患者自填式术前网络麻醉评估问卷(ePAQ PreOperative)的开发与验证
研究在英国三级教学医院开发并验证了一种用于术前麻醉评估的电子问卷(ePAQ PreOperative)。内容效度在30例患者中评估,问卷修改后由另外300例患者完成,评估条目信度及BMI和ASA分级的评分算法。结果显示患者接受度高,数据可靠,其ASA和BMI评分系统与临床医生赋值相当。
要点
- 77%患者认为ePAQ有助于沟通,99%认为易于完成,98%愿意再次使用。
- ePAQ术前分配的ASA分级与顾问医生分级匹配的频率高于护士分级。
- 自报BMI分类正确率78%,另有21%在相邻一个WHO分类内。
核心结论
- 初步评估表明患者对ePAQ接受度高,系统采集的数据可靠,其内在的ASA和BMI评分系统与临床医生赋值相当。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为问卷开发与验证研究,内容效度和表面效度在30例患者中评估,问卷修改后由另外300例患者完成以评估条目信度和BMI及ASA评分算法。
- 共纳入330例18岁及以上、列为手术且能阅读和理解英语的患者,来自神经外科、耳鼻喉科、骨科、妇科、普外科和整形外科、眼科和泌尿外科。
- 研究于2011年1月至2012年2月在英国一家三级教学医院进行,获South Yorkshire Regional Ethics Committee批准(REC 09/H1308/127),由Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust慈善受托人研究基金资助。
主要发现
- 77%患者报告ePAQ有助于沟通,99%报告易于完成,98%报告愿意再次使用。
- ePAQ术前分配的ASA分级与顾问医生分配的ASA分级匹配的频率高于护士分配的ASA分级。
- 自报BMI分类在78%患者中正确,另有21%在一个WHO分类范围内。
- 重测信度良好。
临床怎么用
- ePAQ PreOperative可用于术前麻醉评估,患者自填电子问卷数据可靠,其ASA和BMI评分可作为临床评估的参考。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Worldwide, guidelines support the routine use of anaesthetic preoperative assessment (POA), a process that is frequently supported by pro formas and unvalidated questionnaires. Electronic questionnaires can provide reliable data. A local initiative has seen the development of a computerised electronic Personal Assessment Questionnaire (ePAQ). OBJECTIVE: To develop and validate a novel electronic instrument for POA. DESIGN: The content and face validity were evaluated in 30 patients. The questionnaire was then modified and completed by a further 300 patients, evaluating the reliability of its items and scoring algorithms for BMI and American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) physical status. The study was approved by the South Yorkshire Regional Ethics Committee (REC 09/H1308/127). SETTING: The study was conducted in a tertiary teaching hospital in the United Kingdom between January 2011 and February 2012 and was funded by a research grant from the Charitable Trustees of Sheffield Teaching Hospitals National Health Service Foundation Trust. PATIENTS: A total of 330 patients aged 18 years or older, listed for surgery and able to read and understand English, were recruited. Neurosurgery; ear, nose and throat; orthopaedics; gynaecology; general and plastic surgery; ophthalmology and urology patients were included. All participants provided written consent. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Validation including test-retest analysis, assessment of patient value and burden, assessment of accuracy, mean score difference of BMI estimation and comparison of inter-rater ASA grading. RESULTS: In all, 77% of patients reported that the ePAQ helped with communication, 99% that it was easy to complete and 98% that they would be happy to use it again. ePAQ preoperative assigned ASA grades matched consultant-assigned grades more frequently than nurse-assigned grades. Self-reported BMI classification was correct in 78% of patients and within one WHO category in a further 21%. Test-retest scores were good. CONCLUSION: Initial evaluation suggests that ePAQ is acceptable to patients. Data collected using the system were found to be reliable, and its intrinsic scoring systems for ASA and BMI are comparable with values assigned by clinicians.
引用
- Goodhart IM, Andrzejowski JC, Jones GL, et al. Patient-completed, preoperative web-based anaesthetic assessment questionnaire (electronic Personal Assessment Questionnaire PreOperative): Development and validation. Eur J Anaesthesiol. 2017. PMID: 27798453. doi:10.1097/EJA.0000000000000545
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。