文献速递产科麻醉

津巴布韦省级、地区与教会医院剖宫产麻醉横断面调查

Anesthesia for Cesarean Delivery: A Cross-Sectional Survey of Provincial, District, and Mission Hospitals in Zimbabwe.
PubMed 文献 · Anesth Analg · 2018-01-01

该横断面调查覆盖津巴布韦8家省级、21家地区和13家教会医院,通过结构化问卷访谈麻醉提供者,评估剖宫产麻醉类型、人员培训及基本药物设备可及性。结果显示椎管内麻醉占81%,但麻醉队伍以护士麻醉师为主且培训不足,安全实践、药物供应和术后镇痛存在明显缺陷。

要点

  • 椎管内麻醉是剖宫产最常用方法(81%),全身麻醉占19%。
  • 麻醉队伍中护士麻醉师占77%,其中19%无正式麻醉培训。
  • 省级医院缺乏处理转诊疑难病例所需的高级麻醉专长。

核心结论

  • 调查发现剖宫产麻醉提供与护理存在可改进之处,省级医院缺乏处理转诊病例所需的高级麻醉专长。
  • 需要加强资深临床医生的指导与监督,以解决安全实践、供应链故障、高母婴发病率与死亡率等问题。
  • 应加强医疗官员和护士麻醉师在领导力、团队合作及并发症管理方面的培训。

研究设计与样本

  • 横断面调查,覆盖津巴布韦8家省级、21家地区和13家教会医院。
  • 采用改编自世界麻醉医师学会联合会和世界卫生组织标准工具的结构化问卷,现场访谈麻醉提供者。

主要发现

  • 麻醉队伍构成为22%医疗官员和77%护士麻醉师;55%护士麻醉师被认可为独立麻醉提供者,26%为助手,19%无正式麻醉培训。
  • 唯一专职麻醉专科医生在省级医院兼职。
  • 访谈前3个月内,剖宫产麻醉中椎管内麻醉占81%,全身麻醉占19%,其中4%为未插管的氯胺酮麻醉。
  • 机构平均剖宫产率为活产的13.6%,但5家地区医院低于5%。
  • 估计机构孕产妇死亡率比为省级573/10万活产、地区251/10万活产、教会医院211/10万活产。

关键数值与推荐

  • 继续存在不安全实践:无安全气道的全身麻醉、椎管内麻醉必需药物短缺、恢复区或手术台倾斜/楔形垫使用不一致、血供不足。
  • 术后镇痛管理报告不充分。

临床怎么用

  • 应优先加强护士麻醉师和医疗官员的培训与监督,推广循证安全实践。
  • 需改善基本麻醉药物供应链、血液供应和术后镇痛管理。
  • 省级医院应提升麻醉专长以处理地区/教会医院转诊的疑难病例。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Cesarean delivery is the most common surgical procedure in low- and middle-income countries, so provision of anesthesia services can be measured in relation to it. This study aimed to assess the type of anesthesia used for cesarean delivery, the level of training of anesthesia providers, and to document the availability of essential anesthetic drugs and equipment in provincial, district, and mission hospitals in Zimbabwe. METHODS: In this cross-sectional survey of 8 provincial, 21 district, and 13 mission hospitals, anesthetic providers were interviewed on site using a structured questionnaire adapted from standard instruments developed by the World Federation of Societies of Anaesthesiologists and the World Health Organization. RESULTS: The anesthetic workforce for the hospitals in this survey constituted 22% who were medical officers and 77% nurse anesthetists (NAs); 55% of NAs were recognized independent anesthetic providers, while 26% were qualified as assistants to anesthetic providers and 19% had no formal training in anesthesia. The only specialist physician anesthetist was part time in a provincial hospital. Spinal anesthesia was the most commonly used method for cesarean delivery (81%) in the 3 months before interview, with 19% general anesthesia of which 4% was ketamine without airway intubation. The mean institutional cesarean delivery rate was 13.6% of live births, although 5 district hospitals were <5%. The estimated institutional maternal mortality ratio was 573 (provincial), 251 (district), and 211 (mission hospitals) per 100,000 live births. Basic monitoring equipment (oximeters, electrocardiograms, sphygmomanometers) was reported available in theatres. Several unsafe practices continue: general anesthesia without a secure airway, shortage of essential drugs for spinal anesthesia, inconsistent use of recovery area or use of table tilt or wedge, and insufficient blood supplies. Postoperative analgesia management was reported inadequate. CONCLUSIONS: This study identified areas where anesthetic provision and care could be improved. Provincial hospitals, where district/mission hospitals refer difficult cases, did not have the higher level anesthesia expertise required to manage these cases. More intensive mentorship and supervision from senior clinicians is essential to address the shortcomings identified in this survey, such as the implementation of evidence-based safe practices, supply chain failures, high maternal morbidity, and mortality. Training of medical officers and NAs should be strengthened in leadership, team work, and management of complications.

来源:Anesth Analg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lonnée HA, Madzimbamuto F, Erlandsen ORM, et al. Anesthesia for Cesarean Delivery: A Cross-Sectional Survey of Provincial, District, and Mission Hospitals in Zimbabwe. Anesth Analg. 2018. PMID: 29293184. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000002733

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。