超声引导经皮外周神经刺激:肩胛上神经与臂丛神经调控用于门诊肩袖修复术后镇痛的概念验证研究
这项概念验证研究在门诊肩袖修复患者中,术前超声引导下经皮植入电极,分别靶向肩胛上神经或臂丛神经根/干,术后随机接受刺激或假刺激5分钟并交叉,随后持续刺激至术后14-28天拔除电极。肩胛上神经靶点未见镇痛效果;臂丛电极患者在恢复室最初40分钟内刺激未降低疼痛评分,11例中7例需肌间沟神经阻滞补救,但术后1-14天中位静息和动态疼痛评分≤1,阿片需求平均每日不足1片。结论认为该技术可行,但术后即刻镇痛不如局麻药神经阻滞,需大型随机对照试验进一步验证。
要点
- 臂丛经皮外周神经刺激在门诊肩袖修复术后可行,但恢复室早期镇痛不足。
- 术后1-14天中位疼痛评分≤1,阿片需求平均每日不足1片。
- 电极脱位2例、拔除时断裂4例,无感染或神经损伤报告。
核心结论
- 超声引导经皮臂丛外周神经刺激用于门诊肩袖修复术后镇痛可行。
- 术后即刻镇痛效果不如局麻药外周神经阻滞,但术后数日可能提供镇痛并减少阿片需求。
- 需大型随机对照试验进一步验证,且电极最佳位置、置入技术、刺激方案及脱位断裂问题待解决。
研究设计与样本
- 概念验证研究,术前超声引导下经皮植入电极靶向肩胛上神经或臂丛神经根/干。
- 术后随机双盲接受5分钟刺激或假刺激,交叉5分钟后持续刺激至术后14-28天拔除。
主要发现
- 肩胛上神经靶点电极(n=2)未见镇痛效果;后续14例电极经中斜角肌置入靶向臂丛。
- 3例在数据收集前退出;臂丛电极剩余11例中,恢复室最初40分钟刺激未降低疼痛评分。
- 11例中7例在出院前需单次肌间沟神经阻滞补救镇痛。
- 术后1-14天中位静息和动态疼痛评分≤1(数字评分量表),主动刺激下阿片需求平均每日不足1片。
- 2例电极使用中脱位,4例拔除时断裂,无感染、神经损伤或不良后遗症报告。
临床怎么用
- 该技术可作为门诊肩袖修复术后多模式镇痛的可选方案,但需注意术后即刻镇痛不足。
- 术后早期可能需要肌间沟神经阻滞等补救镇痛。
- 需关注电极脱位和断裂风险,并进一步优化置入与刺激方案。
局限性
- 概念验证研究,样本量小,部分受试者退出。
- 缺乏 adequate control group,无法充分评估疗效。
- 电极最佳位置、置入技术、刺激方案及脱位断裂等问题未解决。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Percutaneous peripheral nerve stimulation (PNS) is an analgesic modality involving the insertion of a lead through an introducing needle followed by the delivery of electric current. This modality has been reported to treat chronic pain as well as postoperative pain following knee and foot surgery. However, it remains unknown if this analgesic technique may be used in ambulatory patients following upper extremity surgery. The purpose of this proof-of-concept study was to investigate various lead implantation locations and evaluate the feasibility of using percutaneous brachial plexus PNS to treat surgical pain following ambulatory rotator cuff repair in the immediate postoperative period. METHODS: Preoperatively, an electrical lead (SPR Therapeutics, Cleveland, Ohio) was percutaneously implanted to target the suprascapular nerve or brachial plexus roots or trunks using ultrasound guidance. Postoperatively, subjects received 5 min of either stimulation or sham in a randomized, double-masked fashion followed by a 5 min crossover period, and then continuous stimulation until lead removal postoperative days 14-28. RESULTS: Leads (n=2) implanted at the suprascapular notch did not appear to provide analgesia, and subsequent leads (n=14) were inserted through the middle scalene muscle and placed to target the brachial plexus. Three subjects withdrew prior to data collection. Within the recovery room, stimulation did not decrease pain scores during the first 40 min of the remaining subjects with brachial plexus leads, regardless of which treatment subjects were randomized to initially. Seven of these 11 subjects required a single-injection interscalene nerve block for rescue analgesia prior to discharge. However, subsequent average resting and dynamic pain scores postoperative days 1-14 had a median of 1 or less on the Numeric Rating Scale, and opioid requirements averaged less than 1 tablet daily with active stimulation. Two leads dislodged during use and four fractured on withdrawal, but no infections, nerve injuries, or adverse sequelae were reported. CONCLUSIONS: This proof-of-concept study demonstrates that ultrasound-guided percutaneous PNS of the brachial plexus is feasible for ambulatory shoulder surgery, and although analgesia immediately following surgery does not appear to be as potent as local anesthetic-based peripheral nerve blocks, the study suggests that this modality may provide analgesia and decrease opioid requirements in the days following rotator cuff repair. Therefore, it suggests that a subsequent, large, randomized clinical trial with an adequate control group is warranted to further investigate this therapy in the management of surgical pain in the immediate postoperative period. However, multiple technical issues remain to be resolved, such as the optimal lead location, insertion technique, and stimulating protocol, as well as preventing lead dislodgment and fracture. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT02898103.
引用
- Ilfeld BM, Finneran JJ, Gabriel RA, et al. Ultrasound-guided percutaneous peripheral nerve stimulation: neuromodulation of the suprascapular nerve and brachial plexus for postoperative analgesia following ambulatory rotator cuff repair. A proof-of-concept study. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2019. PMID: 30770421. doi:10.1136/rapm-2018-100121
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。