麻醉临床试验中估计目标的定义:范围综述与框架
该范围综述纳入2020年1月至2024年6月十本高影响力期刊中≥100例受试者的139项麻醉随机对照试验,发现无一项明确使用估计目标框架,仅27项(19%)可推断估计目标;据此开发了链接伴发事件与干预-结局组合的结构化网络工具。
要点
- 麻醉试验中估计目标框架使用有限,仅19%试验可推断估计目标。
- 最常见伴发事件为未接受随机干预(46%)、治疗中断(27%)和治疗转换(19%)。
- 开发了结构化网络工具,辅助识别和处理麻醉试验中的伴发事件。
核心结论
- 麻醉随机对照试验中估计目标框架的应用有限,需统计学家与临床医生加强合作以提升未来研究的清晰度和可解释性。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,纳入2020年1月至2024年6月十本高影响力期刊中≥100例受试者的139项麻醉随机对照试验。
主要发现
- 139项试验中无一项明确使用估计目标框架,仅27项(19%)可推断估计目标。
- 目标人群可推断44项(32%),治疗条件21项(15%),汇总指标22项(16%),伴发事件处理84项(60%)。
- 最常见伴发事件为未接受随机干预64项(46%)、治疗中断38项(27%)、治疗转换27项(19%)。
- 麻醉相关伴发事件包括手术取消37项(27%)和非方案化麻醉管理17项(12%)。
临床怎么用
- 麻醉临床试验应结构化识别伴发事件并明确估计目标,以提升结果解释的清晰度。
- 可使用所开发的结构化交互式网络工具,将伴发事件映射到干预-结局组合。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Intercurrent events, such as treatment switching and rescue medication, commonly occur in anaesthesia trials, and can affect the occurrence or interpretation of primary outcomes. The estimand framework provides strategies for handling these events, aligning trial objectives with outcomes. METHODS: We conducted a scoping review of RCTs with ≥100 participants published from January 2020 to June 2024 in ten high-impact journals, including patients receiving anaesthesia before surgery. We examined whether estimands were reported and identified intercurrent events. A structured framework was developed by mapping intercurrent events to intervention-outcome combinations investigated across all included anaesthesia trials. RESULTS: Among 139 included trials, none explicitly used the estimand framework, and an estimand could be inferred in only 27 (19%). The primary outcome was defined in all trials, while other attributes were often not inferable: target population (44 [32%]), treatment condition (21 [15%]), summary measure (22 [16%]) and intercurrent event handling (84 [60%]). The most common intercurrent events were not receiving the randomised intervention (64 [46%]), treatment discontinuation (38 [27%]), and treatment switching (27 [19%]). Anaesthesia-related intercurrent events included surgery cancellation (37 [27%]) and non-protocolised anaesthesia management (17 [12%]). Findings informed the development of a structured, interactive web-based tool linking intercurrent events to intervention-outcome combinations, refined by expert review. CONCLUSIONS: Use of estimands in anaesthesia trials is limited. Our tool supports structured identification and handling of intercurrent events in anaesthesia trials. Greater collaboration between statisticians and clinicians, with consistent application of the estimand framework, is needed to improve clarity and interpretability of future anaesthesia research.
引用
- Siriwardena GA, Luu S, Gunaratne RK, et al. Defining estimands in anaesthesia clinical trials: a scoping review and framework. Br J Anaesth. 2026. PMID: 42014230. doi:10.1016/j.bja.2026.03.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。