超越手术特异性方案:一项系统综述识别ERAS学会指南中普适的麻醉学核心
该研究系统检索ERAS学会指南,通过德尔菲共识建立45个麻醉学总括术语分类,两名评价者独立提取推荐意见及强度,并采用AGREE II评估方法学质量。共纳入24部指南(2013–2025),识别出8个一致、10个基本一致、16个混合和11个稀疏的麻醉学域;平均AGREE II评分为76%。结论认为尽管手术类型异质,ERAS指南中存在一致的麻醉学核心。
要点
- ERAS指南中存在跨手术类型的麻醉学核心,一致域包括多模式镇痛、禁食、血栓预防、抗菌预防、营养、体温和液体管理及手术特异性推荐。
- 高频但证据强度混合的域(液体管理、术前碳水化合物、麻醉前用药)需本地结构化评估。
- AGREE II平均评分76%,利益相关者参与域得分最低。
核心结论
- 尽管手术类型异质,ERAS指南中可识别出一致的麻醉学核心。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,纳入24部ERAS学会指南(2013–2025),通过试点提取和德尔菲共识建立45个麻醉学总括术语分类,两名评价者独立提取推荐及强度,采用AGREE II评估方法学质量。
主要发现
- 24部指南中23部可识别麻醉学参与;45个总括术语中8个一致、10个基本一致、16个混合、11个稀疏。
- 一致域为:多模式镇痛、禁食、血栓预防、抗菌预防、营养、体温和液体管理及手术特异性推荐。
- 平均AGREE II评分为76%,范围和目的及表述清晰性得分最高,利益相关者参与得分最低。
关键数值与推荐
- 一致性分类阈值:一致>80%,基本一致60–80%,混合20–60%,稀疏≤20%。
- 平均AGREE II评分为76%。
临床怎么用
- 跨指南一致性可识别跨专科实施的优先域,推荐强度独立反映指南向本地实践转化的信心。
- 对高频、混合强度的域(液体管理、术前碳水化合物给药、麻醉前用药)应进行结构化本地评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS) Society guidelines provide procedure-specific, evidence-based recommendations for perioperative care. Many interventions fall within anaesthesiology, yet the extent to which they reflect cross-speciality principles remains unclear. The objective of this systematic review was to identify a universal anaesthesiological core across ERAS guidelines. METHODS: All ERAS Society guidelines were screened for eligibility. Guidelines were excluded if they had no practical anaesthesiological recommendations, had been superseded, or were not intended for standard hospital settings. A classification of 45 anaesthesiological umbrella terms was developed through pilot extraction and Delphi consensus. Two reviewers independently extracted recommendations and their strength. Methodological quality was assessed using Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II (AGREE II). Umbrella terms were classified as consistent (>80%), mostly consistent (60-80%), mixed (20-60%), or sparse (≤20%). RESULTS: Of 39 publications, 24 guidelines (2013-2025) were included. Anaesthesiological involvement was identifiable in 23 out of 24 guidelines. Of the 45 umbrella terms, eight were consistent, 10 mostly consistent, 16 mixed, and 11 sparse. The consistent domains were: multimodal analgesia, fasting, thromboprophylaxis, antimicrobial prophylaxis, nutrition, temperature and fluid management, and surgery-specific recommendations. The mean AGREE II score was 76%, highest for scope and purpose and clarity of presentation and lowest for stakeholder involvement. CONCLUSIONS: Despite procedural heterogeneity, a consistent anaesthesiological core is identifiable within the ERAS guidelines. Cross-guideline consistency identifies the priority domains for cross-speciality implementation, whereas recommendation strength independently indicates the confidence with which guidance transposes onto local practice; high-frequency, mixed-strength domains, notably fluid management, preoperative carbohydrate administration and preanaesthetic medication, warrant structured local appraisal. REGISTRATION: The study protocol: Open Science Framework (DOI: 10.17605/OSF.IO/CBWDT).
引用
- Bornemann-Cimenti H, Furtmüller JM, Labenbacher S, et al. Beyond procedure-specific protocols: a systematic review identifying a universal anaesthesiological core across Enhanced Recovery After Surgery Society guidelines. Br J Anaesth. 2026. PMID: 42469102. doi:10.1016/j.bja.2026.06.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。