文献速递术前评估与围术期医学产科麻醉区域麻醉与超声

平板电子日志记录尼泊尔14名非医生麻醉提供者四千例临床病例与并发症

Tablet e-Logbooks: Four Thousand Clinical Cases and Complications e-Logged by 14 Nondoctor Anesthesia Providers in Nepal.
PubMed 文献 · Anesth Analg · 2017-01-01

该研究在尼泊尔12个地区招募14名非医生麻醉提供者,参加为期1年的远程混合学习课程,要求通过平板电子日志记录所有临床病例。共记录4143例,其中34%为剖宫产且99%采用脊髓麻醉,并发症记录率6%,总死亡率0.1%。结论认为平板电子日志可成功用于农村地区病例、并发症和结局的记录。

要点

  • 平板电子日志在尼泊尔农村非医生麻醉提供者中可行,共记录4143例。
  • 剖宫产占34%,其中99%采用脊髓麻醉;脉搏血氧监测使用率98%。
  • 并发症记录率6%,以循环问题为主(69%);总死亡率0.1%。

核心结论

  • 平板电子麻醉日志在尼泊尔农村成功记录了病例、并发症和结局。
  • 非医生麻醉提供者对记录结局有信任和信心。
  • 该日志能否在特定培训课程之外常规完成仍需测试。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性课程要求记录:14名非医生麻醉提供者在12个地区参加1年远程混合学习课程,通过平板电子日志记录所有临床病例。
  • 日志内容包括麻醉前评估与干预、ASA分级、病例与麻醉类型、监测、并发症、结局及自由文本备注。
  • 病例每月上传至数据库,由麻醉科导师审核所有日志条目。

主要发现

  • 共记录4143例;每名提供者年病例量50至788例,多数在脊髓麻醉下完成。
  • 34%的总病例为剖宫产,其中99%接受脊髓麻醉;胃肠道剖腹术50例(1%)。
  • 6%病例记录并发症,最常见为循环问题(69%),包括脊髓麻醉后低血压和偶发心动过缓。
  • 总死亡率0.1%(共4例),死因包括重度子痫前期、剖腹术后脓毒症及多器官衰竭患者接受小手术。

关键数值与推荐

  • 1%病例录入不完整,无病例详情。
  • 气道并发症通常发生在氯胺酮麻醉下,需基本气道操作;全身麻醉下记录4例困难插管。

临床怎么用

  • 平板电子日志可用于农村非医生麻醉提供者的病例、并发症和结局记录。
  • 该日志可纳入农村非医生麻醉师的持续职业发展项目。

局限性

  • 1%病例录入不完整,无病例详情。
  • 电子日志能否在特定培训课程之外常规完成仍需测试。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: To meet the need for essential surgery across rural Nepal, anesthesia at district level is delivered by nondoctor anesthetists. They require support to maintain confidence and competence, and upgraded professional registration to secure their status. To meet these needs, a distance-blended learning course was pioneered and delivered. A core course requirement was to log all clinical cases; these were logged on a new e-logbook. METHODS: Fourteen nondoctor anesthesia providers working in 12 different districts across Nepal were enrolled in the 1-year course. The course is based on self-completion on a tablet loaded with new learning modules, a resource library, and a case logbook. Continuous educational mentoring was provided by anesthesiologists by phone and email. The logbook included preanesthesia assessment and interventions, American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) grading, types of cases and anesthesia given, monitors used, complications, outcomes and free text remarks. Cases were uploaded monthly to a database, and mentors reviewed all logbook entries. RESULTS: The 14 nondoctor anesthesia providers were widely distributed across the country in district, zonal, community, and mission hospitals, and had different levels of clinical experience and caseloads. Logbooks and uploads were regularly completed without difficulty; 1% cases were entered incompletely with no case details provided. A total of 4143 cases were recorded. Annual caseload per nondoctor anesthesia provider ranged from 50 to 788, the majority of which were under spinal anesthesia; 34% of the total cases were cesarean deliveries, of which 99% received spinal anesthesia. Fifty gastrointestinal laparotomies (1% total) were recorded. Ninety-one percent of cases were ASA I, 0.8% ASA III/IV. Pulse oximetry was used in 98% of cases. Complications were recorded in 6% of cases; the most common were circulation problems (69%) including hypotension and occasional bradycardia after spinal anesthesia. Airway complications were usually under ketamine anesthesia requiring basic airway maneuvers; 4 difficult intubations were recorded under general anesthesia. Anesthesia outcomes were good with overall mortality of 0.1% (total 4 cases). Causes of death included severe preeclampsia, sepsis postlaparotomy, and patients with multiorgan failure for minor procedure. CONCLUSIONS: The tablet-based electronic anesthesia logbook was successfully used to record cases, complications, and outcomes across rural Nepal. The nondoctor anesthesia providers had trust and confidence in recording outcomes. It remains to be tested whether an e-logbook would be routinely completed outside of a specific training course. Such a logbook could be incorporated into all continuous professional development programs for rural nondoctor anesthetists.

来源:Anesth Analg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Shah S, Ross O, Pickering S, et al. Tablet e-Logbooks: Four Thousand Clinical Cases and Complications e-Logged by 14 Nondoctor Anesthesia Providers in Nepal. Anesth Analg. 2017. PMID: 28504991. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000002094

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。