骶管阻滞对尿道下裂修复术镇痛效果及手术并发症影响的系统评价与Meta分析
该系统评价与Meta分析评估了骶管阻滞用于儿童尿道下裂修复术的镇痛效果及与手术并发症的关系。纳入4项RCT(298例)和7项观察性研究(1726例),RCT显示骶管阻滞与外周神经阻滞在24小时额外镇痛需求上无差异,但镇痛持续时间更短;观察性研究显示骶管阻滞与手术并发症无关。
要点
- RCT中骶管阻滞与外周神经阻滞在24小时额外镇痛需求上无显著差异。
- RCT有限数据显示骶管阻滞镇痛持续时间更短,24小时疼痛评分更低。
- 观察性研究中骶管阻滞与尿道皮肤瘘、龟头裂开等手术并发症无关。
核心结论
- RCT有限数据显示外周神经阻滞可能提供更优的镇痛质量,但骶管阻滞在观察性研究中未增加手术并发症风险。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与Meta分析,纳入4项RCT共298例患者和7项观察性研究共1726例患者,分别分析。
主要发现
- RCT中骶管阻滞与外周神经阻滞在24小时额外镇痛需求上无显著差异(OR 10.49;95%CI 0.32至343.24;p=0.19)。
- RCT有限数据显示骶管阻滞术后24小时疼痛评分更低(SMD 1.57;95%CI 0.29至2.84;p=0.02),镇痛持续时间更短(SMD -3.33;95%CI -4.18至-2.48;p<0.0001)。
- RCT中术后恶心呕吐(OR 3.08;95%CI 0.12至77.80;p=0.50)和运动无力(OR 0.01;95%CI -0.03至0.05;p=0.56)无显著差异。
- 仅一项RCT显示骶管阻滞与外周神经阻滞在尿道皮肤瘘率(OR 25.27;95%CI 1.37至465.01;p=0.03)和父母满意度(OR 0.07;95%CI 0.02至0.21;p<0.00001)上有差异。
- 观察性研究中骶管阻滞与所有类型原发性尿道下裂修复的手术并发症无关(OR 1.83;95%CI 0.80至4.16;p=0.15),远端型亚组并发症率相似(OR 1.02;95%CI 0.39至2.65;p=0.96)。
关键数值与推荐
- RCT中比较骶管阻滞与外周神经阻滞(阴茎背神经阻滞和阴部神经阻滞)或未阻滞。
- 观察性研究比较骶管阻滞与未阻滞,评估手术并发症。
- 亚组分析仅纳入远端型尿道下裂患者以调整混杂因素。
临床怎么用
- 骶管阻滞可用于儿童尿道下裂修复术镇痛,但需权衡其较短的镇痛持续时间与外周神经阻滞的潜在优势。
- 现有证据未显示骶管阻滞增加尿道皮肤瘘或龟头裂开等手术并发症风险。
局限性
- 观察性研究存在选择偏倚和残余混杂因素。
- RCT数据有限,尤其关于手术并发症和父母满意度的结果仅来自单项研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: is commonly used for children undergoing hypospadias repair. However, the safety of caudal block for hypospadias repair in children is controversial in terms of surgical complications such as urethrocutaneous fistula and glans dehiscence. We sought to perform a meta-analysis to estimate the analgesic efficacy and relative complications of caudal block for hypospadias repair in children. METHODS: We identified comparative studies of caudal block versus peripheral nerve block or no caudal block; studies were published or presented through 1 January 2018, and reports of analgesic efficacy or surgical complications of hypospadias repair in children were identified. Peripheral nerve block includes dorsal nerve penile block and pudendal nerve block. Data were abstracted from studies comparing caudal block with peripheral nerve block or no caudal block; original source data were used when available. We prespecified separate assessments of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and observational studies given the inherent differences between types of study designs. Data from 298 patients in four RCTs and from 1726 patients in seven observational studies were included. RCT and observational data were analyzed separately. RESULTS: In RCTs, caudal blocks (compared with peripheral nerve blocks) showed no detectable differences in terms of need for additional analgesia within 24 hours after the surgery (OR 10.49; 95% CI 0.32 to 343.24; p=0.19), but limited data showed lower pain scores 24 hours after the surgery (standardized mean difference (SMD) 1.57; 95% CI 0.29 to 2.84; p=0.02), a significantly shorter duration of analgesia (SMD -3.33; 95% CI -4.18 to -2.48; p<0.0001) and analgesics consumption. No significant differences were observed in terms of postoperative nausea and vomiting (OR 3.08; 95% CI 0.12 to 77.80; p=0.50) or motor weakness (OR 0.01; 95% CI -0.03 to 0.05; p=0.56). Only one randomized study showed that caudal blocks (compared with peripheral nerve blocks) were associated with detectable differences in urethrocutaneous fistula rate (OR 25.27; 95% CI 1.37 to 465.01; p=0.03) and parental satisfaction rate (OR 0.07; 95% CI 0.02 to 0.21; p<0.00001). In observational studies, caudal block was not associated with surgical complications in all types of primary hypospadias repair (OR 1.83; 95% CI 0.80 to 4.16; p=0.15). To adjust for confounding factors and to eliminate potential selection bias involving caudal block indication, we performed subgroup analysis including only patients with distal hypospadias. This analysis revealed similar complication rates in children who received a caudal block and in children not receiving caudal block (OR 1.02; 95% CI, 0.39 to 2.65; p=0.96). This result further confirmed that caudal block was not a risk factor for surgical complications in hypospadias repair. The direction of outcomes in all the other subgroup analyses did not change, suggesting stability of our results. CONCLUSIONS: In RCTs, only limited data showed peripheral nerve blocks providing better analgesic quality compared with caudal blocks. In real-world non-randomized observational studies with greater number of patients (but with admitted the potential for a presence of selection bias and residual confounders), caudal blocks were not associated with postoperative complications including urethrocutaneous fistula and glans dehiscence.
引用
- Zhu C, Wei R, Tong Y, et al. Analgesic efficacy and impact of caudal block on surgical complications of hypospadias repair: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2019. PMID: 30700621. doi:10.1136/rapm-2018-000022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。