围术期医学中荟萃分析与后续大型随机试验显著结果的一致性差
该研究在围术期医学与麻醉领域识别了2000年后发表的18项大型随机对照试验(n≥1000)及44项先前荟萃分析,比较两者对同一干预和人群的主要 morbid 终点显著性(P<0.05)。结果显示仅61.4%的结果被正确预测,荟萃分析阳性结果的比值比为3.6(P=0.033),阳性预测值22.7%,阴性预测值85.7%,Kappa=0.094提示一致性轻微。
要点
- 荟萃分析预测后续大型RCT显著性的正确率仅61.4%。
- 荟萃分析更易得出阳性结果(OR=3.6,P=0.033),阳性预测值仅22.7%。
- 基于荟萃分析结果做围术期临床决策需谨慎。
核心结论
- 荟萃分析在围术期医学中预测后续大型RCT显著结果的一致性差,存在阳性结果倾向且不能归因于研究功效差异。
研究设计与样本
- 通过Medline和PubMed识别2000年后发表的大型RCT(n≥1000)及先前研究相同干预和人群的荟萃分析,共纳入18项大型RCT和44项荟萃分析,涉及16种干预。
主要发现
- 在57个可比较的终点中,35个被最大的近期荟萃分析正确预测(61.4%)。
- 荟萃分析相比后续大型RCT出现显著结果的比值比为3.6(P=0.033,Bonferroni校正)。
- 荟萃分析的阳性预测值为22.7%,阴性预测值为85.7%,Kappa=0.094提示一致性轻微。
- 大型RCT的中位研究样本量为4482例,大于荟萃分析的1389例(P<0.0001),但两者各终点的估计功效相似。
临床怎么用
- 在麻醉和围术期医学中,基于荟萃分析结果进行临床决策时应保持谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The reliability of meta-analysis (MA) in predicting the findings of subsequent large randomized controlled trials (RCTs) has not been assessed in perioperative medicine and anaesthesia. METHODS: Using Medline and PubMed, large RCTs (n≥1000) published since 2000 in the anaesthesia and perioperative medicine/critical care literature were identified. All previous MAs of RCTs investigating the same intervention and population were sourced. For all reported major morbid endpoints common to each, results (significant/non-significant P<0.05) were compared. RESULTS: 18 large RCTs and 44 prior MAs investigating the effects of 16 interventions were identified. Where endpoint results in the large RCTs were each compared with the single largest recent preceding MA, 35 of a total of 57 outcomes were predicted correctly by the MAs (61.4%). The odds ratio for a significant result from MA compared with the subsequent large RCT was 3.6, P=0.033 Bonferroni corrected. The positive predictive value of MAs was 22.7%; the negative predictive value was 85.7%, Kappa was 0.094 indicating slight agreement. The estimated power for each endpoint for large RCTs and MAs were similar, but the median study size for large RCTs was larger than that of the MAs, n=4,482 vs 1,389, P<0.0001. CONCLUSIONS: There was a strong tendency towards positive findings in MA not substantiated by subsequent large RCTs, which was not attributable to differences in study power. This finding suggests caution in clinical decision-making in anaesthesia and perioperative medicine based on findings of meta-analysis.
引用
- Sivakumar H, Peyton PJ. Poor agreement in significant findings between meta-analyses and subsequent large randomized trials in perioperative medicine. Br J Anaesth. 2016. PMID: 28077529. doi:10.1093/bja/aew170
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。