肩胛上神经阻滞与肌间沟臂丛阻滞用于肩部手术:系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析纳入16项随机对照试验共1152例患者,比较肩胛上神经阻滞与肌间沟臂丛阻滞在肩部手术中的镇痛效果与安全性。主要结局为术后24小时累积口服吗啡消耗量和静息疼痛评分曲线下面积差异。结果显示两种阻滞在24小时吗啡消耗量上无差异,肌间沟阻滞在恢复室期间疼痛控制更优但副作用更多。
要点
- 肩胛上神经阻滞与肌间沟阻滞在24小时吗啡消耗量上无差异。
- 肌间沟阻滞在恢复室期间疼痛评分降低1.5 cm(95%CI 0.6-2.5 cm),但临床重要性有限。
- 肩胛上神经阻滞的阻滞相关并发症和呼吸系统并发症风险更低。
核心结论
- 肩胛上神经阻滞与肌间沟臂丛阻滞在肩部手术中无临床意义的镇痛差异,但肩胛上神经阻滞副作用更少,可作为有效安全的替代方案。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,检索比较肌间沟臂丛阻滞与肩胛上神经阻滞用于肩部手术的随机对照试验,纳入16项研究共1152例患者,采用随机效应模型合并数据。
主要发现
- 肌间沟阻滞与肩胛上阻滞在术后24小时累积口服吗啡消耗量上无差异。
- 24小时疼痛评分曲线下面积差异有利于肌间沟阻滞1.1 cm/h,但无临床重要性。
- 恢复室期间肌间沟阻滞疼痛评分较肩胛上阻滞降低加权均数差1.5 cm(95%CI 0.6-2.5 cm;P<0.0001),其他时间点疼痛评分无差异。
- 肩胛上阻滞降低了阻滞相关并发症和呼吸系统并发症的比值比。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局:术后24小时累积口服吗啡消耗量和静息疼痛评分曲线下面积差异。
- 恢复室期间疼痛评分加权均数差1.5 cm(95%CI 0.6-2.5 cm;P<0.0001),利于肌间沟阻滞。
- 24小时疼痛评分曲线下面积差异1.1 cm/h,利于肌间沟阻滞但无临床重要性。
临床怎么用
- 肩胛上神经阻滞可作为肌间沟臂丛阻滞的有效安全替代方案用于肩部手术镇痛。
- 需权衡肌间沟阻滞在恢复室期间更优的疼痛控制与其较高的阻滞相关及呼吸系统并发症风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Interscalene block provides optimal shoulder surgery analgesia, but concerns over its associated risks have prompted the search for alternatives. Suprascapular block was recently proposed as an interscalene block alternative, but evidence of its comparative analgesic effect is conflicting. This meta-analysis compares the analgesic effect and safety of suprascapular block versus interscalene block for shoulder surgery. METHODS: Databases were searched for randomized trials comparing interscalene block with suprascapular block for shoulder surgery. Postoperative 24-h cumulative oral morphine consumption and the difference in the area under curve for pooled rest pain scores were designated as primary outcomes. Analgesic and safety outcomes, particularly block-related and respiratory complications, were evaluated as secondary outcomes. Results were pooled using random-effects modeling. RESULTS: Data from 16 studies (1,152 patients) were analyzed. Interscalene block and suprascapular block were not different in 24-h morphine consumption. The difference in area under the curve of pain scores for the 24-h interval favored interscalene block by 1.1 cm/h, but this difference was not clinically important. Compared with suprascapular block, interscalene block reduced postoperative pain but not opioid consumption during recovery room stay by a weighted mean difference (95% CI) of 1.5 cm (0.6 to 2.5 cm; P < 0.0001). Pain scores were not different at any other time. In contrast, suprascapular block reduced the odds of block-related and respiratory complications. CONCLUSIONS: This review suggests that there are no clinically meaningful analgesic differences between suprascapular block and interscalene block except for interscalene block providing better pain control during recovery room stay; however, suprascapular block has fewer side effects. These findings suggest that suprascapular block may be considered an effective and safe interscalene block alternative for shoulder surgery.
引用
- Hussain N, Goldar G, Ragina N, et al. Suprascapular and Interscalene Nerve Block for Shoulder Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Anesthesiology. 2017. PMID: 28968280. doi:10.1097/ALN.0000000000001894
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。