文献速递气道管理

视频喉镜下三种声门视野评分系统的准确性及信度比较

Accuracy, intra- and inter-rater reliability of three scoring systems for the glottic view at videolaryngoscopy.
PubMed 文献 · Anaesthesia · 2017-03-24

本研究比较了Cormack-Lehane、POGO和Fremantle三种评分系统在视频喉镜插管声门视野记录中的表现,由74名重症监护医生对30段匿名视频进行评分。结果显示POGO和Fremantle评分的准确性及评分者间信度均高于Cormack-Lehane,其中Fremantle评分还能提供插管难易信息。

要点

  • POGO与Fremantle评分准确性高于Cormack-Lehane。
  • Fremantle评分者间信度与POGO相当,均优于Cormack-Lehane。
  • Fremantle评分额外反映插管难易,支持其常规使用。

核心结论

  • POGO和Fremantle评分在视频喉镜声门视野记录中优于Cormack-Lehane评分。

研究设计与样本

  • 74名重症监护医生对30段匿名视频喉镜插管视频进行三种评分系统评分。

主要发现

  • 准确性:POGO 75.5%,Fremantle 73.9%,均高于Cormack-Lehane 65.4%(p < 0.001)。
  • 评分者内信度:Fremantle 0.796,Cormack-Lehane 0.773,均高于POGO 0.693。
  • 评分者间信度:Fremantle 0.618与POGO 0.614相似,均高于Cormack-Lehane 0.464(p < 0.001)。

临床怎么用

  • 记录视频喉镜插管声门视野时,可优先选用POGO或Fremantle评分。
  • Fremantle评分可额外提供插管难易信息,支持其常规使用。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

An accurate and reproducible recording of laryngoscopic view at tracheal intubation is an important aspect of anaesthetic practice. Unlike direct laryngoscopy, in which the view achieved by the line of sight directly relates to the ease of intubating the trachea, videolaryngoscopy can create a situation in which the view is good, but intubation difficult or impossible. Communicating this to a subsequent anaesthetist is important. We compared three scoring systems: Cormack and Lehane; POGO (percentage of glottic opening); and the Fremantle score, as used by 74 critical care doctors rating 30 anonymised videos of videolaryngoscopic intubations. Accuracy (degree of agreement of score with an expert panel assessment) was higher for POGO (75.5%) and the Fremantle score (73.9%) than for Cormack and Lehane (65.4%; p < 0.001). Intra-rater reliability (mean free marginal Kappa for ordinal scores and mean Cronbach's Alpha for continuous score) was higher for Fremantle score (0.796) and Cormack and Lehane (0.773) than POGO (0.693). Inter-rater reliability for Fremantle score (0.618) and POGO (0.614) were similar and higher than the inter-rater reliability of Cormack and Lehane 0.464 (p < 0.001). The higher accuracy and inter-rater reliability of POGO and the Fremantle score suggest they are preferable to Cormack and Lehane for use when documenting videolaryngoscopy. The additional information about ease of intubation conveyed by the Fremantle score may support its routine use in recording videolaryngoscopic intubation.

来源:Anaesthesia,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. O'Loughlin EJ, Swann AD, English JD, et al. Accuracy, intra- and inter-rater reliability of three scoring systems for the glottic view at videolaryngoscopy. Anaesthesia. 2017. PMID: 28337769. doi:10.1111/anae.13837

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。