文献速递术前评估与围术期医学

基于需求的麻醉科住院医师在线反馈工具的实施及其与ACGME里程碑的映射

Implementation of a Needs-Based, Online Feedback Tool for Anesthesia Residents With Subsequent Mapping of the Feedback to the ACGME Milestones.
PubMed 文献 · Anesth Analg · 2017-01-01

本研究通过焦点小组定义最佳反馈特征,开发并实施在线反馈工具,并将反馈内容映射至ACGME麻醉学里程碑。焦点小组揭示反馈的三大障碍:不及时、不具体、过多无效评价。

要点

  • 住院医师认为理想反馈应 timely、specific 且结构化。
  • 在线反馈工具使用率低于预期,提示行为文化改变需多步骤。
  • 自由文本反馈可映射至ACGME里程碑,辅助评估。

核心结论

  • 基于焦点小组开发的在线反馈工具可行,其自由文本评论可映射至ACGME麻醉学里程碑,但工具使用率低于预期。

主要发现

  • 焦点小组揭示良好反馈的三大障碍:反馈太晚、太泛、太多无效评价。
  • 反馈工具使用:每位住院医师平均4.03次(标准差5.08,中位数2,范围1-21,四分位距1-4);每位教师平均1.98次(标准差3.2,中位数1,范围1-25,四分位距1-2)。
  • 针对「住院医师表现良好的具体学习目标」项,产生296条里程碑特异性回应:71.3%涉及患者照护能力,最常见为麻醉计划与实施(35.8%)和气道管理(11.1%);10.5%涉及人际沟通技巧;8.4%涉及基于实践的学习和改进。
  • 针对「住院医师可改进的具体学习目标」项:67.0%涉及患者照护,最常见为麻醉计划与实施(33.5%),其次为监测设备使用/解读(8.5%)和气道管理(8.5%);10.2%涉及基于实践的学习和改进;9.7%涉及基于系统的实践。

临床怎么用

  • 麻醉科可借鉴此在线反馈工具,鼓励及时、具体的书面反馈,并将评论映射至ACGME里程碑以辅助评估。

局限性

  • 反馈工具使用率低于预期,可能反映行为和文化改变需多步骤实施。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Optimizing feedback that residents receive from faculty is important for learning. The goals of this study were to (1) conduct focus groups of anesthesia residents to define what constitutes optimal feedback; (2) develop, test, and implement a web-based feedback tool; and (3) then map the contents of the written comments collected on the feedback tool to the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) anesthesiology milestones. METHODS: All 72 anesthesia residents in the program were invited to participate in 1 of 5 focus groups scheduled over a 2-month period. Thirty-seven (51%) participated in the focus groups and completed a written survey on previous feedback experiences. On the basis of the focus group input, an initial online feedback tool was pilot-tested with 20 residents and 62 feedback sessions, and then a final feedback tool was deployed to the entire residency to facilitate the feedback process. The completed feedback written entries were mapped onto the 25 ACGME anesthesiology milestones. RESULTS: Focus groups revealed 3 major barriers to good feedback: (1) too late such as, for example, at the end of month-long clinical rotations, which was not useful because the feedback was delayed; (2) too general and not specific enough to immediately remedy behavior; and (3) too many in that the large number of evaluations that existed that were unhelpful such as those with unclear behavioral anchors compromised the overall feedback culture. Thirty residents (42% of 72 residents in the program) used the final online feedback tool with 121 feedback sessions with 61 attendings on 15 rotations at 3 hospital sites. The number of feedback tool uses per resident averaged 4.03 (standard deviation 5.08, median 2, range 1-21, 25th-75th % quartile 1-4). Feedback tool uses per faculty averaged 1.98 (standard deviation 3.2, median 1, range 1-25, 25th-75th % quartile 1-2). For the feedback question item "specific learning objective demonstrated well by the resident," this yielded 296 milestone-specific responses. The majority (71.3%) were related to the patient care competency, most commonly the anesthetic plan and conduct (35.8%) and airway management (11.1%) milestones; 10.5% were related to the interpersonal and communication skills competency, most commonly the milestones communication with other professionals (4.4%) or with patients and families (4.4%); and 8.4% were related to the practice-based learning and improvement competency, most commonly self-directed learning (6.1%). For the feedback tool item "specific learning objective that resident may improve," 67.0% were related to patient care, most commonly anesthetic plan and conduct (33.5%) followed by use/interpretation of monitoring and equipment (8.5%) and airway management (8.5%); 10.2% were related to practice-based learning and improvement, most commonly self-directed learning (6.8%); and 9.7% were related to the systems-based practice competency. CONCLUSIONS: Resident focus groups recommended that feedback be timely and specific and be structured around a tool. A customized online feedback tool was developed and implemented. Mapping of the free-text feedback comments may assist in assessing milestones. Use of the feedback tool was lower than expected, which may indicate that it is just 1 of many implementation steps required for behavioral and culture change to support a learning environment with frequent and useful feedback.

来源:Anesth Analg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Tanaka P, Bereknyei Merrell S, Walker K, et al. Implementation of a Needs-Based, Online Feedback Tool for Anesthesia Residents With Subsequent Mapping of the Feedback to the ACGME Milestones. Anesth Analg. 2017. PMID: 28099326. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000001647

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。