困难颈部解剖训练模型在环甲膜切开术培训中的必要性:两种手术器械在新混合模型上的初步研究
共完成384例操作,中位完成时间74秒,74%成功通气;短胖模型完成时间更长且失败风险高于长瘦模型;ControlCric完成更快但成功率更低、并发症风险更高;熟练组操作更快但气管壁损伤风险更高。结论认为肥胖模型操作困难,但困难解剖情况必须被培训,新混合模型为下一步手术气道培训提供了必要条件。
要点
- 短胖颈部模型环甲膜切开完成时间更长、失败风险更高。
- ControlCric完成更快但成功率更低、并发症风险更高。
- 熟练者操作更快但气管壁损伤风险高于初学者。
核心结论
- 参与者在肥胖模型中行环甲膜切开困难,但各种困难解剖情况在气道管理中必须被教授。
- 结合猪与合成材料的新混合模型为手术气道操作培训的下一步提供了必要条件。
研究设计与样本
- 基于模型的比较试验,在德国乌尔姆武装部队医院于2018年8月进行。
- 在四种颈部解剖变异(长瘦/长胖/短瘦/短胖)上比较两种环甲膜切开手术方式(SurgiCric II vs. ControlCric)。
主要发现
- 总体中位完成时间为74秒,284例(74%)操作成功实现通气。
- 短胖模型完成时间长于长瘦模型,且短胖模型操作失败风险高于长瘦模型。
- ControlCric完成操作更快,但成功率更低且并发症风险高于SurgiCric II。
- 熟练操作者组操作更快,但气管壁损伤风险高于初学者组。
临床怎么用
- 培训中应涵盖肥胖等困难颈部解剖情况,不能仅用标准模型训练。
- 选择环甲膜切开器械时需权衡操作速度与成功率及并发症风险。
- 熟练操作者需注意气管壁损伤风险,培训中应强调解剖识别与操作精度。
局限性
- 本研究为初步研究,样本量有限。
- 研究在混合训练模型上进行,非真人患者。
- 研究未涉及人组织或活体动物,经伦理委员会豁免审查。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Everyone dealing with airway emergencies must be able to accomplish cricothyroidotomy, which cannot be trained in real patients. Training models are necessary. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the suitability of a hybrid training model combining synthetic and porcine parts to depict variable neck anatomy. DESIGN: Model-based comparative trial. SETTING: Armed Forces Hospital Ulm, Germany, August 2018. INTERVENTION: On four anatomical neck variations (long slim/long obese/short slim/short obese) we performed two surgical approaches to cricothyroidotomy (SurgiCric II vs. ControlCric). PARTICIPANTS: Forty-eight volunteers divided into two groups based on their personal skill level: beginners group and proficient performers group. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Time to completion was recorded for each procedure. Once the operator had indicated completion, the correct anatomical tube placement was confirmed by dissection and structures were inspected for complications. Primary outcomes were successful tracheal placement of an airway tube and time needed to achieve a patent airway. Secondary outcome was assessment of complications. RESULTS: Overall, 384 procedures were performed. Median time to completion was 74 s. In total, 284 procedures (74%) resulted in successful ventilation. Time to completion was longer in short obese than in long slim and the risk of unsuccessful procedures was increased in short obese compared with long slim. Even if ControlCric resulted in faster completion of the procedure, its use was less successful and had an increased risk of complications compared with SurgiCric II. Proficient performers group performed faster but had an increased risk of injuring the tracheal wall compared with beginners group. CONCLUSION: Participants had difficulties in performing cricothyroidotomy in obese models, but various and difficult anatomical situations must be expected in airway management and therefore must be taught. A new hybrid model combining porcine and synthetic materials offers the necessary conditions for the next step in training of surgical airway procedures. TRIAL REGISTRATION: The study was performed without human tissue or living animals, and was therefore exempted from ethical review by the University of Ulm Ethical Committee, Germany (Chairperson Prof Dr C. Lenk) on 9 August 2018. Hence a protocol number was not attributed.
引用
- Hossfeld B, Mahler O, Mayer B, et al. Necessity to depict difficult neck anatomy for training of cricothyroidotomy: A pilot study evaluating two surgical devices on a new hybrid training model. Eur J Anaesthesiol. 2019. PMID: 30950903. doi:10.1097/EJA.0000000000000993
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。