportion of lumbosacral epidural injections administered to patients who had received ≥4 such injections during the preceding 364 days, and whether these proportions varied among hospitals. METHODS: This observational cohort study included data from all facilities owned by the 121 nonfederal hospitals in the State of Iowa, July 2012 through September 2017. One end point was the percentage of all lumbar or sacral transforaminal or interlaminar epidural injections where the patient had received ≥4 such injections during the preceding 364 days. Comparisons also were made among hospitals' percentages of injections that were the fifth or greater (ie, patient had already received ≥4 during preceding 364 days) using Bonferroni-adjusted conservative 95% confidence intervals. RESULTS: There were 48,270 unique patients who underwent at least 1 lumbosacral epidural steroid injection. The patients received care at 112 hospitals' facilities. Most patients received no additional steroid injections within 364 subsequent calendar days after the first steroid injection (54.1%). There were ≥5 steroid injections for 1.27% of patients (ie, the injection was the fifth or greater). Among the 39 hospitals in Iowa that performed overall at least 1 steroid injection every 4 days, there were 6 hospitals at which the percentages of injections that were the fifth or greater significantly exceeded the overall prevalence of 1.91% (range: 3.0%-6.4%). There were 14 of the 39 hospitals with prevalences significantly less. CONCLUSIONS: Although most patients received only 1 lumbosacral steroid injection within 1 year, 1.27% of patients received 5 or more, and 1.91% of injections were the fifth or greater. Several hospitals had significantly greater than the overall average percent of steroid injections which were fifth or more. This heterogeneity warrants study of whether annual steroid injections per patient should be a clinical quality measure for the care received by patients with lower back pain or whether payment should be greater when injections are in accordance with guidelines.
引用
- Pearson ACS, Dexter F, Epstein RH, et al. Heterogeneity Among Hospitals in the Percentages of All Lumbosacral Epidural Steroid Injections Where the Patient Had Received 4 or More in the Previous Year. Anesth Analg. 2019. PMID: 31166229. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000004253
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。