文献速递术前评估与围术期医学

麻醉药物差错风险数学模型:药物选择、注射途径、手术时长与疲劳的影响

Mathematical model of the risk of drug error during anaesthesia: the influence of drug choices, injection routes, operation duration and fatigue.
PubMed 文献 · Anaesthesia · 2019-03-18

研究构建概率数学模型,将麻醉医生建模为在手术中反复做出用药选择的「易错主体」,以初始内在错误率为基础,纳入剂量、给药时机与注射途径等选择,并将疲劳作为放大累积错误率的因素。初始内在错误率为1/1000时,模型预测约12小时手术的累积错误概率约10%,与大观察性试验报告率相似。

要点

  • 初始内在错误率1/1000时,约12小时手术累积错误概率约10%。
  • 疲劳即使以温和假设建模,也对累积错误率产生显著不利影响。
  • 手术时长>5-6小时被视为风险明显增高的时段。

核心结论

  • 模型预测的累积药物差错概率与大观察性试验报告率相似,严重差错符合泊松分布。
  • 疲劳假设即使温和,也会显著且不利地升高累积错误率。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究构建概率数学模型,将麻醉医生建模为在手术中反复做出用药选择的「易错主体」。
  • 模型纳入的选择包括剂量、给药时机和可用的注射途径(如静脉、动脉、硬膜外等)。
  • 疲劳被建模为放大累积错误率的因素。

主要发现

  • 初始内在错误率为1/1000时,模型预测约12小时手术的累积错误概率约10%,即每10台如此长的手术有1台出现某种药物差错。
  • 严重差错仅占所有差错的一小部分,模型预测其呈泊松分布,与独立观察一致。
  • 疲劳的温和假设对累积错误率有显著且不利的影响。

关键数值与推荐

  • 初始内在错误率取1/1000,作者从第一性原理认为这是合理估计。
  • 约12小时手术的累积错误概率约10%。
  • 手术时长>5-6小时构成风险明显增高的时段。

临床怎么用

  • 状态不佳时应谨慎或避免开始工作。
  • 在不熟悉的环境中应加强警觉。
  • 保持麻醉配方简单。
  • 认识手术时长>5-6小时为风险明显增高时段。

局限性

  • 上述实践启示为观察性试验中可检验的预测,尚待验证。
  • 模型若获验证,可作为研究工具通过模拟探讨安全干预对内在错误率的影响。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

The incidence of an anaesthetic drug error can be directly observed in large trials. In an alternative approach, we developed a probabilistic mathematical model in which the anaesthetist is modelled as a 'fallible entity' who makes repeated drug administration choices during an operation. This fallibility was factored in the model as an initial 'intrinsic error rate'. The choices faced included: dose; timing of administration; and the routes available for injection (e.g. venous, arterial, epidural, etc.). Additionally, we modelled the effect of fatigue as a factor that magnifies the cumulative error rate. For an initial intrinsic error rate of 1 in 1000 (which from first principles we consider a reasonable estimate), our model predicted a cumulative probability of error over a ~12 h operation of ~10%; that is, 1 in 10 operations this long results in some drug error. This is similar to the rate reported by large observational trials. Serious errors constitute a small fraction of all errors; our model predicts a Poisson distribution for the uncommon serious errors, also consistent with independent observations. Even modest assumptions for the development of fatigue had a dramatic and adverse impact on the cumulative error rate. The practice implications of our modelling include: exercising caution or avoiding starting work if under par; added vigilance in unfamiliar environments; keeping anaesthetic recipes simple; and recognising that operation durations > 5-6 h constitute a time of exaggerated risk. These implications are testable predictions in observational trials. If validated, our model could serve as a potential research tool to investigate the impact of safety interventions on the rate of intrinsic error using simulation.

来源:Anaesthesia,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Sivia DS, Pandit JJ. Mathematical model of the risk of drug error during anaesthesia: the influence of drug choices, injection routes, operation duration and fatigue. Anaesthesia. 2019. PMID: 30883682. doi:10.1111/anae.14629

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。