三种无通道视频喉镜与Macintosh喉镜在模拟困难气道中的随机对照试验
这项前瞻性随机对照试验纳入480例患者,用颈托模拟困难气道,比较三种无通道视频喉镜(KingVision、Airtraq、A.P. Advance MAC)与Macintosh喉镜的插管表现。首次插管成功率分别为KingVision 90%、Airtraq 82%、A.P. Advance MAC 49%、Macintosh 44%(p < 0.001)。KingVision和Airtraq在总体成功率、声门视野、插管困难评分及视野质量方面均优于A.P. Advance MAC和Macintosh喉镜。
要点
- 模拟困难气道下KingVision和Airtraq首次插管成功率优于A.P. Advance MAC和Macintosh喉镜。
- 所有器械首次插管成功率的95%CI均低于90%。
- 导管推进困难是插管失败的常见原因。
核心结论
- 在颈托模拟困难气道患者中,KingVision和Airtraq的表现优于A.P. Advance MAC和Macintosh喉镜。
- 无通道KingVision和Airtraq的成功率与既往报道的其有通道版本相似,提示性能主要取决于镜片设计而非是否有引导通道。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性随机对照试验,经伦理委员会批准并获书面知情同意,纳入480例患者。
- 用颈托限制张口和颈部活动以模拟困难气道。
- 主要结局为首次经口插管成功率,次要结局包括总体成功率、声门视野、插管困难评分、操控性、插管时间及副作用。
主要发现
- 首次插管成功率:KingVision 90%(95%CI 83-94%),Airtraq 82%(95%CI 74-88%),A.P. Advance MAC 49%(95%CI 40-58%),Macintosh 44%(95%CI 35-53%),p < 0.001。
- 所有器械首次插管成功率的95%CI均低于90%。
- KingVision和Airtraq在总体成功率、声门视野、插管困难评分和视野质量方面表现更好。
- 导管推进困难是插管失败的常见原因。
关键数值与推荐
- 首次插管成功率:KingVision 90%(95%CI 83-94%),Airtraq 82%(95%CI 74-88%),A.P. Advance MAC 49%(95%CI 40-58%),Macintosh 44%(95%CI 35-53%),p < 0.001。
临床怎么用
- 在模拟困难气道(颈托限制张口和颈部活动)情况下,可优先考虑KingVision或Airtraq而非A.P. Advance MAC或Macintosh喉镜。
- 插管时应警惕导管推进困难,将其视为插管失败的常见原因。
局限性
- 困难气道为颈托模拟,非真实困难气道患者。
- 所有器械首次插管成功率的95%CI均低于90%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
This prospective randomised, controlled trial compares the performance of three unchannelled videolaryngoscopes (KingVision™ , Airtraq™ , A.P. Advance™ MAC) and the standard Macintosh laryngoscope. With ethics committee approval and written informed consent, 480 patients were included. A difficult airway was created with a cervical collar, limiting mouth opening and neck movement. Primary outcome was first-attempt orotracheal intubation success. Overall success, laryngeal view, intubation difficulty scale, handling, intubation times and side-effects were secondary outcomes. First-attempt success rates were: KingVision 90% (95% CI 83-94%), Airtraq 82% (74-88%), A.P. Advance MAC 49% (40-58%), Macintosh 44% (35-53%; p < 0.001). The 95% confidence interval of first-attempt success rate was thus below 90% for all devices, but the KingVision and the Airtraq performed better than the A.P. Advance MAC and the Macintosh laryngoscope. Also, performance was better with the KingVision and the Airtraq in terms of overall success, laryngeal view, intubation difficulty scale and quality of view. Problems with tube advancement were a frequent cause of intubation failure. In summary, the KingVision and the Airtraq performed better than the A.P. Advance MAC and the Macintosh laryngoscope. Success rates of the unchannelled KingVision and Airtraq were similar to those of their channelled versions reported previously, indicating that performance largely depends on blade design rather than the presence of a channel for tube advancement.
引用
- Kleine-Brueggeney M, Buttenberg M, Greif R, et al. Evaluation of three unchannelled videolaryngoscopes and the Macintosh laryngoscope in patients with a simulated difficult airway: a randomised, controlled trial. Anaesthesia. 2016. PMID: 27882535. doi:10.1111/anae.13714
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。