前路肩胛上神经阻滞、锁骨上神经阻滞与肌间沟神经阻滞用于大型门诊肩关节镜手术的比较:随机双盲非劣效试验
主要结局为疼痛数字评分,非劣效界值为1分。前路肩胛上阻滞的镇痛效果非劣效于肌间沟阻滞,而锁骨上阻滞未达到非劣效;前路肩胛上阻滞对肺功能的保护最佳。
要点
- 前路肩胛上阻滞镇痛非劣效于肌间沟阻滞,锁骨上阻滞未达非劣效。
- 前路肩胛上阻滞组肺活量保留最佳(基线90%),优于肌间沟组(67%)。
- 三组阿片类药物消耗量相似。
核心结论
- 对于大型肩关节镜手术,前路肩胛上阻滞的镇痛效果非劣效于肌间沟阻滞,而锁骨上阻滞未达到非劣效。
- 前路肩胛上神经阻滞对肺功能的保护最佳。
研究设计与样本
- 受试者随机分为肌间沟、锁骨上或前路肩胛上阻滞组,均使用0.5%罗哌卡因15 ml。
- 主要结局为疼痛数字评分,预设非劣效界值为11分制疼痛量表上的1分。
主要发现
- 术后平均疼痛评分:肌间沟组1.9(95%CI 1.3至2.5),锁骨上组2.3(95%CI 1.7至2.9),肩胛上组2.0(95%CI 1.4至2.6)。
- 锁骨上组与肌间沟组平均疼痛评分差为0.4(95%CI -0.4至1.2;非劣效性P=0.088)。
- 肩胛上组与肌间沟组平均疼痛评分差为0.1(95%CI -0.7至0.9;非劣效性P=0.012)。
- 肺活量保留:前路肩胛上组为基线90%(P<0.001),锁骨上组为76%(P=0.002),肌间沟组为67%。
- 三组阿片类药物消耗量相似。
关键数值与推荐
- 非劣效界值为11分制疼痛量表上的1分。
- 前路肩胛上阻滞对比肌间沟阻滞的疼痛评分差为0.1(95%CI -0.7至0.9),非劣效性P=0.012。
- 锁骨上阻滞对比肌间沟阻滞的疼痛评分差为0.4(95%CI -0.4至1.2),非劣效性P=0.088。
临床怎么用
- 对于大型肩关节镜手术,可考虑采用前路肩胛上阻滞替代肌间沟阻滞,以提供非劣效镇痛并更好保留肺功能。
- 锁骨上阻滞在此场景下未证明非劣效于肌间沟阻滞,选择时需权衡。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The interscalene nerve block provides analgesia for shoulder surgery, but is associated with diaphragm paralysis. One solution may be performing brachial plexus blocks more distally. This noninferiority study evaluated analgesia for blocks at the supraclavicular and anterior suprascapular levels, comparing them individually to the interscalene approach. METHODS: One hundred-eighty-nine subjects undergoing arthroscopic shoulder surgery were recruited to this double-blind trial and randomized to interscalene, supraclavicular, or anterior suprascapular block using 15 ml, 0.5% ropivacaine. The primary outcome was numeric rating scale pain scores analyzed using noninferiority testing. The predefined noninferiority margin was one point on the 11-point pain scale. Secondary outcomes included opioid consumption and pulmonary assessments. RESULTS: All subjects completed the study through the primary outcome analysis. Mean pain after surgery was: interscalene = 1.9 (95% CI, 1.3 to 2.5), supraclavicular = 2.3 (1.7 to 2.9), suprascapular = 2.0 (1.4 to 2.6). The primary outcome, mean pain score difference of supraclavicular-interscalene was 0.4 (-0.4 to 1.2; P = 0.088 for noninferiority) and of suprascapular-interscalene was 0.1 (-0.7 to 0.9; P = 0.012 for noninferiority). Secondary outcomes showed similar opioid consumption with better preservation of vital capacity in the anterior suprascapular group (90% baseline [P < 0.001]) and the supraclavicular group (76% [P = 0.002]) when compared to the interscalene group (67%). CONCLUSIONS: The anterior suprascapular block, but not the supraclavicular, provides noninferior analgesia compared to the interscalene approach for major arthroscopic shoulder surgery. Pulmonary function is best preserved with the anterior suprascapular nerve block.
引用
- Auyong DB, Hanson NA, Joseph RS, et al. Comparison of Anterior Suprascapular, Supraclavicular, and Interscalene Nerve Block Approaches for Major Outpatient Arthroscopic Shoulder Surgery: A Randomized, Double-blind, Noninferiority Trial. Anesthesiology. 2018. PMID: 29634491. doi:10.1097/ALN.0000000000002208
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。