床旁试验预测困难气道的Cochrane诊断准确性系统评价
该Cochrane系统评价纳入133项研究(844,206例患者),评估常用床旁气道筛查试验对成人全麻困难气道的诊断准确性。结果显示所有试验敏感性低且变异大,特异性高;上唇咬合试验诊断困难喉镜暴露的敏感性0.67、特异性0.92,优于张口试验,但尚无单一试验能可靠识别未预料的困难气道。
要点
- 所有床旁气道试验敏感性低,特异性高,阴性结果不能排除困难气道。
- 上唇咬合试验诊断困难喉镜暴露敏感性0.67、特异性0.92,优于张口试验。
- 改良Mallampati试验预测困难插管敏感性0.51,高于张口试验和颏甲距离。
核心结论
- 上唇咬合试验诊断准确性相对最优,但所有常用床旁试验均不适合检出未预料的困难气道,漏诊较多。
- 各试验敏感性普遍较低且变异大,特异性一致且明显高于敏感性。
研究设计与样本
- Cochrane诊断准确性系统评价,检索7个文献数据库至2016年12月16日。
- 纳入133项研究(127项队列型、6项病例对照),共844,206例参与者。
- 纳入无 apparent 解剖异常的成人全麻患者,评估预定义的床旁指数筛查试验。
- 方法学质量按QUADAS-2评估为中至高度。
主要发现
- 共评估7种试验:Mallampati试验6项研究、改良Mallampati试验105项、Wilson风险评分6项、颏甲距离52项、胸颏距离18项、张口试验34项、上唇咬合试验30项。
- 参考标准:困难面罩通气7项研究、困难喉镜暴露92项、困难插管50项、插管失败2项。
- 困难喉镜暴露:上唇咬合试验敏感性0.67(95%CI 0.45-0.83)、特异性0.92(95%CI 0.86-0.95)。
- 上唇咬合试验敏感性显著高于张口试验(0.22,95%CI 0.13-0.33;p < 0.001)。
- 困难气管插管:改良Mallampati试验敏感性0.51(95%CI 0.40-0.61),显著高于张口试验(0.27,95%CI 0.16-0.41;p < 0.001)和颏甲距离(0.24,95%CI 0.12-0.43;p < 0.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 上唇咬合试验诊断困难喉镜暴露:敏感性0.67(95%CI 0.45-0.83),特异性0.92(95%CI 0.86-0.95)。
- 张口试验诊断困难喉镜暴露:敏感性0.22(95%CI 0.13-0.33)。
- 改良Mallampati试验诊断困难插管:敏感性0.51(95%CI 0.40-0.61)。
- 张口试验诊断困难插管:敏感性0.27(95%CI 0.16-0.41)。
- 颏甲距离诊断困难插管:敏感性0.24(95%CI 0.12-0.43)。
临床怎么用
- 床旁气道试验阳性可提示困难气道风险增高,但阴性不能排除,需结合临床综合判断。
- 上唇咬合试验可作为困难喉镜暴露的辅助筛查工具之一。
- 改良Mallampati试验对困难插管有一定提示价值,但敏感性仍有限。
局限性
- 各试验敏感性低且变异大,可能漏诊许多未预料困难气道。
- 纳入研究间存在异质性,部分试验研究数量较少。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Although bedside screening tests are routinely used to identify people at high risk of having a difficult airway, their clinical utility is unclear. We estimated the diagnostic accuracy of commonly used bedside examination tests for assessing the airway in adult patients without apparent anatomical abnormalities scheduled to undergo general anaesthesia. We searched for studies that reported our pre-specified bedside index screening tests against a reference standard, published in any language, from date of inception to 16 December 2016, in seven bibliographic databases. We included 133 studies (127 cohort type and 6 case-control) involving 844,206 participants. Overall, their methodological quality (according to QUADAS-2, a standard tool for assessing quality of diagnostic accuracy studies) was moderate to high. Our pre-specified tests were: the Mallampati test (6 studies); modified Mallampati test (105 studies); Wilson risk score (6 studies); thyromental distance (52 studies); sternomental distance (18 studies); mouth opening test (34 studies); and the upper lip bite test (30 studies). Difficult facemask ventilation, difficult laryngoscopy, difficult intubation and failed intubation were the reference standards in seven, 92, 50 and two studies, respectively. Across all reference standards, we found all index tests had relatively low sensitivities, with high variability, but specificities were consistently and markedly higher than sensitivities. For difficult laryngoscopy, the sensitivity and specificity (95%CI) of the upper lip bite test were 0.67 (0.45-0.83) and 0.92 (0.86-0.95), respectively; upper lip bite test sensitivity (95%CI) was significantly higher than that for the mouth opening test (0.22, 0.13-0.33; p < 0.001). For difficult tracheal intubation, the modified Mallampati test had a significantly higher sensitivity (95%CI) at 0.51 (0.40-0.61) compared with mouth opening (0.27, 0.16-0.41; p < 0.001) and thyromental distance (0.24, 0.12-0.43; p < 0.001). Although the upper lip bite test showed the most favourable diagnostic test accuracy properties, none of the common bedside screening tests is well suited for detecting unanticipated difficult airways, as many of them are missed.
引用
- Roth D, Pace NL, Lee A, et al. Bedside tests for predicting difficult airways: an abridged Cochrane diagnostic test accuracy systematic review. Anaesthesia. 2019. PMID: 30843190. doi:10.1111/anae.14608
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。