新型尸体模型(Fix for Life)与福尔马林固定尸体及模拟人在气道管理培训中的适用性与真实性比较
研究比较了新型Fix for Life(F4L)尸体、福尔马林固定尸体和模拟人(SimMan 3G)在气道管理培训中的适用性与真实性。30名麻醉医生和经验丰富的住院医师对三种模型进行面罩通气、气管插管和喉罩置入操作并评分。结果显示F4L尸体在面罩通气中排名最高,在喉罩置入真实性评分更高,而福尔马林固定尸体排名最低,模拟人操作成功率最高。
要点
- F4L尸体在面罩通气教学中排名最高(中位总排名1,P<.001)。
- F4L尸体在喉罩置入真实性评分高于模拟人和福尔马林固定尸体(P=.043)。
- 福尔马林固定尸体在所有操作中排名最低、评分最差(所有P<.001)。
核心结论
- F4L尸体在面罩通气培训中排名最高,并被认为是喉罩置入培训最真实的模型。
- 福尔马林固定尸体不适合用于气道管理培训。
研究设计与样本
- 30名麻醉医生和经验丰富的住院医师作为操作者,在10具F4L尸体、10具福尔马林固定尸体和1具模拟人上执行三种气道技术。
- 每位操作者的模型类型顺序随机化。
- 主要结局为操作者对每种模型作为教学模型的总排名、每种技术下的模型排名以及适用性和真实性的平均言语评分。
- 次要结局为每种技术和每种模型的操作成功率。
主要发现
- 每种技术的尝试总数:模拟人30次,F4L 292次,福尔马林固定尸体282次。
- 操作者对每种模型作为教学模型的中位总排名:F4L为1,模拟人为2,福尔马林固定尸体为3(P<.001)。
- F4L被认为是面罩通气的最佳模型(P=.029),并且在喉罩置入的真实性方面具有更高的平均言语评分(P=.043)。
- F4L和模拟人在其他适用性和真实性评分上无显著差异;福尔马林固定尸体在所有操作中排名最后且评分最低(所有P<.001)。
临床怎么用
- 在气道管理培训中,可优先考虑使用F4L尸体进行面罩通气和喉罩置入教学。
- 不应使用福尔马林固定尸体进行气道管理培训。
- 模拟人操作成功率最高,但F4L在真实感方面具有优势,可根据培训目标选择模型。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Manikins are widely used in airway management training; however, simulation of realism and interpatient variability remains a challenge. We investigated whether cadavers embalmed with the novel Fix for Life (F4L) embalmment method are a suitable and realistic model for teaching 3 basic airway skills: facemask ventilation, tracheal intubation, and laryngeal mask insertion compared to a manikin (SimMan 3G) and formalin-fixed cadavers. METHODS: Thirty anesthesiologists and experienced residents ("operators") were instructed to perform the 3 airway techniques in 10 F4L, 10 formalin-fixed cadavers, and 1 manikin. The order of the model type was randomized per operator. Primary outcomes were the operators' ranking of each model type as a teaching model (total rank), ranking of the model types per technique, and an operator's average verbal rating score for suitability and realism of learning the technique on the model. Secondary outcomes were the percentages of successfully performed procedures per technique and per model (success rates in completing the respective airway maneuvers). For each of the airway techniques, the Friedman analysis of variance was used to compare the 3 models on mean operator ranking and mean verbal rating scores. RESULTS: Twenty-seven of 30 operators (90%) performed all airway techniques on all of the available models, whereas 3 operators performed the majority but not all of the airway maneuvers on all models for logistical reasons. The total number of attempts for each technique was 30 on the manikin, 292 in the F4L, and 282 on the formalin-fixed cadavers. The operators' median total ranking of each model type as a teaching model was 1 for F4L, 2 for the manikin and, 3 for the formalin-fixed cadavers (P < .001). F4L was considered the best model for mask ventilation (P = .029) and had a higher mean verbal rating score for realism in laryngeal mask airway insertion (P = .043). The F4L and manikin did not differ significantly in other scores for suitability and realism. The formalin-fixed cadaver was ranked last and received lowest scores in all procedures (all P < .001). Success rates of the procedures were highest in the manikin. CONCLUSIONS: F4L cadavers were ranked highest for mask ventilation and were considered the most realistic model for training laryngeal mask insertion. Formalin-fixed cadavers are inappropriate for airway management training.
引用
- van Emden MW, Geurts JJ, Schober P, et al. Comparison of a Novel Cadaver Model (Fix for Life) With the Formalin-Fixed Cadaver and Manikin Model for Suitability and Realism in Airway Management Training. Anesth Analg. 2018. PMID: 30096080. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000003678
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。