麻醉学领域的掠夺性开放获取出版现象分析
该研究调查了麻醉学及相关专业(重症、呼吸、疼痛和急诊医学)中潜在或可能的掠夺性开放获取出版商和期刊。共识别出来自83家出版商的212种期刊,发表文章总数12,871篇。多数出版商报告位于美国,但43%(37/84)经谷歌地图三维视图核查后位置被判定为「不可靠」。仅6种期刊被PubMed收录,声称被DOAJ收录的6种期刊实际均未注册。中位文章处理费为634.5美元(四分位距275-1005美元)。仅32%(67/212)报告主编姓名,24%(50/212)报告伦理/科学不端行为规则。结论认为掠夺性开放获取出版在麻醉学领域广泛存在,研究者投稿时应仔细核查期刊信息。
要点
- 麻醉学及相关领域存在大量潜在掠夺性开放获取期刊,共识别212种来自83家出版商。
- 多数出版商报告位于美国,但43%经核查位置不可靠,仅6种期刊被PubMed收录。
- 中位文章处理费634.5美元,仅32%期刊报告主编姓名,24%报告伦理规则。
核心结论
- 潜在或可能的掠夺性开放获取出版商和期刊在麻醉学及相关专业领域广泛存在。
- 研究者向开放获取期刊投稿时应仔细核查期刊报告的位置、编委会、索引和伦理规则等信息。
研究设计与样本
- 两位作者独立调查了Beall潜在、可能或 probable 掠夺性出版商和独立期刊列表的可免费获取且不断更新的版本。
- 研究范围涵盖麻醉学及相关专业(重症监护、危重和呼吸医学、疼痛医学和急诊护理)。
主要发现
- 共识别出来自83家出版商的212种期刊,发表文章总数为12,871篇。
- 多数出版商报告位置为美国,但43%(37/84)经谷歌地图三维视图核查后位置被判定为「不可靠」。
- 6种期刊被PubMed收录;尽管6种期刊声称被DOAJ收录,但实际均未注册。
- 中位文章处理费为634.5美元(四分位距275-1005美元)。
- 仅32%(67/212)报告主编姓名,仅24%(50/212)报告伦理/科学不端行为规则。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识别212种期刊来自83家出版商,发表文章总数12,871篇。
- 43%(37/84)的出版商报告位置经核查判定为「不可靠」。
- 6种期刊被PubMed收录,0种声称被DOAJ收录的期刊实际注册。
- 中位文章处理费634.5美元(四分位距275-1005美元)。
- 32%(67/212)报告主编姓名,24%(50/212)报告伦理/科学不端行为规则。
临床怎么用
- 麻醉科医生投稿开放获取期刊前应核查期刊位置、编委会、索引和伦理规则等信息。
- 警惕文章处理费异常、主编信息缺失或索引声明虚假的期刊。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Predatory publishing is an exploitative fraudulent open-access publishing model that applies charges under the pretense of legitimate publishing operations without actually providing the editorial services associated with legitimate journals. The aim of this study was to analyze this phenomenon in the field of anesthesiology and related specialties (intensive care, critical and respiratory medicine, pain medicine, and emergency care). Two authors independently surveyed a freely accessible, constantly updated version of the original Beall lists of potential, possible, or probable predatory publishers and standalone journals. We identified 212 journals from 83 publishers, and the total number of published articles was 12,871. The reported location of most publishers was in the United States. In 43% of cases (37/84), the reported location was judged as "unreliable" after being checked using the 3-dimensional view in Google Maps. Six journals were indexed in PubMed. Although 6 journals were declared to be indexed in the Directory of Open Access Journals, none were actually registered. The median article processing charge was 634.5 US dollars (interquartile range, 275-1005 US dollars). Several journals reported false indexing/registration in the Committee on Publication Ethics and International Committee of Medical Journal Editors registries and Google Scholar. Only 32% (67/212) reported the name of the editor-in-chief. Rules for ethics/scientific misconduct were reported in only 24% of cases (50/212). In conclusion, potential or probable predatory open-access publishers and journals are widely present in the broad field of anesthesiology and related specialties. Researchers should carefully check journals' reported information, including location, editorial board, indexing, and rules for ethics when submitting their manuscripts to open-access journals.
引用
- Cortegiani A, Longhini F, Sanfilippo F, et al. Predatory Open-Access Publishing in Anesthesiology. Anesth Analg. 2019. PMID: 30234529. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000003803
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。