麻醉学脑电图教育共识:学习成果定义的四轮改良Delphi研究
通过四轮改良Delphi研究,33名国际麻醉学专家就脑电图教育的学习成果达成共识,191项中58项获得共识。共识条目涵盖脑电图基础、原始脑电图、麻醉影响、处理脑电图、伪差、伤害性感受、患者变异性、与麻醉管理整合、临床实践和持续专业学习等维度。基础维度的一致性高于高级或新兴领域。
要点
- 共识定义了58项脑电图学习成果,涵盖基础和高级培训。
- 基础维度(如脑电图基础、原始脑电图)一致性高于高级或新兴领域。
- 框架支持结构化课程开发,以提升麻醉实践中的脑电图能力。
核心结论
- Delphi共识为麻醉学教育定义了全面的脑电图学习成果框架,支持结构化课程开发,反映麻醉实践中对脑电图能力的需求增长。
主要发现
- 191项学习成果中58项达成共识,涵盖基础和高级脑电图培训水平。
- 共识条目分组维度包括脑电图基础、原始脑电图、麻醉影响、处理脑电图、伪差、伤害性感受、患者变异性、与麻醉管理整合、临床实践和持续专业学习。
- 基础维度的一致性高于高级或新兴领域,如神经反馈或药物基因组学。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识定义为前3轮在10点Likert量表上至少80%同意(评分9或10),第4轮二元是/否回答至少80%同意。
临床怎么用
- 框架可用于开发基础和高级脑电图培训的结构化课程,以提升麻醉实践中的患者监测和安全性。
局限性
- 需要在教育和临床环境中验证这些学习成果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The brain is the primary target of general anaesthesia, yet routine brain monitoring remains underutilised. Although electroencephalography (EEG) is increasingly recognised as an important tool for assessing brain states during anaesthesia, inconsistent training and over-reliance on processed indices have hindered its adoption in clinical practice. OBJECTIVES: To define a set of core learning outcomes for EEG education in anaesthesiology through expert consensus, aiming to support the development of a structured, tiered curriculum for both basic and advanced EEG training. DESIGN: Modified four-round Delphi study. SETTING: Multinational, online Delphi panel involving 33 anaesthesiology experts across various academic and clinical institutions. The study was conducted between 29 May 2023 and 28 November 2024. PARTICIPANTS: Thirty-three international anaesthesiology experts with recognised experience in EEG use, teaching and/or research. Experts were purposively sampled to ensure diversity in geography, clinical background, subspecialty focus and broad spectrum of perspectives. INTERVENTIONS: Not applicable. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Consensus on learning outcomes, defined as at least 80% agreement (score of 9 or 10) on a 10-point Likert scale for Rounds 1 to 3, or at least 80% agreement for binary yes/no responses in Round 4. RESULTS: Consensus was achieved for 58 out of 191 learning outcomes across both basic and advanced EEG training levels. Accepted items were grouped into dimensions, including EEG Fundamentals, Raw EEG, Anaesthetic Effects, Processed EEG, Artefacts, Nociception, Patient Variability, Integration with Anaesthetic Management, Clinical Immersion and Continuous Professional Learning. Foundational dimensions had higher agreement than advanced or emerging areas, such as neurofeedback or pharmacogenomics. CONCLUSIONS: This Delphi consensus defines a comprehensive framework of EEG learning outcomes for anaesthesiology education. The framework supports the development of structured curricula and reflects a growing need for EEG competence in anaesthesia practice to improve patient monitoring and safety. Further research is needed to validate the outcomes in educational and clinical settings.
引用
- Berger-Estilita J, Baron Shahaf D, Barreto Chang OL, et al. Consensus document on electroencephalography education in anaesthesiology: defining learning outcomes: A modified four-round Delphi study. Eur J Anaesthesiol. 2026. PMID: 41709666. doi:10.1097/EJA.0000000000002346
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。