肩关节镜术后选择性肩胛上神经与腋神经阻滞对比肌间沟臂丛阻滞的非劣效性随机对照试验
主要终点为非劣效性(界值1.3分,0-10分制)。结果显示术后前4小时SSB与ISB平均疼痛评分差异大于2.5分(±0.8),8小时降至1.1分(±1.0),夜间及24小时达到非劣效;SSB组前8小时哌替啶用量显著更高,但ISB组呼吸困难和不适感发生率更高,两组满意度相似。
要点
- 肩关节镜术后早期SSB镇痛劣于ISB,前8小时阿片用量更高。
- SSB在术后夜间及24小时疼痛评分与ISB达到非劣效。
- ISB呼吸困难和肌肉无力相关不适发生率更高,满意度两组相似。
核心结论
- 肩胛上-腋神经联合阻滞在肩关节镜术后早期镇痛和减少阿片需求方面劣于肌间沟臂丛阻滞,但呼吸困难和不适感发生率更低。
- 随着阻滞作用消退,两组疼痛评分和阿片消耗差异逐渐缩小,术后第一夜及24小时达到非劣效。
研究设计与样本
- 主要终点为非劣效性,界值为0-10分疼痛评分量表上的1.3分。
- 次要终点包括阿片消耗量、呼吸困难、肌肉无力相关不适和患者满意度。
主要发现
- 术后前4小时SSB与ISB平均疼痛评分差异大于2.5分(±0.8)。
- 疼痛评分差异在8小时逐渐降至1.1分(±1.0),夜间及24小时达到非劣效。
- SSB组术后前8小时哌替啶消耗量显著高于ISB组。
- ISB组呼吸困难和不适感发生率高于SSB组。
- 两组治疗满意度相似。
关键数值与推荐
- 非劣效性界值为0-10分疼痛评分量表上的1.3分。
- 术后前4小时SSB与ISB平均疼痛评分差异大于2.5分(±0.8)。
- 8小时疼痛评分差异为1.1分(±1.0)。
临床怎么用
- SSB可作为肩关节镜术后镇痛的选择,但需注意术后早期镇痛不足和阿片需求增加。
- 对于呼吸困难或肌肉无力相关不适风险较高的患者,SSB可能优于ISB。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: This randomized trial aimed to assess if a combined suprascapular-axillary nerve block (SSB) is noninferior (margin = 1.3 on a 0- to 10-point scale) to interscalene block (ISB) in treating pain after arthroscopic shoulder surgery. Secondary end points included opioid consumption, dyspnea, discomfort associated with muscle weakness, and patient satisfaction. METHODS: One hundred patients undergoing arthroscopic shoulder surgery were randomized to receive ultrasound-guided ISB (n = 50) or SSB (n = 50). Pain intensity at rest, dyspnea, and discomfort were recorded upon arrival in the recovery room, discharge to the ward, and at 4, 8, and 24 hours after surgery. Piritramide consumption was recorded for the first 24 hours. Patient satisfaction was assessed on the second postoperative day. RESULTS: During the first 4 hours after surgery, the difference in mean pain score between SSB and ISB was higher than 2.5 (±0.8). The difference gradually decreased to 1.1 (±1.0) at 8 hours before resulting in noninferiority during the night and at 24 hours. Piritramide consumption was significantly higher in the SSB group in the first 8 hours. The incidence of dyspnea and discomfort was higher after ISB. Treatment satisfaction was similar in both groups. CONCLUSIONS: Suprascapular-axillary nerve block is inferior to ISB in terms of analgesia and opioid requirement in the immediate period after arthroscopic shoulder surgery but is associated with a lower incidence of dyspnea and discomfort. The difference in pain and opioid consumption gradually decreases as the blocks wear off in order to reach similar pain scores during the first postoperative night and at 24 hours. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: This study was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov, identifier NCT02415088.
引用
- Neuts A, Stessel B, Wouters PF, et al. Selective Suprascapular and Axillary Nerve Block Versus Interscalene Plexus Block for Pain Control After Arthroscopic Shoulder Surgery: A Noninferiority Randomized Parallel-Controlled Clinical Trial. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2018. PMID: 29659438. doi:10.1097/AAP.0000000000000777
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。