C-MAC可视喉镜与直接喉镜在急诊快速序贯插管中的随机对照试验
在瑞士苏黎世大学医院急诊科开展的随机对照试验,纳入150例需紧急快速序贯插管的患者,1:1随机分配至C-MAC可视喉镜组或直接喉镜组。结果显示两组首次插管成功率无差异,C-MAC组声门视野(Cormack-Lehane评分)显著更优,但插管时间相似。
要点
- C-MAC可视喉镜未提高急诊快速序贯插管的首次成功率,可能因操作者均为经验丰富的麻醉顾问。
- C-MAC组声门视野(Cormack-Lehane评分)显著优于直接喉镜组。
- 两组插管时间相似,C-MAC组为32±11秒,直接喉镜组为31±9秒。
核心结论
- C-MAC可视喉镜改善了声门视野,但未提高首次插管成功率,可能与参与操作的麻醉顾问经验丰富有关。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,在瑞士苏黎世大学医院急诊科开展,前瞻性纳入150例18至99岁需紧急快速序贯插管的患者,1:1随机分配至C-MAC可视喉镜组或直接喉镜组。
- 排除颌面部创伤、颈椎固定、已知困难气道或正在心肺复苏的患者;所有插管由三名经验丰富的麻醉顾问之一完成。
主要发现
- C-MAC组74例中73例首次插管成功,直接喉镜组73例全部首次成功(P=1.0)。
- 插管时间两组相似(32±11 vs. 31±9秒,P=0.51)。
- C-MAC组Cormack-Lehane评分显著优于直接喉镜组(P<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 在操作者经验丰富的急诊快速序贯插管中,C-MAC可视喉镜可改善声门视野,但首次插管成功率与直接喉镜相当。
局限性
- 排除颌面部创伤、颈椎固定、已知困难气道或正在心肺复苏的患者,限制了结果在外推至这些人群时的适用性。
- 所有插管均由三名经验丰富的麻醉顾问完成,结论可能不适用于经验较少的操作者。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Airway management in the emergency room can be challenging when patients suffer from life-threatening conditions. Mental stress, ignorance of the patient's medical history, potential cervical injury or immobilisation and the presence of vomit and/or blood may also contribute to a difficult airway. Videolaryngoscopes have been introduced into clinical practice to visualise the airway and ultimately increase the success rate of airway management. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to test the hypothesis that the C-MAC videolaryngoscope improves first-attempt intubation success rate compared with direct laryngoscopy in patients undergoing emergency rapid sequence intubation in the emergency room setting. DESIGN: A randomised clinical trial. SETTING: Emergency Department of the University Hospital, Zurich, Switzerland. PATIENTS: With approval of the local ethics committee, we prospectively enrolled 150 patients between 18 and 99 years of age requiring emergency rapid sequence intubation in the emergency room of the University Hospital Zurich. Patients were randomised (1 : 1) to undergo tracheal intubation using the C-MAC videolaryngoscope or by direct laryngoscopy. INTERVENTIONS: Owing to ethical considerations, patients who had sustained maxillo-facial trauma, immobilised cervical spine, known difficult airway or ongoing cardiopulmonary resuscitation were excluded from our study. All intubations were performed by one of three very experienced anaesthesia consultants. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: First-attempt success rate served as our primary outcome parameter. Secondary outcome parameters were time to intubation; total number of intubation attempts; Cormack and Lehane score; inadvertent oesophageal intubation; ease of intubation; complications including violations of the teeth, injury/bleeding of the larynx/pharynx and aspiration/regurgitation of gastric contents; necessity of using further alternative airway devices for successful intubation; maximum decrease of oxygen saturation and technical problems with the device. RESULTS: A total of 150 patients were enrolled, but three patients had to be excluded from the analysis, resulting in 74 patients in the C-MAC videolaryngoscopy group and 73 patients in the direct laryngoscopy group. Tracheal intubation was achieved successfully at the first attempt in 73 of 74 patients in the C-MAC group and all patients in the direct laryngoscopy group (P = 1.0). Time to intubation was similar (32 ± 11 vs. 31 ± 9 s, P = 0.51) in both groups. Visualisation of the vocal cords, represented as the Cormack and Lehane score, was significantly better using the C-MAC videolaryngoscope (P < 0.001). CONCLUSION: Our study demonstrates that visualisation of the vocal cords was improved by using the C-MAC videolaryngoscope compared with direct laryngoscopy. Better visualisation did not improve first-attempt success rate, which in turn was probably based on the high level of experience of the participating anaesthesia consultants. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Clinicaltrials.gov identifier NCT02297113.
引用
- Sulser S, Ubmann D, Schlaepfer M, et al. C-MAC videolaryngoscope compared with direct laryngoscopy for rapid sequence intubation in an emergency department: A randomised clinical trial. Eur J Anaesthesiol. 2016. PMID: 27533711
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。