鼻导管联合球囊面罩预给氧:不同氧流量影响的随机交叉研究
该随机交叉研究在健康志愿者中比较单纯球囊面罩(BVM)与BVM联合鼻导管(NC)不同流量(0、5、10、15 L/min)预给氧3分钟后的呼气末氧浓度(ETO2)。结果显示NC-0和NC-5显著降低ETO2,而NC-10与BVM-only无差异,NC-15在1分钟时ETO2更高但2、3分钟无差异。
要点
- 鼻导管0或5 L/min联合BVM会显著降低预给氧效果,应避免。
- 鼻导管至少10 L/min不损害预给氧,15 L/min可能在1分钟时更快达到高ETO2。
- 临床决策需权衡15 L/min鼻导管带来的潜在获益与患者舒适度。
核心结论
- 鼻导管0和5 L/min联合BVM对预给氧有害,应避免使用。
- 鼻导管至少10 L/min不损害预给氧过程,15 L/min可能在1分钟时提供获益但需平衡患者舒适度。
研究设计与样本
- 随机交叉设计研究,在健康志愿者中比较BVM单独与BVM联合鼻导管不同流量(0、5、10、15 L/min)。
- 主要结局为预给氧3分钟后的呼气末氧浓度(ETO2)。
主要发现
- NC-15、NC-10与BVM-only在3分钟时ETO2无差异。
- NC-0和NC-5在所有时间点ETO2显著低于NC-15、NC-10或BVM-only(最小差异NC-5为-7% [95%CI -4%至-10%],NC-0为16% [95%CI 13%-19%])。
- NC-15与BVM-only在1分钟时ETO2差异为7%(95%CI 5%-9%),但2或3分钟时无差异。
- NC-10与NC-15之间ETO2无差异。
临床怎么用
- 预给氧时避免使用鼻导管0或5 L/min联合BVM。
- 如需预给氧期间使用鼻导管,流量至少10 L/min不会损害预给氧效果。
- 15 L/min鼻导管可能加快达到最大ETO2,但需考虑患者舒适度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A critical safety component of emergency anesthesia is the avoidance of hypoxemia during the apneic phase of a rapid sequence intubation. Preoxygenation with a bag valve mask (BVM) or anesthetic circuit may be improved with supplemental oxygen by nasal cannula (NC) if there is a mask leak. In addition, NC is recommended for apneic oxygenation after induction and may be placed before preoxygenation. However, the optimum NC flow rate for preoxygenation or whether the presence of NC alone creates a mask leak remains unclear. METHODS: We performed a randomized crossover study on healthy volunteers comparing BVM alone and BVM with NC flow rates of 0 (NC-0), 5 (NC-5), 10 (NC-10), and 15 (NC-15) liters per minute (lpm). Our primary outcome was end-tidal oxygen (ETO2) after 3-minute preoxygenation. RESULTS: There was no difference in ETO2 between NC-15, NC-10, or BVM-only at 3 minutes. NC-0 and NC-5 recorded significantly lower ETO2 at all times compared with NC-15, NC-10, or BVM-only (least difference NC-5, -7% [95% confidence interval {CI}, -4% to -10%), NC-0, 16% [95% CI, 13%-19%]). There was a difference in ETO2 between NC-15 and BVM-only at 1 minute (7%; 95% CI, 5%-9%), but not at 2 or 3 minutes. There was no difference in ETO2 between NC-10 and NC-15. CONCLUSIONS: Our study found that NC at 0 and 5 lpm with a BVM is deleterious to preoxygenation and should be avoided. In addition, a lack of difference between NC-10 and BVM-only demonstrates that NC at flows of at least 10 lpm should not impair the preoxygenation process. While NC-15 may offer a benefit by reaching maximal ETO2 at 1 minute, this would need to be balanced against patient comfort.
引用
- McQuade D, Miller MR, Hayes-Bradley C, et al. Addition of Nasal Cannula Can Either Impair or Enhance Preoxygenation With a Bag Valve Mask: A Randomized Crossover Design Study Comparing Oxygen Flow Rates. Anesth Analg. 2018. PMID: 28759496. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000002341
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。