儿科麻醉后恢复室心跳骤停罕见但可预防:Wake Up Safe 数据分析
该研究基于 Wake Up Safe 多中心儿科麻醉不良事件登记数据库,分析 26 例麻醉后恢复室(PACU)儿科心跳骤停(CA)事件。67% 发生于 5 岁以下儿童,30% 为婴儿;69% 被判定为很可能或几乎确定可预防,且均为呼吸源性。呼吸源性 CA 多无伤害,心脏源性 CA 与更高伤害水平相关。结论认为 PACU 儿科 CA 罕见且多可存活,但多数可预防,提示术后早期需加强监测。
要点
- PACU 儿科 CA 罕见,69% 被判定为很可能或几乎确定可预防。
- 可预防 CA 均为呼吸源性,根因常涉及判断/经验不足、监督不足和事务优先级竞争。
- 心脏源性 CA 与更高伤害水平相关,呼吸源性 CA 多无伤害。
核心结论
- PACU 儿科 CA 事件罕见且总体可存活,呼吸源性事件结局更好,但多数被判定为可预防。
- 建议在术后早期保持警惕,转运至 PACU 期间维持监测并由麻醉照护者持续照护至麻醉苏醒,可能进一步降低可预防的心脏骤停率。
研究设计与样本
- 基于 Wake Up Safe 儿科麻醉质量改进倡议的多中心儿科麻醉不良事件登记数据库的病例系列分析。
- 共纳入 26 例 PACU 儿科 CA 事件,提取人口学、基础疾病、CA 原因和结局,采用描述性统计。
主要发现
- 26 例 CA 事件中,67% 发生于 5 岁以下儿童,30% 为婴儿(<1 岁)。
- 18 例(69%)被判定为很可能或几乎确定可预防,所有可预防 CA 均为呼吸源性。
- 可预防 CA 中多数(67%)的推定根因包括提供者判断或经验不足、监督不足和事务优先级竞争。
- 心脏源性 CA 与更高伤害水平(暂时性或更严重)相关,呼吸源性 CA 更常无伤害。
关键数值与推荐
- 可预防 CA 判定:18/26(69%)被判定为很可能或几乎确定可预防。
- 可预防 CA 均为呼吸源性;其中 67% 的推定根因涉及提供者判断或经验不足、监督不足和事务优先级竞争。
- 心脏源性 CA 与更高伤害水平(暂时性或更严重)相关,呼吸源性 CA 更常无伤害。
临床怎么用
- 术后早期应加强监测和警惕,尤其针对 5 岁以下儿童及婴儿。
- 转运至 PACU 期间维持监测,并由麻醉照护者持续照护至麻醉苏醒,可能降低可预防的心脏骤停率。
- 多中心协作可能有助于深入理解有效的心脏骤停预防策略。
局限性
- 各报告机构开展的根因分析仅提供有限见解。
- 研究为病例系列描述性分析,样本量有限(26 例),可能限制结论外推。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Nearly 20% of anesthesia-related pediatric cardiac arrests (CAs) occur during emergence or recovery. The aims of this case series were to use the Wake Up Safe database to describe the following: (1) the nature of pediatric postanesthesia care unit (PACU) CA and subsequent outcomes and (2) factors associated with harm after pediatric PACU CA. METHODS: Pediatric CAs in the PACU were identified from the Wake Up Safe Pediatric Anesthesia Quality Improvement Initiative, a multicenter registry of adverse events in pediatric anesthesia. Demographics, underlying conditions, cause of CA, and outcomes were extracted. Descriptive statistics were used to characterize data and to assess risk of harm in those suffering CA. RESULTS: A total of 26 CA events were included: 67% in children <5 years, and 30% in infants (<1 year); 18 (69%) were deemed likely or almost certainly preventable. All preventable CAs were respiratory in nature and most (67%) had purported root causes that included provider judgment or inexperience, inadequate supervision, and competing priorities. CAs of cardiac origin were associated with increased level of harm (temporary or greater), whereas those of respiratory origin were associated more often with no harm. CONCLUSIONS: PACU CA events are rare and generally survivable, with better outcomes for respiratory-based events, but most were deemed preventable, suggesting a need for further vigilance in the early postoperative period. Maintenance of monitoring during patient transport to PACU and continuing care by anesthesia care providers until emergence from anesthesia may further reduce the preventable arrest rate. The root cause analyses conducted by individual institutions reporting these data to the Wake Up Safe provided only limited insight, so multicenter collaborative approaches may allow for greater insight into effective CA-prevention strategies.
引用
- Christensen RE, Haydar B, Voepel-Lewis TD, et al. Pediatric Cardiopulmonary Arrest in the Postanesthesia Care Unit, Rare but Preventable: Analysis of Data From Wake Up Safe, The Pediatric Anesthesia Quality Improvement Initiative. Anesth Analg. 2017. PMID: 28166099. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000001744
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。