全院视频喉镜转换:麻醉与重症监护科室的结构化实施路径
该文描述了某麻醉与重症监护科室将C-MAC视频喉镜推广为全院默认插管技术前的决策与实施过程。科室经培训后强制所有成人手术室插管使用视频喉镜2个月,随后改为广泛可用但非强制。调查显示,试验前仅三分之一麻醉医师认为普遍使用视频喉镜对患者安全等有整体益处,而试验期间及结束后支持率逐步上升至几乎一致,并报告临床表现、教学及团队合作等显著获益。
要点
- 强制使用视频喉镜的正式试验可改变科室认知并达成共识。
- 试验前仅三分之一麻醉医师认可普遍视频喉镜的整体获益。
- 试验后科室同意将C-MAC视频喉镜作为默认插管技术。
核心结论
- 在手术室进行正式且持续时间较长的强制视频喉镜试验,改变了科室认知并达成共识。
- 试验后科室同意在手术室和重症监护室将C-MAC视频喉镜作为默认插管技术,并停止常规使用标准Macintosh喉镜。
研究设计与样本
- 科室采用结构化流程评估转换为普遍视频喉镜的可行性。
- 科室培训后,对全部成人手术室插管强制使用视频喉镜,试验期为2个月。
- 试验期后视频喉镜仍广泛可用但不再强制,期间定期调查麻醉医师和麻醉助理的科室意见。
主要发现
- 试验期前,三分之一的麻醉医师认为普遍视频喉镜对患者安全、团队动力和医疗质量有整体益处。
- 初级和高级麻醉医师的保留意见集中在培训方面。
- 试验期间,麻醉医师和麻醉助理对转换为视频喉镜的支持增加。
- 2个月试验结束6个月后,支持率进一步增长且几乎一致。
- 麻醉医师报告在临床表现、教学和人为因素(尤其是团队合作和情境意识)方面有显著获益。
临床怎么用
- 可参考该结构化试验流程在科室层面推动视频喉镜的普遍应用。
- 试验期间强制使用有助于暴露问题并提升团队支持度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Videolaryngoscopy (VL) is increasingly used, but not yet routine practice, for tracheal intubation. Few departments formally trial equipment before adopting it into practice. We describe the decision-making and implementation processes that our department used when introducing universal VL, with the C-MAC© (Karl Storz, Germany), throughout our anaesthesia and intensive care departments. METHODS: We used a structured process to assess the feasibility of a change to universal VL. After departmental training, we undertook a 2 month trial period of mandating VL for all adult in-theatre intubations. Thereafter, VL remained widely available, but not mandated. We regularly surveyed anaesthetists and anaesthetic assistants to evaluate departmental opinion regarding the introduction of universal VL. RESULTS: Before the trial period, one-third of anaesthetists judged that universal VL would be of overall benefit to patient safety, team dynamics, and quality of care. Reservations from both junior and senior anaesthetists focused on training concerns. Support for a changeover to VL, amongst both anaesthetists and anaesthetic assistants, increased throughout the trial period. Six months after the 2 month trial, support had grown further and was almost unanimous. Anaesthetists reported significant benefits in clinical performance, teaching, and human factors, especially teamwork and situation awareness. CONCLUSIONS: Performing a formal and prolonged trial of mandatory VL in theatre led to changes in perceptions and departmental consensus. As a result of the trial, the department agreed to the use of C-MAC© videolaryngoscopy as the default intubation technique throughout theatres and intensive care, with removal of standard Macintosh laryngoscopes from routine use.
引用
- Cook TM, Boniface NJ, Seller C, et al. Universal videolaryngoscopy: a structured approach to conversion to videolaryngoscopy for all intubations in an anaesthetic and intensive care department. Br J Anaesth. 2017. PMID: 29397126. doi:10.1016/j.bja.2017.11.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。