英国视频喉镜的国家调查
该调查于2014年1月截止,向英国所有国民健康服务体系医院发放电子问卷,以了解视频喉镜的配备、使用和态度。结果显示,91%的手术室配备视频喉镜,但重症监护室和产科手术室约50%,急诊科、儿科麻醉和独立部门医院配备率更低。大约七分之一受访者报告所有临床区域均配备视频喉镜。多数科室对使用有限制,设备选择和结构化引入不常见,普及程度差异大。大多数医院需改变实践以符合现行指南。
要点
- 视频喉镜在91%手术室配备,但ICU和产科仅约50%,急诊和儿科更低。
- 仅约七分之一受访者报告所有临床区域均配备视频喉镜。
- 多数科室限制使用,设备选择和结构化引入不常见。
核心结论
- 视频喉镜在多数医院主要手术部门可用,但其他地点不足一半。
- 设备、引入方法、使用和临床采纳存在显著差异。
- 大多数医院需改变实践以符合现行指南。
研究设计与样本
- 电子问卷调查英国所有国民健康服务体系医院,2014年1月截止,回复率67%。
主要发现
- 视频喉镜在91%手术室可用,约50%重症监护室和产科手术室可用。
- 急诊科、儿科麻醉和独立部门医院可用性更低。
- 最广泛可用的设备是Airtraq、GlideScope和C-MAC。
- 约七分之一受访者报告所有临床区域均有视频喉镜可用。
- 多数科室对视频喉镜使用施加限制,尤其是ICU和急诊科。
临床怎么用
- 需提高视频喉镜在其他临床区域(如ICU、急诊、产科)的配备。
- 应基于文献或正式试验选择设备,并结构化引入实践。
- 需改变实践以符合困难气道协会2015年指南。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND.: There are increasing numbers of videolaryngoscopes marketed and increasing interest in the technology. The Difficult Airway Society's 2015 guidelines recommend that videolaryngoscopes should be immediately available at all times and that all anaesthetists should be trained and skilled in their use. METHODS.: An electronic survey was sent to all UK National Health Service hospitals to examine availability, use, and attitudes to videolaryngoscopy, and closed in January 2014. RESULTS.: The return rate was 67%. Videolaryngoscopy was available in 91% of operating theatres, ∼50% of intensive care units (ICUs) and obstetric theatres, with lower availability in emergency departments (EDs), paediatric anaesthesia, and independent sector hospitals. The most widely available devices were the Airtraq, the GlideScope, and C-MAC. Approximately one in seven respondents reported availability of videolaryngoscopy in all clinical areas. Most departments imposed restrictions on videolaryngoscopy use, especially the ICU and ED. Device selection was only infrequently based on published literature or formal trial. Structured introduction of videolaryngoscopy into practice was uncommon. Penetration of videolaryngoscopy was highly variable; fewer than a third reported widespread use or enthusiasm, although this increased where the C-MAC and GlideScope were widely available. CONCLUSIONS.: Videolaryngoscopy is available in most hospitals' main operating departments, but in fewer than half of other locations. There is marked variation in device, methods of introduction, usage, and clinical adoption. Most hospitals need to change practice to comply with current guidelines. Selection and implementation vary widely.
引用
- Cook TM, Kelly FE. A national survey of videolaryngoscopy in the United Kingdom. Br J Anaesth. 2017. PMID: 28403414. doi:10.1093/bja/aex052
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。