关节置换区域麻醉试验的性别、种族和民族报告:已发表文献与ClinicalTrials.gov数据的系统综述
该系统综述检索了2015至2025年发表的美国区域麻醉用于全关节置换术的随机对照试验,最终纳入29项RCT共2914名参与者,比较了期刊文章与ClinicalTrials.gov注册信息中性别、种族和民族的报告情况。结果显示性别报告较普遍(期刊96.6%),而种族(48.3%)和民族(17.2%)报告不足,且报告与否与试验特征无显著关联。
要点
- 区域麻醉关节置换RCT中性别报告率高达96.6%,但种族和民族报告率分别仅为48.3%和17.2%。
- ClinicalTrials.gov注册信息中性别、种族和民族的报告率分别为75.9%、41.4%和24.1%,与期刊文章存在不一致。
- 报告种族的研究中,White参与者占78.5%,Black占18.6%,其他种族比例极低。
核心结论
- 在美国区域麻醉关节置换RCT中,性别报告一致,但种族和民族报告不频繁,且不同试验特征间无差异,提示该领域存在更广泛的问题。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索AACT数据库纳入2015至2025年发表的美国区域麻醉全关节置换术RCT,最终分析29项RCT共2914名参与者。
主要发现
- 29篇期刊文章中,28篇(96.6%)报告性别,14篇(48.3%)报告种族,5篇(17.2%)报告民族。
- 报告种族的研究中,1068名(78.5%)为White,253名(18.6%)为Black,30名(2.2%)为其他,6名(0.4%)为Asian or Pacific Islander,1名(0.07%)为Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander。
- ClinicalTrials.gov数据中,22项(75.9%)报告性别,12项(41.4%)报告种族,7项(24.1%)报告民族。
- 比较报告与未报告种族、民族或性别的研究,试验特征无统计学显著关联(Fisher精确检验)。
临床怎么用
- 临床解读区域麻醉关节置换RCT结果时,需注意种族和民族数据报告不足可能限制结果的外推性。
局限性
- 仅纳入美国注册且发表的英文RCT,排除会议摘要、重复发表和非同行评议报告,可能限制结论的普遍性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Regional anesthesia provides significant perioperative benefits, including improved pain control and reduced opioid consumption. Clinical trial evidence underpins anesthetic practice, yet inadequate demographic representation and reporting may limit the ability to likely evaluate findings and perpetuate inequities. This systematic review assessed the reporting of race, ethnicity, and sex in randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of regional anesthesia for total joint arthroplasty (TJA). The Aggregate Analysis of Clinical Trials (AACT) database was searched for US-based interventional RCTs of regional anesthesia for TJA published from 2015 to 2025. Trials were required to be registered and published in English. Exclusion criteria included conference abstracts, duplicate publications, and non-peer-reviewed reports. Data on trial characteristics, sample size, interventions, and participant demographics were compared from published articles and ClinicalTrials.gov. The primary outcome was reporting of participant sex, race, and ethnicity in publications and registry entries. Secondary outcomes included demographic distributions across racial and ethnic groups and associations between reporting and study characteristics (funding source, year of publication, center type, US region, sample size) using Fisher's exact test. Twenty-nine RCTs were included in the final analysis, representing 2914 participants. Of 29 journal articles, 28 studies (96.6%) reported sex, 14 (48.3%) reported race, and five (17.2%) reported ethnicity in the published journal articles. Among studies reporting race, 1068 (78.5%) participants identified as White, 253 (18.6%) as Black, 30 (2.2%) as other, 6 (0.4%) as Asian or Pacific Islander, and one (0.07%) as Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander. Conversely, the data from ClinicalTrials.gov reveals that of the same 29 studies, 22 (75.9%) reported sex, 12 (41.4%) reported race, and seven (24.1%) reported ethnicity. Trial characteristics did not show statistically significant associations when comparing studies that did versus did not report race, ethnicity, or sex. In this review of demographic reporting of US-based regional anesthesia RCTs for TJA, sex was consistently reported, whereas race and ethnicity were infrequently captured. The lack of difference in reporting practices across various trial characteristics points toward a broader issue within the field of regional anesthesia for TJA. Notable inconsistencies in demographic reporting on ClinicalTrials.gov were also observed. The absence of standardized demographic reporting underscores the need for journals to mandate consistent reporting practices in clinical research. Efforts to recruit more diverse study populations are essential to enhance the applicability of trial results and to address ongoing inequities in access to care and patient outcomes following TJA.
引用
- Umeh UO, Rowe J, Thor P, et al. Sex, Racial, and Ethnic Reporting in Regional Anesthesia Trials for Joint Arthroplasty: A Systematic Review of Published Versus ClinicalTrials.gov Data. Anesth Analg. 2026. PMID: 42868023. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000008378
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。