文献速递疼痛医学区域麻醉与超声

门诊介入性疼痛操作医疗法律分析:2009-2016年

A Contemporary Medicolegal Analysis of Outpatient Interventional Pain Procedures: 2009-2016.
PubMed 文献 · Anesth Analg · 2019-01-01

最常见的操作是腰椎和颈椎硬膜外类固醇注射,最常见损伤事件为操作不当,最常见结局为疼痛加重和脊髓梗死。技术技能缺陷在83%的诉讼中被认为存在。

要点

  • 硬膜外类固醇注射虽常见但可能导致严重神经损伤。
  • 触发点注射可能导致气胸或深部结构损伤。
  • 减少法律责任需加强操作培训、遵循最佳实践、完善知情同意和患者选择。

核心结论

  • 硬膜外类固醇注射和触发点注射等门诊介入性疼痛操作可能导致显著神经损伤等严重并发症,需通过多因素措施减少患者伤害和医师责任。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性观察性研究,利用Controlled Risk Insurance Company Comparative Benchmarking System数据库,查询2009年1月1日至2016年12月31日以疼痛医学为主要服务的已结案医疗诉讼案例,识别门诊介入性疼痛管理案例,共126例。

主要发现

  • 最常见操作:腰椎间孔硬膜外类固醇注射(n=34)、颈椎间孔硬膜外类固醇注射(n=31)、触发点注射(n=13)。
  • 最常见指控损伤事件:操作不当(n=38)、非无菌技术(n=17)、意外硬膜穿破(n=13)、针误入脊髓(n=11)、针误入肺(n=10)。
  • 最常见指控结局:疼痛加重(n=26)、脊髓梗死(n=16)、硬膜外血肿(n=9)、软组织感染(n=9)、硬膜穿破后头痛(n=9)、气胸(n=9)。
  • 根据Controlled Risk Insurance Company专有 contributing factor 系统,83%的诉讼中存在技术技能缺陷。

临床怎么用

  • 应持续加强操作技能培训,关注已发表的最佳实践建议,完善包括知情同意讨论的文档记录,并审慎选择患者。

局限性

  • 已结案诉讼数据不能覆盖所有发生的并发症,且偏向更严重的并发症。
  • Controlled Risk Insurance Company Comparative Benchmarking System数据无法独立验证。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Closed malpractice claim studies allow a review of rare but often severe complications, yielding useful insight into improving patient safety and decreasing practitioner liability. METHODS: This retrospective observational study of pain medicine malpractice claims utilizes the Controlled Risk Insurance Company Comparative Benchmarking System database, which contains nearly 400,000 malpractice claims drawn from >400 academic and community medical centers. The Controlled Risk Insurance Company Comparative Benchmarking System database was queried for January 1, 2009 through December 31, 2016, for cases with pain medicine as the primary service. Cases involving outpatient interventional pain management were identified. Controlled Risk Insurance Company-coded data fields and the narrative summaries were reviewed by the study authors. RESULTS: A total of 126 closed claims were identified. Forty-one claims resulted in payments to the plaintiffs, with a median payment of $175,000 (range, $2600-$2,950,000). Lumbar interlaminar epidural steroid injections were the most common procedures associated with claims (n = 34), followed by cervical interlaminar epidural steroid injections (n = 31) and trigger point injections (n = 13). The most common alleged injuring events were an improper performance of a procedure (n = 38); alleged nonsterile technique (n = 17); unintentional dural puncture (n = 13); needle misdirected to the spinal cord (n = 11); and needle misdirected to the lung (n = 10). The most common alleged outcomes were worsening pain (n = 26); spinal cord infarct (n = 16); epidural hematoma (n = 9); soft-tissue infection (n = 9); postdural puncture headache (n = 9); and pneumothorax (n = 9). According to the Controlled Risk Insurance Company proprietary contributing factor system, perceived deficits in technical skill were present in 83% of claims. CONCLUSIONS: Epidural steroid injections are among the most commonly performed interventional pain procedures and, while a familiar procedure to pain management practitioners, may result in significant neurological injury. Trigger point injections, while generally considered safe, may result in pneumothorax or injury to other deep structures. Ultimately, the efforts to minimize practitioner liability and patient harm, like the claims themselves, will be multifactorial. Best outcomes will likely come from continued robust training in procedural skills, attention paid to published best practice recommendations, documentation that includes an inclusive consent discussion, and thoughtful patient selection. Limitations for this study are that closed claim data do not cover all complications that occur and skew toward more severe complications. In addition, the data from Controlled Risk Insurance Company Comparative Benchmarking System cannot be independently verified.

来源:Anesth Analg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Abrecht CR, Saba R, Greenberg P, et al. A Contemporary Medicolegal Analysis of Outpatient Interventional Pain Procedures: 2009-2016. Anesth Analg. 2019. PMID: 30925562. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000004096

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。