高频结构化专家反馈对区域麻醉基础介入超声技能学习曲线的影响
本研究将42名受试者随机分为对照组和干预组,参与两项各25次试验的模拟训练,评估高频结构化专家反馈对超声引导区域麻醉中针-超声束对齐和准确接近结构能力的影响。结果显示,与自学相比,专家反馈与更短的学习曲线、更少的技术错误和更长的训练内改善持续时间相关,但训练会话时长增加。
要点
- 高频结构化专家反馈相比自学与更短的学习曲线相关
- 专家反馈与更少的技术错误相关
- 专家反馈与更长的训练内改善持续时间相关,但训练会话时长增加
核心结论
- 高频结构化专家反馈相比自学与更短的学习曲线、更少的技术错误和更长的训练内改善持续时间相关,但训练会话时长增加。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照模拟训练研究,42名受试者随机分为对照组或干预组,参与两项各25次试验的实验。
- 实验1为将针平行于超声束插入牛肌肉体模并保持针全程成像;实验2为针尖接触体模内目标。
- 干预组在试验间接受结构化反馈,对照组在完成试验后接受整体点评。
主要发现
- 实验1学习曲线起始成功率对照组73%、干预组76%,斜率(标准误)分别为0.79%(0.02%)和0.71%(0.04%),平均绝对差异0.18%(95%CI 0.17%-0.19%;P=0)。
- 实验2学习曲线起始成功率对照组43%、干预组80%,斜率(标准误)分别为1.06%(0.02%)和0.42%(0.03%),平均差异0.65%(95%CI 0.64%-0.66%;P=0)。
- 反馈与实验1(平均差异1.55次试验;95%CI 0.15-3;P=0)和实验2(平均差异4.25次试验;95%CI 1.47-7.03;P=0)中更多与学习相关的试验次数相关。
- 反馈与实验1(平均差异0.19;95%CI 0.07-0.30;P=.02)和实验2(平均差异0.58;95%CI 0.45-0.70;P=0)中更低的每次试验技术错误数相关。
- 反馈与实验1(平均差异9.2分钟;95%CI 4.15-14.24分钟;P=.01)和实验2(平均差异7.4分钟;95%CI 1.17-13.59分钟;P=.02)中更长的训练会话时长相关。
临床怎么用
- 在区域麻醉超声引导技能模拟训练中,可考虑采用高频结构化专家反馈以缩短学习曲线并减少技术错误。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Proficiency in needle-to-ultrasound beam alignment and accurate approach to structures are pivotal for ultrasound-guided regional anesthesia. This study evaluated the effects of high-frequency, structured expert feedback on simulation training of such abilities. METHODS: Forty-two subjects randomly allocated as controls or intervention participated in two 25-trial experiments. Experiment 1 consisted of inserting a needle into a bovine muscular phantom parallel to the ultrasound beam while maintaining full imaging of the needle. In experiment 2, the needle aimed to contact a target inside the phantom. Intervention subjects received structured feedback between trials. Controls received a global critique after completing the trials. The slopes of the learning curves derived from the sequences of successes and failures were compared. Change-point analyses identified the start and the end of learning in trial sequences. The number of trials associated with learning, the number of technical errors, and the duration of training sessions were compared between intervention and controls. RESULTS: In experiment 1, learning curves departed from 73% (controls) and 76% (intervention) success rates; slopes (standard error) were 0.79% (0.02%) and 0.71% (0.04), respectively, with mean absolute difference of 0.18% (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.17%-0.19%; P = 0). Intervention subjects' learning curves were shorter and steeper than those of controls. In experiment 2, the learning curves departed from 43% (controls) and 80% (intervention) success rates; slopes (standard error) were 1.06% (0.02%) and 0.42% (0.03%), respectively, with a mean difference of 0.65% (95% CI, 0.64%-0.66%; P = 0). Feedback was associated with a greater number of trials associated with learning in both experiment 1 (mean difference, 1.55 trials; 95% CI, 0.15-3 trials; P = 0) and experiment 2 (mean difference, 4.25 trials; 95% CI, 1.47-7.03 trials; P = 0) and a lower number of technical errors per trial in experiments 1 (mean difference, 0.19; 95% CI, 0.07-0.30; P = .02) and 2 (mean difference, 0.58; 95% CI, 0.45-0.70; P = 0), but longer training sessions in both experiments 1 (mean difference, 9.2 minutes; 95% CI, 4.15-14.24 minutes; P = .01) and 2 (mean difference, 7.4 minutes; 95% CI, 1.17-13.59 minutes; P = .02). CONCLUSIONS: High-frequency, structured expert feedback compared favorably to self-directed learning, being associated with shorter learning curves, smaller number of technical errors, and longer duration of in-training improvement, but increased duration of the training sessions.
引用
- de Oliveira Filho GR, Mettrau FAC. The Effect of High-Frequency, Structured Expert Feedback on the Learning Curves of Basic Interventional Ultrasound Skills Applied to Regional Anesthesia. Anesth Analg. 2018. PMID: 29261545. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000002748
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。