神经刺激对超声引导下收肌管下段隐神经阻滞成功率的影响:随机对照试验
该随机单盲平行组试验纳入80例足踝手术患者,比较单纯超声引导与联合神经刺激行收肌管下段隐神经阻滞的成功率。主要终点为30分钟时两个解剖区域针刺感觉完全消失,两组分别为55%与45%,差异无统计学意义(P=0.25)。结论为加用神经刺激未提高阻滞成功率,但神经刺激未引出反应与阻滞失败相关。
要点
- 加用神经刺激未显著提高超声引导下收肌管下段隐神经阻滞30分钟完全无感觉成功率。
- 神经刺激组20%患者5分钟内未引出隐神经分布反应,其中3例30分钟感觉正常。
- 两组阻滞失败率分别为7.5%(神经刺激组)与2.5%(超声组)。
核心结论
- 加用神经刺激未提高超声引导下收肌管下段隐神经阻滞的成功率。
- 神经刺激组中无法引出「敲击」感与阻滞失败相关。
研究设计与样本
- 随机、单盲、平行组临床试验,纳入80例足踝手术患者,每组40例。
- 超声组仅用超声引导,神经刺激组联合神经刺激(时限5分钟),均注射10 mL 0.5%罗哌卡因。
- 主要终点为30分钟时两个解剖区域针刺感觉完全消失。
主要发现
- 30分钟时两个区域任何阻滞证据(感觉减退或完全消失)的比例分别为92.5%(神经刺激组)与97.5%(超声组)(P=0.62[双侧])。
- 相应失败率(感觉正常)分别为7.5%(神经刺激组)与2.5%(超声组)。
- 神经刺激组20%(n=8)在5分钟刺激时限内未引出隐神经分布反应,该亚组包含全部3例30分钟感觉正常者。
临床怎么用
- 超声引导下收肌管下段隐神经阻滞可单独使用超声,加用神经刺激未显示额外获益。
- 若使用神经刺激,5分钟内未引出隐神经分布反应提示阻滞失败风险较高。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Ultrasound-guided subsartorial saphenous nerve block is commonly used to provide complete surgical anesthesia of the foot and ankle in combination with a popliteal sciatic nerve block. However, in part owing to its small caliber and absence of a prominent vascular landmark in the subsartorial plane distal to the adductor canal, the saphenous nerve is more difficult to reliably block than the sciatic nerve in the popliteal fossa. Although the saphenous nerve is a sensory nerve only, neurostimulation can be used to elicit a "tapping" sensation on the anteromedial aspect of the lower leg extending toward the medial malleolus. Our objective was to test the hypothesis that the addition of nerve stimulation use to an ultrasound (US)-guided technique will increase the success rate of subsartorial saphenous nerve block. METHODS: With institutional human ethics board approval and participants' written informed consent, we enrolled 80 patients undergoing foot and ankle surgery in a randomized, single-blinded, parallel-group clinical trial. Patients were randomly assigned to receive US-guided subsartorial saphenous nerve block either alone (US group) or with the use of additional nerve stimulation (NS group; time limit, 5 minutes). For saphenous nerve blockade, all patients received 10 mL of 0.5% ropivacaine. The primary end point was complete absence of sensation to pinprick at 30 minutes at two different anatomic areas in the distribution of the saphenous nerve (2 cm proximal to the medial malleolus and 10 cm distal to the medial tibial condyle). Secondary end points included decreased sensation at 30 minutes and block failure (normal sensation) at 30 minutes. This trial was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT02382744. RESULTS: All 80 patients completed the trial (40 patients in each group). Twenty-two patients (55%) in the NS group versus 18 (45%) in the US group had complete absence of sensation to pinprick at 30 minutes at both anatomic areas of assessment (Fisher exact test, P = 0.25 [one sided]; 95% confidence interval of difference in proportions, -11.9% to 31.9%). The percentages of patients with any evidence of block (decreased or complete absence of sensation) at both areas at 30 minutes were 92.5% (NS) and 97.5% (US), respectively (P = 0.62 [two sided]); corresponding failure rates (normal sensation) were 7.5% (NS) and 2.5% (US). In the NS group, no response in the saphenous nerve distribution was elicited within 5 minutes of stimulation time limit in 20% of patients (n = 8). All of the patients in the NS group with normal sensation at 30 minutes (n = 3) were among this subcohort. CONCLUSIONS: The addition of the use of nerve stimulation did not improve the success rate of US-guided subsartorial saphenous nerve block. However, in the NS group, an inability to elicit a "tapping" sensation in the saphenous nerve distribution was associated with block failure.
引用
- Montgomery SH, Shamji CM, Yi GS, et al. Effect of Nerve Stimulation Use on the Success Rate of Ultrasound-Guided Subsartorial Saphenous Nerve Block: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2017. PMID: 27902645. doi:10.1097/AAP.0000000000000522
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。