尸体研究比较三种纤维支气管镜辅助将声门上气道转换为带套囊气管导管的技术
本研究在尸体上比较三种纤维支气管镜辅助将标准LMA Unique声门上气道转换为带套囊气管导管的技术,主要终点为插管时间。直接气管导管技术平均37秒,显著短于Aintree导管技术70秒和导丝技术126秒(p<0.001)。直接气管导管和Aintree技术均快速简便,导丝技术不推荐。
要点
- 直接气管导管技术插管时间最短(37秒),优于Aintree(70秒)和导丝技术(126秒)。
- 直接气管导管和Aintree技术均被多数操作者评为容易或非常容易。
- 导丝技术耗时最长且评价最低,不应推荐使用。
核心结论
- 直接气管导管技术和Aintree技术均为快速且简便的声门上气道转换为带套囊气管导管的方法。
- 导丝技术不能推荐使用。
研究设计与样本
- 尸体研究,比较三种纤维支气管镜辅助技术将标准LMA® Unique转换为带套囊气管导管。
- 主要终点为插管时间,次要终点为成功率、感知难度和首选技术。
主要发现
- 直接气管导管技术平均插管时间37秒(95%CI 31-42),显著短于Aintree技术70秒(95%CI 60-80)和导丝技术126秒(95%CI 110-141)(p<0.001)。
- 13/24参与者首选直接气管导管技术,11/24首选Aintree技术。
- 感知为非常容易或容易的比例:直接气管导管技术23/24,Aintree技术21/24,导丝技术9/24。
- 既往培训、经验和培训水平与任何技术的完成时间无关系。
临床怎么用
- 临床可优先选择直接气管导管技术或Aintree技术进行声门上气道向带套囊气管导管的转换。
- 避免使用导丝技术。
局限性
- 研究在尸体上进行,结果可能不能完全推广至临床。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
After rescuing an airway with a supraglottic airway device, a method to convert it to a cuffed tracheal tube is often needed. The best method to do this has never been directly studied. We compared three techniques for conversion of a standard LMA® Unique airway to a cuffed endotracheal tube using a fibrescope. The primary endpoint was time to intubation, with secondary endpoints of success rate, perceived difficulty and preferred technique. We also investigated the relationship between level of training and prior training and experience with the techniques on the primary outcome. The mean (95% CI) time to intubation using a direct tracheal tube technique of 37 (31-42) s was significantly shorter than either the Aintree intubation catheter technique at 70 (60-80) s, or a guidewire technique at 126 (110-141) s (p < 0.001). Most (13/24) participants rated the tracheal tube as their preferred technique, while 11/24 preferred the Aintree technique. In terms of perceived difficulty, 23/24, 21/24 and 9/24 participants rated the tracheal tube technique, Aintree technique and guidewire technique, respectively, as either very easy or easy. There was no relationship between prior training, prior experience or level of training on time to completion of any of the techniques. We conclude the tracheal tube and Aintree techniques both provide a rapid and easy method for conversion of a supraglottic airway device to a cuffed tracheal tube. The guidewire technique cannot be recommended.
引用
- Olesnicky BL, Rehak A, Bestic WB, et al. A cadaver study comparing three fibreoptic-assisted techniques for converting a supraglottic airway to a cuffed tracheal tube. Anaesthesia. 2016. PMID: 27861696. doi:10.1111/anae.13733
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。