环状软骨压迫力量施加的可训练性:一项基于模拟的研究
本研究评估临床医生能否通过培训在环状软骨压迫中持续达到指南推荐的10 N和30 N目标力。基线时400个周期中仅1.3%成功,经教育和自主练习后成功率提升至16%,最后4个周期达45%,但累积和分析显示无一人达到预设熟练阈值。
要点
- 基线时环状软骨压迫达到目标力的成功率极低,仅1.3%。
- 模拟培训可提高成功率,但无人达到预设熟练标准。
- 临床需重视环状软骨压迫力量的规范化培训与反馈。
核心结论
- 基线时临床医生达到指南目标力的表现很差,模拟培训可提高成功率但无人达到预设熟练阈值。
研究设计与样本
- 在Vernier测力板模拟器上评估100名临床医生基线环状软骨压迫表现,其中40名自愿接受教育、自主练习并完成30个1分钟高频模拟周期,用累积和分析评估变化。
主要发现
- 成功几率随时间增加(OR 1.1,P < .001),但累积和分析中无人跨越h0线,即无人达到预设目标力的熟练标准。
关键数值与推荐
- 目标力为意识消失前10±5 N、意识消失后30±5 N,成功周期需4个时间点均在该范围。
临床怎么用
- 模拟培训可改善环状软骨压迫力量控制,但需更强化的训练或反馈手段以达到指南目标。
局限性
- 仅40名参与者接受培训,样本量有限;模拟环境可能不完全代表临床实际。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Aspiration of gastric contents is a leading cause of airway management-related mortality during anesthesia practice. Cricoid pressure (CP) is widely used during rapid sequence induction to prevent aspiration. National guidelines for CP suggest a target force of 10 N before and 30 N after loss of consciousness. However, few studies have rigorously assessed whether clinicians can be trained to consistently achieve these levels of force. We hypothesized that clinicians can be trained effectively to deliver 10-30 N during application of CP. METHODS: Clinicians (attending anesthesiologist, anesthesiology residents, certified registered nurse anesthetists, or operating room nurses) applied CP on a Vernier force plate simulator with measurements taken at 4 time points over 60 seconds, 2 measurements before and 2 measurements after loss of consciousness. A successful cycle required all 4 time points to be within the target range (10 ± 5 and 30 ± 5 N, respectively). After baseline assessment (n = 100 clinicians), a subset of 40 participants volunteered for education on recommended force targets, underwent self-regulated practice, and then performed 30 1-minute cycles of high-frequency simulation analyzed by cumulative sum analysis to assess their change in performance. RESULTS: At baseline, 5 cycles (1.3% [confidence interval {CI}, 0.3%-2.50%]) out of 400 were successful. Performance improved after education and self-regulated practice (16% successful cycles [CI, 7.8%-25%]), and performance during the last 4 of 30 cycles was 45% (CI, 33%-58%). The odds of success increased over time (odds ratio, 1.1; P < .001). By cumulative sum analysis, however, no subject crossed the h0 line, indicating that no one achieved proficiency of the predefined target forces. CONCLUSIONS: At baseline, performance was poor at achieving target forces specified by national guidelines. Simulation-based training improved the success rate, but no participant achieved the predefined threshold for proficiency.
引用
- Noll E, Shodhan S, Varshney A, et al. Trainability of Cricoid Pressure Force Application: A Simulation-Based Study. Anesth Analg. 2019. PMID: 29750692. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000003385
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。