改良加强型硅胶管在探条与导丝引导下插管的咽喉并发症比较:语音分析新评估
本研究比较了改良加强型硅胶气管导管沿探条与沿导丝引导插管后的咽喉并发症。导丝组术后语音参数未受显著影响,探条组则显著改变。两组首次插管成功率相似。
要点
- 导丝引导插管咽喉主诉发生率显著低于探条引导
- 探条组术后语音参数较术前显著改变,导丝组无显著改变
- 两组首次插管成功率相似
核心结论
- 导丝引导经口气管插管较探条引导者咽喉主诉发生率更低且对语音影响更小。
主要发现
- 探条组咽喉主诉发生率为48.3%(95%CI 35.9-60.9%),导丝组为28.3%(95%CI 18.0-40.6%),p=0.01。
- 术后探条组所有语音参数较术前显著改变(p<0.05),导丝组无显著改变。
- 两组首次插管成功率相似。
临床怎么用
- 在需用半硬质引导器插管时,可优先选择导丝引导以降低咽喉并发症及语音影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Semi-rigid flexible introducer-guided tracheal intubation is associated with pharyngolaryngeal morbidities. We compared the practice of railroading a newly described modified reinforced silicone tracheal tube with a built-in guide channel in its wall over a non-kinking guidewire with railroading the same tube over a disposable bougie, with respect to pharyngolaryngeal morbidities. One hundred and twenty-four ASA 1 and 2 adults were randomly assigned to undergo bougie-guided (n = 62) or wire-guided (n = 62) intubation under general anaesthesia. All patients were assessed for postoperative pharyngolaryngeal complaints. In addition, voice parameters (fundamental frequency, shimmer, jitter and harmonic noise ratio) with vowels 'a' and 'i' were analysed pre-operatively and 24 h postoperatively. The success of first-attempt intubation and the associated haemodynamic response were also recorded. A higher incidence of pharyngolaryngeal complaints was seen in the bougie group, 48.3%, 95%CI (35.9-60.9%) when compared with wire-guided group 28.3%, 95%CI (18.0-40.6%), p = 0.01. Postoperatively, all the voice parameters were significantly more affected when compared with their pre-operative value in the bougie-guided group (p < 0.05) but not in the wire-guided group. The success of first-attempt intubation was similar in both groups. Wire-guided orotracheal intubation was associated with a lower incidence of pharyngolaryngeal complaints and effect on voice when compared with bougie-guided intubation.
引用
- Ponnusamy T, Kundra P, Rudingwa P, et al. Comparison of laryngeal morbidities with modified reinforced silicone tube intubation guided over a bougie vs. a guidewire: novel assessment with voice analysis. Anaesthesia. 2018. PMID: 29411359. doi:10.1111/anae.14236
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。