额区α-δ脑电图不排除麻醉中自主反应:孤立前臂试验前瞻性队列研究
该前瞻性队列研究在气管插管后行孤立前臂试验(IFT),记录额区脑电图,分析功率频谱、麻醉深度指数、排列熵等。90例中6例出现自主反应,其中3例在额区α-δ脑电模式下发生,且其功率频谱与无反应者相似(P>0.05)。结论认为额区α-δ脑电图不能排除麻醉中连接意识的存在,脑电参数难以区分有无自主反应。
要点
- 额区α-δ脑电图模式不能排除麻醉中连接意识的发生。
- IFT有反应者与无反应者的脑电功率频谱无显著差异(P>0.05)。
- 衍生麻醉深度指数均不能可靠区分IFT有反应者与无反应者。
核心结论
- 麻醉中额区α-δ脑电图模式下仍可发生连接意识。
- 额区脑电参数不能可靠区分麻醉中自主反应与无反应。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性队列研究,来自三个中心参与国际多中心IFT研究的患者子集,记录气管插管后额区脑电图。
- 共90例患者,分析原始脑电波形功率频谱、麻醉深度指数、排列熵、慢波活动饱和及α-δ幅相耦合。
主要发现
- 90例中6例对言语指令出现自主反应。
- 3例反应发生于插管后即刻,患者(来自Site 1和2)呈现α-δ主导脑电模式(δ功率>20 dB,α功率>10 dB)。
- 这些反应时的功率频谱与同中心无反应者相似(P>0.05)。
- 另3例反应发生于Site 3患者,无经典α-δ脑电模式,反应相对插管较晚,且患者合用氯胺酮和较少挥发性麻醉药。
- 所有衍生麻醉深度指数均不能可靠区分IFT有反应者与无反应者。
关键数值与推荐
- α-δ主导脑电模式定义为δ功率>20 dB且α功率>10 dB。
- IFT有反应者与无反应者功率频谱比较P>0.05。
临床怎么用
- 临床不应仅凭额区α-δ脑电图模式判断患者无连接意识。
- IFT有反应者与无反应者的脑电参数重叠,脑电监测不能替代IFT评估连接意识。
局限性
- 研究为子集分析,样本量有限(90例)。
- Site 3患者合用氯胺酮和较少挥发性麻醉药,与Site 1和2方案不同。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The isolated forearm test (IFT) is the gold standard test of connected consciousness (awareness of the environment) during anaesthesia. The frontal alpha-delta EEG pattern (seen in slow wave sleep) is widely held to indicate anaesthetic-induced unconsciousness. A priori we proposed that one responder with the frontal alpha-delta EEG pattern would falsify this concept. METHODS: Frontal EEG was recorded in a subset of patients from three centres participating in an international multicentre study of IFT responsiveness following tracheal intubation. Raw EEG waveforms were analysed for power-frequency spectra, depth-of-anaesthesia indices, permutation entropy, slow wave activity saturation and alpha-delta amplitude-phase coupling. RESULTS: Volitional responses to verbal command occurred in six out of 90 patients. Three responses occurred immediately following intubation in patients (from Sites 1 and 2) exhibiting an alpha-delta dominant (delta power >20 dB, alpha power >10 dB) EEG pattern. The power-frequency spectra obtained during these responses were similar to those of non-responders (P>0.05) at those sites. A further three responses occurred in (Site 3) patients not exhibiting the classic alpha-delta EEG pattern; these responses occurred later relative to intubation, and in patients had been co-administered ketamine and less volatile anaesthetic compared with Site 1 and 2 patients. None of the derived depth-of-anaesthesia indices could robustly discrimate IFT responders and non-responders. CONCLUSIONS: Connected consciousness can occur in the presence of the frontal alpha-delta EEG pattern during anaesthesia. Frontal EEG parameters do not readily discriminate volitional responsiveness (a marker of connected consciousness) and unresponsiveness during anaesthesia. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: NCT02248623.
引用
- Gaskell AL, Hight DF, Winders J, et al. Frontal alpha-delta EEG does not preclude volitional response during anaesthesia: prospective cohort study of the isolated forearm technique. Br J Anaesth. 2017. PMID: 29121278. doi:10.1093/bja/aex170
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。